New Orleans Saints Forums - blackandgold.com - WhoDat and Saintfan sound off on Brooks

The only thing I \"get\" WhoDat is that you\'re crawfishing badly. I\'m gald to see your getting tired of tyring to prove a point you\'ll never prove. And I am forced to assume your attacks on Brooks are as much personal as anything simply because your comparisons aren\'t fair and again, by your own admission, you were after his head when the team was 6-1. You\'re attacking the coaches now because you\'ve had to realize that Brooks isn\'t the issue.

And if you\'ll look back at your own posts, you\'ll no doubt read and be forced to realize that you have put far too much blame on Brooks. You refuse to account for the fact that he doesn\'t have the experience some people you\'d like to compare him to have. You\'ve gone so far as to insinuate that Michael Vick is a better QB and you\'ve even reached the depths of attempting to blame Aaron Brooks for shotty blocking. You are far more forgiving when speaking of other QB\'s. Don\'t take my word for it. Look back at your own posts and verify it for yourself.

You ask me if I \"disagree that Delhomme is also a \"young\" and \"capable\" quarterback?\" when time after time after time I have indicated that I see nothing wrong with Jake...that I like Jake...that I thought he should have been given a chance to start before they brought in Jeff Blake. Are you reading what I type in here or not? Go back and find ONE post I made indicating otherwise...just ONE. I can tell you now you won\'t find it. Don\'t waste your time.

The New Orleans Saints are a young team with very talented (but very young) weapons. It is my belief that they are a team still searching to some degree for an identity. You\'re hell bent on this \"West Coast\" thing, but I\'m not so sure what the Saints are trying to do is in its essence really \"West Coast\". Now you can preach to me about how Delhomme is better suited for a \"West Coast\" offense all you\'d like. I might just respond by asking you what happened to Rich Gannon yesterday, in a system you say he\'s so well suited for. How many INT\'s did he throw? Does he get the credit or do you load him up with all the blame? I know one thing for sure, and that\'s that you\'d be screaming for Brooks\' job after a game like the one Gannon played yesterday huh?

Let me finish by saying you\'re awefully adamant about my insisting that Brooks either is now or one day will become a \"great\" QB. I have defended the fact that Aaron is right now a quality NFL QB with the ability to get much better, but I have never indicated that he is now or will ever become a \"great\" QB. I do, however, think he has all the tools to do so. Let me remind you that it does not take a \"great\" QB to win the superbowl. A team that wins the superbowl must have certain intangilbes that cannot come from one man. You already know that tho, don\'t you? You know that if for no other reason than that the QB that won the superbowl yesterday is, by no stretch of your imagination, a \"great\" NFL QB.