John Karney
 

We have a Kicker who misses etra points and get kicks blocked... Lets cut him now.

RE: John Karney
 

okay, i'm with you on that. Bring back the guy we had in preseason.

RE: John Karney
 

The entire special teams unit is playing bad. He may not miss so much if he has better blocking and a better snapper. However, he is getting old.

RE: John Karney
 

I agree, this guy ruined one of the greatest plays of all time (Jacksonville) by missing the freakin EP. He misses way too many short kicks. He sucks. And he's ugly.
And it's Carney, but hey whatever

RE: John Karney
 

Is it just my perception, or did he seem like "Mr. Automatic" up until they replaced the turf in the dome?
He is getting old, but I think that the new turf really had a bad effect on his game. Old dog- new trick situation?
Whatever the cause, he's not what he used to be, I think he needs to go.

Re: John Karney
 

Are you really making a post about cutting one player, when you run around here defending another one til no end with a "the team sucks, changing one player isn't the answer" argument? Seriously? H-Y-P-O-C-R-............

RE: Re: John Karney
 

Euphoria,...............what?????

Whodis got you there man. Like you have said all over this site, and I do happen to agree with you; one person will not change this team. Besides it can't be that hard to find a place kicker.

Re: RE: John Karney
 

This is what I was going for... Doesn't matter that the kicker is bad... the whole unit is sucking... this is the post I was trying to get and yall couldn't even read it... you don't get it not even here do you? It doesn't matter Brooks is having a bad year the whole unit sucks. You can't really worry to much about the K ability if your linemen can't block for diddly poo.

This is so dumb, it almost defies logic. My man, you need a clue.

It absolutely does matter. What world are you living in where it wouldn't matter? If the kicker is bad, saying everyone else is bad DOES NOT EXCUSE HIM. If he is bad, he needs to go, just like the QB. AB's CAREER numbers, gaffes, etc. prove he is bad. Not just this year, pretty much every year. Carney has proven he is bad, he needs to go.

What is this year 5 of a bad year? Is your next statement, doesn't matter if he is having a bad half a decade? Ab has never been "good." Even in his "career year" he fumbled so much noone noticed his numbers. Average is the best he has achieved. Just like Carney, if he is bad, which he is, he needs to go. Trying to throw blame to tohers doesn't change that. You fix it all. We have changed our o-line a lot in 5 years, and AB has been mediocr enomatter who has been around him.

Giants should cut Eli after his last weeks performance.

Carney, Brooks, Deuce, and Horn are all gone at the end of you year?