Yet another QB discussion...
 

Anybody think Peyton is worth his giant contract that restricts his team to the point where they have to cut 10 players to make cap room just for him?

Yet another QB discussion...
 

Uhhhh, no.

Yet another QB discussion...
 

What a Bledsoe when with the Pats, or Culpepper with the Vikes ??

Yet another QB discussion...
 

How hard is it for the Colts? Leave him franchised and save more money than a new deal would cost.

Yet another QB discussion...
 

WhoDat....the point is, he is worth whatever someone is willing to pay him.

Yet another QB discussion...
 

Heck if someone wants to franchise tag me and pay me 18 million so be it... Manning has had nothing to say about it thus far and don\'t blame him either... CO-MVP, I\'d say he deserves it.

Would I re-negoticate my contrat in hopes to win a tittle sure but figure how much power manning has in who they bring in... if he doesn\'t like whom they are trying to bring in then he can say \'nope, not renegociating\'. But Manning has to make every buck he can and you can\'t blame a guy for that, you can\'t expect a guy to work for nothing???

Yet another QB discussion...
 

Uhhh, no. It costs around $17m to keep him franchised. They could easily drop that number to $11m/year with a long term deal.

Yet another QB discussion...
 

I\'m not blaming Manning. I\'m simply suggesting that MAYBE the Colts could do better by spending that money elsewhere. Manning is undoubtedly important to that team and one of the best QBs in the league... when was the last time a top QB was in the SB again? Anyone, anyone? Beuller? Beuller?

Yet another QB discussion...
 

Agreed..........you mean Aaron Brooks has a fumbling problem?

Yet another QB discussion...
 

The Colts would have had to cut E. James had they kept him franchisen since it would have been an 18.5 hit towards the cap while this deal makes him only 9 against the cap. Saved money, IMO.

Yet another QB discussion...
 

Is Peyton worth it? Nobody is worth the money. But if McNabb is getting $100 million as is Culpepper...why shouldn\'t he? Smartest QB in the game,.

Yet another QB discussion...
 

if they franchise him... its average of best 5 at that position and its only for a year and they will have the same problem next year and could be worse if someone else they don\'t want to let go next year to use the tag on them. Tagging manning also lets someone else come in and pick him up.