Should the Colts have traded.......
 

Peyton Manning for Jake Delhomme? I think Dungy made a big mistake keeping Manning and not signing Delhomme. Peyton chokes in the playoffs every year and this year was no different.

Jake is CLEARLY a better decision maker when under pressure. Well, maybe the Colts have learned their lesson about Peyton Manning. And to think, some folks actually want Eli Manning. I guess if you are willing to wait 10-years on a Manning to come through, that it would be a good choice.

Should the Colts have traded.......
 

You\'re absolutely correct, if you use Delhommite logic.

That logic also states that our Saints should ...
Trade Brooks for Delhomme
Trade Deuce for Steven Davis (or DeShaun Foster)
Trade Horn and Stallworth for Smith and MuhHammed.
After all, they\'re going to the Superbowl and Brooks, Deuce, Horn and Stallworth are sitting at home.

Should the Colts have traded.......
 

Now fellas, that\'s not what the Delhomme-ites are saying. Oh, Wait, yes it is. That\'s EXACTLY what they\'re saying.

Think about it. Is there really any doubt that Peyton is a better (read smarter) QB than either Brady or Delhomme? Is Fox a better coach than Andy Reid? If one follows the \"logic\" (loosly defined here) of some posters than one must say that...

No, Peyton is not a better (smarter) QB than either Brady or Delhomme

and

Yes, Fox is CLEARLY a better coach than Reid

...and to think I am often accused of not being original here. Well folks, the above is original...or is it? Am I polorizing the argument? Depends on whom ya ask. :P

Should the Colts have traded.......
 

This is clearly a completely antagonistic thread. Now why do you want to start this again? Don\'t you already have enough threads discussing this subject? Get on to something constructive please!