49er's message board... Enjoy

LongTimeFan · 03-18-2006, 06:01 PM

Well, it looks like Aaron Brooks will be trade-bait now. Based on his success under Mike McCarthy, I think we should make New Orleans an offer. Maybe a 3rd rounder, or a 4th and Dorsey?

I've always liked Aaron Brooks personally, he has a very good arm and would immediately make us better. He would easily be the best QB on our roster, knows the offense already, has great athletic skills and could allow Smith a couple years to develop.

Reply: Im not sure I would want a guy who fails to win the big games... or many games at all!

Reply: I didn't get past the thread title. I want Aaron Brooks nowhere near the 9ers except as an opponent!

Reply : (Adds Aaron Brooks to the list of things that would make me stop watching 49'ers football)

Reply: The same Aaron Brooks who makes all those "highlight reel" plays? Like throwing backwards (ie. fumbling) when surrounded by defenders? I don't know that there's a single QB in the NFL who makes worse decisions. He's like the anti-Dorsey... all that physical talent, nothing else. Yeah, that's just who I want Smith learning the position from...

Reply : None of you guys know jack about football. Aaron Brooks is a great QB, just ask him

03-18-2006, 06:01 PM	#1
LongTimeFan Moderator Join Date: Jan 2005 Location: Louisiana Posts: 2,403	49er's message board... Enjoy Well, it looks like Aaron Brooks will be trade-bait now. Based on his success under Mike McCarthy, I think we should make New Orleans an offer. Maybe a 3rd rounder, or a 4th and Dorsey? I've always liked Aaron Brooks personally, he has a very good arm and would immediately make us better. He would easily be the best QB on our roster, knows the offense already, has great athletic skills and could allow Smith a couple years to develop. Reply: Im not sure I would want a guy who fails to win the big games... or many games at all! Reply: I didn't get past the thread title. I want Aaron Brooks nowhere near the 9ers except as an opponent! Reply : (Adds Aaron Brooks to the list of things that would make me stop watching 49'ers football) Reply: The same Aaron Brooks who makes all those "highlight reel" plays? Like throwing backwards (ie. fumbling) when surrounded by defenders? I don't know that there's a single QB in the NFL who makes worse decisions. He's like the anti-Dorsey... all that physical talent, nothing else. Yeah, that's just who I want Smith learning the position from... Reply : None of you guys know jack about football. Aaron Brooks is a great QB, just ask him
	Rest In Peace JoeSam, thanks for everything my friend.