2 superbowls = Elite QB. Plus, he's a Manning.

Yep!

Categorically.

I don't know if he is elite or not, but he has 2 rings and he is tough as he!!, during the 9'ers game he took a lot of shots and got up every time.

He may be elite...but he is the ugliest looking elite qb.(I am not talking about looks) I don't know what it is but his play is not awe inspiring.

I'm not sold on Elite, but its just another opinion.

I guess it depends on the specific criteria for Elite versus Great.

Yeah, I'd call him "Elite".

pretty much answers that question!

Yup

Brady
Brees
Peyton Manning
Eli Manning
Aaron Rodgers

Elite A QB's

Brees
Brady
P Manning
Rodgers

Elite B

Rothleshamburgerler
Stafford (Gonna be in the A catagory..very close)
E Manning
Newton (Lets face it; when you play against him, you worry about him)

Rivers; He is spotty at best. Just when you think you have to worry about him, BAM he blows the game. Then when you count him out, he plays like a mad-man.