New Orleans Saints Forums - blackandgold.com

New Orleans Saints Forums - blackandgold.com (https://blackandgold.com/community/)
-   Saints (https://blackandgold.com/saints/)
-   -   Medical Doctor questions Drew's ability to recover from MCL injury (https://blackandgold.com/saints/32198-medical-doctor-questions-drews-ability-recover-mcl-injury.html)

TheEnigma 01-26-2011 03:48 PM

Medical Doctor questions Drew's ability to recover from MCL injury
 
As a biological scientist who has extensively studied the human body with regards to diseases, injuries and patterns of recovery, the recent announcement by New Orleans Saints Quarterback, Drew Brees(notes), that he played the entire football season with a sprained MCL has made me question his ability to fully recover from it.

Drew Brees playing with an MCL sprain: A medical view - NFL - Yahoo! Sports

AsylumGuido 01-26-2011 03:55 PM

What a quack. Brees sees Dr. James Andrews who is a REAL medical doctor that has dealt with these injuries for many years. I'm sure he has a better grasp of things than this wanna-be.

AsylumGuido 01-26-2011 04:01 PM

Here's what this "doctor" has in her bio:

Halina Zakowicz

I am employed in the biotechnology field. I am also an affiliate marketer, freelance writer, and SEO/SMO specialist. I am building a Web site and blog called Your Money and Debt, which provides readers with financial advice and money-making tips.

Yes, she has a PhD so she is technically a doctor, but not in medicine.

Education/Experience

Western Illinois University, B.S., Microbiology, George Washington University, Ph.D., genetics

dizzle88 01-26-2011 04:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AsylumGuido (Post 282660)
What a quack. Brees sees Dr. James Andrews who is a REAL medical doctor that has dealt with these injuries for many years. I'm sure he has a better grasp of things than this wanna-be.

This!

If a real doctor like Dr. James Andrews can fully reconstruct a shoulder and then have that shoulder being pushed to the limit every day, i don't think an MCL sprain that most likely has already recovered giving drew any problems.

Seems like everyone calls themselves doctors these days if they wear a white coat.

WVSaint 01-26-2011 04:51 PM

they didnt think he'd come back from the shoulder injury either.

skymike 01-26-2011 05:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AsylumGuido (Post 282661)
Here's what this "doctor" has in her bio:

Halina Zakowicz

I am employed in the biotechnology field. I am also an affiliate marketer, freelance writer, and SEO/SMO specialist, snake oil salesman, and attention whore. I am building a Web site and blog called Your Money and Debt, which provides readers with financial advice and money-making tips. I also have an exercise gadget (the snake-weight) and video available for 19.99 for this amazing tv offer. You just insert the snake-weight right here, and start pumping for an exhilirating, calorie burning, sensuous workout. Lube not included.

Yes, she has a PhD so she is technically a doctor, but not in medicine.

Education/Experience

Western Illinois University, B.S., Microbiology, George Washington University, Ph.D., genetics, orthopedic medicine? Oops, I forgot to study orthopedic medicine before I start writing Yahoo columns about sports injuries.

The real question is why does yahoo print this crap?

SAINT_MICHAEL 01-26-2011 05:55 PM

Indeed what a joke. Why would someone even risk their "reputation" by writing this. No background in the field she is commenting on whatsoever. It's too bad that no ramifications will come of this pathetic article. I say we keep her link information and around week 13 or so of next football season, we pull it out again and ask her how she thinks his recovery has gone so far.

neugey 01-26-2011 06:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by skymike (Post 282688)
The real question is why does yahoo print this crap?

Yahoo has been writing some pretty shaky, poorly thought out stories in order to increase their visitors and hits. Many of these have little journalistic substance and are just glorified blog posts in disguise. As a Yahoo mail user, I've noticed this increase over the last year or so.

foreverfan 01-26-2011 06:21 PM

Quit making fun of Yahoo. I'm thinking about applying for a job with them.

CheramieIII 01-26-2011 06:22 PM

and if I punch this dumbarse in the face I question my ability to get my fist out!

RaginCajun83 01-26-2011 06:56 PM

Who dare question the healing powers of Drew Brees? This guy is an idiot

st thomas 01-26-2011 07:22 PM

please blow-up this thread.

Speedy Ron 01-27-2011 08:00 AM

one of the stupidest things i have ever heard. how do you question it after the fact?!?!? what a loser. where was this article or this expertise opinion when he originally hurt it. like someone else said...they thought he wouldnt even been able to throw the ball again. and recover?!?!?! this happened months ago and he played the rest of the year and if we had a rb and our d show up in seattle we would be in the superbowl. with a one legged brees. the writer can take this article and shove it up their @$$.

skymike 01-27-2011 06:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by foreverfan (Post 282697)
Quit making fun of Yahoo. I'm thinking about applying for a job with them.

I guarantee you have enough journalistic credentials for them to hire you now.

Beastmode 01-27-2011 06:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WVSaint (Post 282671)
they didnt think he'd come back from the shoulder injury either.

Exactly. Everyone heals different. That shoulder injury would have ended many QB careers. You just never really know how someone's body will react. My arm was broke in half and elbow completley crushed in a suicide attack. Six months later the bones were completely healed and I was doing pushups.

Granted I did lose some minor dexterity but the doctors were amazed. I ate a very good diet and never missing PT but it's still uncommon for someoe to heal that quick. Not to get off on a tangent but one thing I have always noticed is that my nails grow fast and super hard even boefore the accident. NOt sure if that means anything but other than that wound I have never been inuried without a quick recovery.

st thomas 01-27-2011 09:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Beastmode (Post 282877)
Exactly. Everyone heals different. That shoulder injury would have ended many QB careers. You just never really know how someone's body will react. My arm was broke in half and elbow completley crushed in a suicide attack. Six months later the bones were completely healed and I was doing pushups.

Granted I did lose some minor dexterity but the doctors were amazed. I ate a very good diet and never missing PT but it's still uncommon for someoe to heal that quick. Not to get off on a tangent but one thing I have always noticed is that my nails grow fast and super hard even boefore the accident. NOt sure if that means anything but other than that wound I have never been inuried without a quick recovery.

CAN'T THANK-YOU ENOUGH BEAST FOR GIVING YOUR BODY UP FOR US TO BE SAFER, U DA MAN.

MatthewT 01-28-2011 01:44 AM

In theory the article is probably dead on. Where it loses credibility is this person is not Drew's doctor and really has no clue on what was going on. I can guarantee if Drew's doctor would have said to shut it down for a while, he would have done so. Obviously the situation with Drew wasn't very serious. He did take protective measures and wore a brace. With the Saints having probably another few years at a legitimate Super Bowl run, I don't believe anyone would have risked running him out on the field if there was a decent chance of this injury getting worse.

WVSaint 01-28-2011 05:42 PM

if anyone read drew's book, you get some insight on how the guy takes care of his body. one part of the book that really stood out to me was drew talking about food allergies. his nutritionist told him about food allergies that dont always show up. apparently we are all allergic to foods, but dont ever know about it or have any symptoms because our blood cells fight it off before anything can show. still while those cells are working to fight what we might have just eaten, they could have been working at other things in the body, like healing tissue or other injuries. who would think to get checked for such a thing? drew would.

moral of the story is no one should ever bet against that guy.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:24 PM.


Copyright 1997 - 2020 - BlackandGold.com