Would you consider J.P. Losman as the backup for Brees?
 

I just read on Yahoo's NFL page (http://sports.yahoo.com/nfl), the Bills may be interested in getting rid of J.P. Losman. I know some of you Green Wave fans may have some insight on that idea...what do you think? I never really got to see him play but coming out of college, I thought there was some chatter about him being a good NFL prospect.

RE: Would you consider J.P. Losman as the backup for Brees?
 

I don't think Losman had a real fair chance to prove himself in Buffalo. I reserve my judgement on him until I see him play a little more. Wouldn't mind seeing him in a Saints uniform either.

RE: Would you consider J.P. Losman as the backup for Brees?
 

that kid wasn't handled properly in Buffalo, he's damaged goods. you can tell by watching him play- his cage has been severly rattled. i hate it for him, because i thought he was a good prospect coming out.

RE: Would you consider J.P. Losman as the backup for Brees?
 

I dont want to see him NO....I'm not sure what they filled his head with in buffalo but it was not a playbook....plus I really think that guy has a serious ego problem...

Re: RE: Would you consider J.P. Losman as the backup for Bre
 

That seems to be a trend for Tulane QBs. Ramsey, Losman. That being said, i'd give him a shot as a no pressure back-up. You gotta remember, the Bills moved back up itn he first round to grab him as their starter going forward. That's a lot of pressure for a guy not expected to go until the second round.

RE: Re: RE: Would you consider J.P. Losman as the backup for
 

hell-to-the-no!!!!

The most common thing i have read is that his teammates hate him and he is locker room cancer. We have a young project QB already. A known quality vet is the need.

And that quality vet is??? Jeff Blake? Jim McMahon? Ty Detmer? Kerry Collins?

This is a list by espn of all the FA quarterbacks are and where they've gone, if they've moved. Who's your dream acquisition? After lookning at this list, you can't help but want to draft Lienart.

http://proxy.espn.go.com/nfl/fa?positionId=8

Misread-
Quantity not quality.
Someone who is proven to whatever quality they are. Better than an untested rookie. I would rather see Tommy Maddox as a game one starter or come in off the bench in the middle of game four if Brees is hurt. Immediate pressure on a rookie can not only yield disappointing results (ala a list too long to write) but can scar them permanently. Carson Palmer behind Kitna for a year or Eli behind Warner (until he was injured) is the more proven means of QB developmental success.

As Payton said, We are in the win now business.

As to your two examples, a quality qb to start with a phenominal rookie talent behind them. Thanks for making the argument to draft Lienart so simple.

I wouldn't mind if the Saints went after Losman, but I'd only give up a 5th rounder

No No No No

Totally agree LT.

pencil me in for mcmahon. i didn't know he still played. at least he won a super bowl

Again, HELL-to-the-NO!!!

:crow: GROUND PAT'I!!

Better idea...let's get Archie to un-retire, before we go that route

That is the same kid that got diced by our defense. A defense that is so schizophrenic we never know what part of the opponent's gameplan we are going to come strong against.

I have to agree, if I may quote a great poet: hell-to-the-no!

NO. AND i VOTE FOR AMAC

lets see here we get there #8, #42, and JP this year and a #1 and a 4 next year.
Haloti Ngata, Michael Huff, Jimmy Williams, Jay Cutler, Chad Greenway are still on the board. hmm food for thought.
I believe JP was missed handled in Buffallo but I do think he will be nothing more than an above average #2 QB in the nfl. but instead of a low pick say in the 5 or 6 range i would take him. Trade straight for him I would have to say NO.

i may have been talking about mcmahon from the bears 85 super bowl team. way to pick that up. obviously not serious

We still need a back-up though....I don't know about AMac right now...maybe in a year, but who is still out there?

I mean....back-up QB lightning doesn't strike twice...does it?

I say we cut Bouwoman, make AMAC #2 and draft either Jacobs in the second or Josh Betts in the 6th or 7th round as our 3rd.

cherm i am with you on letting todd go. he isn't a good backup in my opinion

I wouldn't want him as a backup for the SCOUT team !!!!!!