Saints greatest
 

A Fanatics ad keeps popping up in my feed for a plaque called All time greats it has player cards on it with Drew, Archie, Rickey, Eric M., Horn, Deuce, Dalton, and Marques. All great, but when you say "All-time greats' to me says the best of all, and in that case my list would be different
In no order -
Drew
Rickey
Deuce
Mills
Roaf
Horn
Will Smith
Wayne Martin

anyone else wanna play?

Re: Saints greatest
 

Mort Andersen and Morestead make my list for sure

Re: Saints greatest
 

I seriously considered both as well as Marques

Re: Saints greatest
 

Yes! How is Colston not ahead of Horn?

Re: Saints greatest
 

Marques had some times where he had a LOT of drops, it looked like his confidence was low. I know over all his completion % was better than Joe's and obviously he out did Joe's ultimate yardage but I don't ever remember Joe not being a reliable catcher, and he only had Drew for one year. That's my convoluted logic.

Re: Saints greatest
 

Convoluted is better than none.

Re: Saints greatest
 

Your top 8?

Re: Saints greatest
 

So who gets showed the door?

Re: Saints greatest
 

Who to be Dropped from your list for those guys? That’s tough cause your list is solid. I suppose I’d remove Horn and Will Smith, but with reluctance. I’d rather just add them to yours.

Re: Saints greatest
 

Re: Saints greatest
 

I can't limit it to eight. I wouldn't even try. Number nine would need to be in, then ten, and eleven, twelve, etcetera.

Re: Saints greatest
 

I wish ya'll had asked me before my memory issues set in. I love the big uglies so I'm going with Jhari Evans.

Re: Saints greatest
 

You could make a top 8 of lineman alone 😁

Re: Saints greatest
 

I don’t know if that’s the best or worst thing I’ve ever watched! LOL!

Re: Saints greatest
 

Colston
Kamara
Davis
Brees
Pierre Thomas
Roaf
Jordan
Swilling