Toon or Stills
 

Ok this might go under fantasy but I think I will get more input here.

We have an auction keeper draft tomorrow. I have already spent a wad of my money. But I am set at QB (Brees), RB (Ridley & Gore) & Defense with Seattle.
I need WR I know I will need to spend to get a good one but late I the draft when. Dollar daze sets in....

Who would you see as the better player....

Stills

Or

Toon

(Why?)

Thanks. :bng:

Re: Toon or Stills
 

About the same honestly. Being the 5th/6th option on the team, I expect them to both hover around the 40 reception mark. With Toon being larger in size, I'd give him a slighter edge as one would think he'd get more opportunities in the red zone.

This will go to the Fantasy board but I will leave a re-direct on the main board so you can get more feedback.

Re: Toon or Stills
 

Id go with Stills.
I think he sees more playing time though i think Toon has the better long term career.

Re: Toon or Stills
 

I wouldn't go with either one, personally. The ball gets spread around too much in this offense to consider anyone other than Brees or Graham as a sure thing. Anyone else, especially the third and fourth receiver, is a total shot in the dark.

Re: Toon or Stills
 

Never draft a Saint Receiver not named Graham; they're too up and down week to week...

But if you need a crap shoot fill-in for a couple of weeks, you definitely grab an available Saint WR...

Re: Toon or Stills
 

Tough call. I'd go with Toon. big target and he plays faster than what the paper says.