New Orleans Saints Forums - blackandgold.com

New Orleans Saints Forums - blackandgold.com (https://blackandgold.com/community/)
-   Saints (https://blackandgold.com/saints/)
-   -   Marcus Davenport Pec Injury, Small School Gems, and Risk (https://blackandgold.com/saints/101001-marcus-davenport-pec-injury-small-school-gems-risk.html)

BakoSaint 09-13-2021 12:20 PM

Marcus Davenport Pec Injury, Small School Gems, and Risk
 
Davenport reportedly has a pec injury and will be out for the season if its a partial or full tear. If its just a strain, he would still be out at least a month and possibly limited all season.

His seeming inability to stay healthy relates to something I have always felt we should consider. We seem to love finding small school gems, even if we have to trade up and draft them early like Davenport. We see a player at an unknown school and realize they have the measurables and athleticism to succeed on a much higher level. But the one thing that playing at a small school can never do is test an athletes durability against players their own size and strength, or let them begin learning how to avoid injury against athletes their own size and strength. It may even create bad habits of relying on size and strength advantage as a crutch resulting in more injuries at the pro level. Its also possible that elite athletes who end up at small programs sometimes do because they themselves are a little nervous about times their knee almost buckled and don't want to risk a big injury for no pay.

If Alex Anzalone had played at UT San Antonio he would have probably looked like a man among boys, never been injured, and we might have identified him as an elite physical talent who was only overlooked due to coming from a small school and traded up to take him in the 1st round. Then it would have hurt a lot more when we found out he was glass.

With Terron Armstead, we got good value in the 3rd round, probably where we should have looked at Davenport because players fall even with hype. But coming from a small school, Armstead has had to make a lot of adjustments to stay on the field.

I am just saying that in the future, when we spend two 1st round picks on a player at a very physically challenging position, lets make sure they had 3-4 years at a real college program to prove they are not made of glass. That means something. You still never know, but the closer the audition is to the big show the more it means, and you can't figure this out with a tape measure or stop watch.

cmike 09-13-2021 12:28 PM

Re: Marcus Davenport Pec Injury, Small School Gems, and Risk
 
Saw this coming when he was sporting that full arm brace.

K Major 09-13-2021 12:40 PM

Re: Marcus Davenport Pec Injury, Small School Gems, and Risk
 
School/competition has very little to do with it. He’s extremely talented. Some players are simply injury prone. See Derwin James, Tyler Eifert and Clowney.

Unfortunately for us, MD can’t seem to stay healthy.

BakoSaint 09-13-2021 12:54 PM

Re: Marcus Davenport Pec Injury, Small School Gems, and Risk
 
I think it does have something to do with it. Say that you are recruiting a police officer with 4 years experience to join military special forces. No matter who you choose, they might not get hurt in action. But if your choice is between a member of the SWAT team who didn't get hurt in 4 years working on the SWAT team versus a mall cop who has amazing measureables in a workout, who do you think is more likely to get hurt out there? SEC vs UT San Antonio is SWAT team vs Mall Cop.

Quote:

Originally Posted by K Major (Post 928194)
School/competition has very little to do with it. He’s extremely talented. Some players are simply injury prone. See Derwin James, Tyler Eifert and Clowney.

Unfortunately for us, MD can’t seem to stay healthy.


Rugby Saint II 09-13-2021 12:59 PM

Re: Marcus Davenport Pec Injury, Small School Gems, and Risk
 
Davenport is snake bit! Poor fella'.:brood:

Boston Saint 09-13-2021 01:11 PM

Re: Marcus Davenport Pec Injury, Small School Gems, and Risk
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BakoSaint (Post 928191)
Davenport reportedly has a pec injury and will be out for the season if its a partial or full tear. If its just a strain, he would still be out at least a month and possibly limited all season.

His seeming inability to stay healthy relates to something I have always felt we should consider. We seem to love finding small school gems, even if we have to trade up and draft them early like Davenport. We see a player at an unknown school and realize they have the measurables and athleticism to succeed on a much higher level. But the one thing that playing at a small school can never do is test an athletes durability against players their own size and strength, or let them begin learning how to avoid injury against athletes their own size and strength. It may even create bad habits of relying on size and strength advantage as a crutch resulting in more injuries at the pro level. Its also possible that elite athletes who end up at small programs sometimes do because they themselves are a little nervous about times their knee almost buckled and don't want to risk a big injury for no pay.

If Alex Anzalone had played at UT San Antonio he would have probably looked like a man among boys, never been injured, and we might have identified him as an elite physical talent who was only overlooked due to coming from a small school and traded up to take him in the 1st round. Then it would have hurt a lot more when we found out he was glass.

With Terron Armstead, we got good value in the 3rd round, probably where we should have looked at Davenport because players fall even with hype. But coming from a small school, Armstead has had to make a lot of adjustments to stay on the field.

I am just saying that in the future, when we spend two 1st round picks on a player at a very physically challenging position, lets make sure they had 3-4 years at a real college program to prove they are not made of glass. That means something. You still never know, but the closer the audition is to the big show the more it means, and you can't figure this out with a tape measure or stop watch.

I’m not gonna say there is no logic to your viewpoint bako. Being Battle tested does have some advantage. I truly feel bad for him. it’s too bad he hasn’t panned out for whatever reasons.

The Dude 09-13-2021 01:58 PM

Re: Marcus Davenport Pec Injury, Small School Gems, and Risk
 
Ashame. He was balling all preseason and he had a major impact in the game. Losing him and possibly Lattimore for a stretch is going to hurt. This has been the toughest offseason/start of season I can remember. If we manage to make the post season Payton should get Coach of the Year hands down.

NewfieSaint 09-13-2021 02:30 PM

Re: Marcus Davenport Pec Injury, Small School Gems, and Risk
 
Looks like it's just a strain as per Rapoport..
Great news.. will still miss time but back sooner rather than later..

AsylumGuido 09-13-2021 02:33 PM

Re: Marcus Davenport Pec Injury, Small School Gems, and Risk
 

AsylumGuido 09-13-2021 02:34 PM

Re: Marcus Davenport Pec Injury, Small School Gems, and Risk
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by The Dude (Post 928204)
Ashame. He was balling all preseason and he had a major impact in the game. Losing him and possibly Lattimore for a stretch is going to hurt. This has been the toughest offseason/start of season I can remember. If we manage to make the post season Payton should get Coach of the Year hands down.

Doom and gloom.

:D


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:54 PM.


Copyright 1997 - 2020 - BlackandGold.com