He is not even close
 

Not really no. He is not horrible as some would have it but he is not truly elite either.

He's getting better but he's still in the 3rd tier of quarterbacks in my book.

Much as I hate it, Brady is as elite as they come. If he's as good as Brady, then I'm as good as Chipper Jones.

It's funny to read all the comments about him. I don't think that I saw one to agree with him. On a professional level, the cats out of the bag. He is no way near a top QB. A personal level I have never liked the guy, I always thought of him as a little bit**. Sorry Eli, your not anywhere near what you think you are.

Saw this story on Fox News this morning. He didn't say he was as good as Brady, but he did say he believed that he is one of the elite QBs in the league...

I have to agree with you. Sadly, despite their pedigree, I have always
found both Manning football bros. to be quite whiney and finicky,
but Eli is the most ridiculous of the two. They've both got Superbowl
rings, so yay for them, but they are BOTH pouters and tantrum
throwers and to say they act like six year olds is an insult
to six year olds everywhere.

Oh, did I mention arrogant? Yeah, that too.

That boy is tore up from the floor up!

NFL.com news: If you believe you're in Brady's class, you also might believe ...