Lofton? He was on the list last year .... no way its Vilma, he was injured half the season last yer

There is tunnel vision about RB yardage. If a RB doesn't get the yards rushing then it's frowned upon in any rating system. But I'm fine with it like BM stated. I'd take Sproles over any one dimensional 1500 yd RB anyday.

I don't understand how Darren is at 86. Did the people/players not watch him this year?

Hell I read the thread title and thought Roger was about to fine and suspend another one of our guys...

I thought another player was going to sue Goodell. I think many are waiting in line.

Wonder where Reggie ranks on this list? He did have a big year for Miami and the NFL network is part of the player hype machine........

While I'll give it to him for having had a great year with the Dolphins, he should never be ranked higher than Sproles, but like you said - it might happen because of all the hype surrounding him throughout his career.


I think the player in question is Greer like some have already suggested.