New Orleans Saints Forums - blackandgold.com

New Orleans Saints Forums - blackandgold.com (https://blackandgold.com/community/)
-   Saints (https://blackandgold.com/saints/)
-   -   excellent article on brees!!! (https://blackandgold.com/saints/12121-excellent-article-brees.html)

spkb25 04-02-2006 09:50 AM

excellent article on brees!!!
 
i had to save this to word as a text file but it is off espn. you can only see it if you have insider and is i guess from this months espn magazine. early preview. it is kinda long but a great read. if anyone can come back from this it has to be this kid


COLD
S H O U L D E R

DREW BREES THOUGHT HE'D DONE ALL HE TO MAKE THE CHARGERS
HIS TEAM. TURNS OUT
HE THOUGHT WRONG

BY TOM FRIEND
PHOTOGRAPHS BY AMY ARBUS


A football team is saying its postgame prayer in the bowels of a damp stadium, and kneeling down with them, in street clothes, is a man in a sling. His eyes are glass, his shoulder is on fire and a car has been waiting on him for an hour, but he rises and begins to work the room. Good game. I'm fine. A setback ain't nothing but a setup for a comeback.
They don't know how he's doing this, how he's cheering them up when it should be vice versa. They saw what happened two hours before, saw him fumble on his own goal line, saw him dive for the ball helmet-first, saw a 325-pound opponent pile on, saw his throwing shoulder get contorted, twisted and dislodged. It was gruesome, foreboding, and everyone knew it.

The wife in the stands knew, the doctor in Alabama knew and the backup quarterback on the sideline knew. But not the man in the sling.

How come? What is it with him? Why had he even stuck around? His wife, fighting back tears, had stood with him outside the X-ray room as the game was droning on, and she'd asked, “You ready to go home, babe?'' He'd told her no, that he needed to be in the locker room at game's end, that he had to let the team know
that their leader was in one piece. That it was his team. His team! He kept saying it and saying it. His team, his team, his team.
THE GENERAL manager isn't thinking the San Diego Chargers belong to Drew Brees. He's thinking, “What a #@#% mess.'' It's New Year's Eve, the season's just ended and his Pro Bowl quarterback, a pending free agent, can't even lift his throwing arm. What now? What now? That's what A.J. Smith

is pondering as he leaves Qualcomm Stadium. He's got a backup QB who's a bonus baby, over whom he drooled so much that he traded the draft rights to Eli Manning for him. True, Philip Rivers has taken only 64 NFL snaps, but he also stays after practice every day, throwing, sweating, learning. On game days, he huddles with the kickoff coverage team, counts off players and shouts, “We got 11!'' Then he growls, “Who's gonna make this tackle?� He's a leader, too, dammit. And so the GM spends his night pitting one against the
other. Brees or Rivers. Rivers or Brees. What now? What now?

Meanwhile, at Brees' house, more than 10 people are waiting for the injured quarterback. They're somber, but Brees, who just won't stand for it, walks in with wife Brittany and announces, “All right, who's ready to drink?'' They all start whooping, clapping. That's the Brees they know. He tells them, “Nobody feel sorry for me tonight. This is just a bump in the road. No sad faces.'' He doesn't

tell them about his MRI in the morning.

The next day, he calls the Birmingham, Ala., home of orthopedist James Andrews, who's never met a shoulder he couldn't renovate. Andrews tells Brees he saw the injury occur live on TV, that he was able to diagnose a torn labrum from his couch. Two days later, on Jan. 3, Brees is headed to Birmingham for surgery. He connects through Dallas, and on the layover, he sees a message from Smith on his cell phone. When Brees returns the call, the GM says, “You're our guy. We want you longterm. It's what you wanted. So rest your mind, have the surgery, rehab, get healthy and come back and win us a championship. We'll be in contact with [agent] Tom Condon. But Drew, business is business, and I don't know where this will go. I want you to understand that.''

Brees, ecstatic, answers, “Yes, sir, I understand,'' and just as he's about to hang up, Smith has something else to add. A minor detail.

“Drew,'' the GM says, “Philip Rivers will be here too. You'll both be back.''
PHILIP RIVERS bites his lip. He wants to say it so badly, wants to say, “Pick
one! Me or him!'' But he can't now, not 72 hours after this injury, not with Brees in a sling, not with everything in limbo. Before the injury, he thought there'd be a resolution, thought they'd trade him or let Brees walk. But one wrecked shoulder has changed everything.

He feels awful for Brees, but what about him? A third straight year as a backup? Forget it. He'd started 51 consecutive games at NC State, an NCAA record. He'd never sat in his life. He was too hyper to sit. As a kid, he'd wanted to be the
quarterback on the field and the drum major at halftime. He was a doer. But now he’s just a scout-team quarterback trying to win over someone else’s team. At practice, linebacker Donnie Edwards would say, “How many picks you gonna throw me today, Rivers?’’ And the bonus baby would growl, “I’m gonna complete every ball.’’ And in one 7-on-7 drill, he actually did. Not one ball hit the ground. But the public didn’t know that; the public knew nothing. In fact, Rivers went to Sea World one day after his rookie year, and no one recognized him. He was a

nobody. And apparently, that’s how it’s going to stay. It’s Brees’ team again and Rivers’ scout team again. Unbelievable. THE FIRST thing Brees sees postsurgery is the ruddy face of James Andrews. “Drew!’’ says the doctor in his Southern accent. “If I did that operation 100 times, I couldn’t do it as good as I just did. But it’s only as good as your rehab, son. It’s up to you.’’

Uh-oh, the doc went and did it. Anytime someone challenges Brees, it lights a ridiculous fire. That’s how it was in high school, when he tore his ACL as a junior and colleges stopped recruiting him. And that’s how it was when the Chargers drafted Rivers in April 2004.

You should have seen Brees prior to that season’s training camp. He changed his diet and his
sleeping habits and began doing visualization therapy. He’d close his eyes and throw to receivers. At first, the receivers would be stationary, but then they’d run routes, and he’d hit them in stride, eyes shut. He decided quarterbacking was about multitasking-avoiding a rush and reading a defense at the same time-so in private, he’d call out pass progressions while juggling three

tennis balls. He’d also attach himself to a sled with a bungee cord and throw rollout passes while high school kids rushed him. He was at the practice facility 24/7. “I never drove by and didn’t see his car,’’ Edwards says. “Even at 5 on a Friday. I’d say, ‘Dude, go home.’ �

So Rivers picked a bad time to stage a rookie holdout. Brees was coming off an ugly 67.5 passer rating in 2003, but he waltzed in on the first day of the 2004 training camp and called a players-only meeting. He handed everyone a typed piece of paper stating his team and personal goals and asked each player to write in his. He told them, “Line up behind me, because I’m gonna lead you.’’

That’s how the Chargers became his

team. They went 12–4 and won the AFC West, and his 27:7 TDs-to-interceptions ratio got him voted into the Pro Bowl. He’d connected with every player, especially the other quarterbacks. He nicknamed Doug Flutie Salty Dog because Flutie was always grousing about something. He even brought in a football he’d bought at the famous Salty Dog Cafe in Hilton Head, S.C., so that Flutie-or anyone else-could sign and
date it if he was in a “salty’’ mood. “Philip signed it eight times, I signed it seven times, Doug all the time,’’ Brees says.

He even made Rivers feel welcome, because, frankly, they were alike. Brees was the grandson of a coach, Rivers the son of one, and both had been ball boys. Brees, at his grandpa’s football practices near Corpus Christi, Texas, used to steal

sips of green electrolyte water. And Rivers, as a 7-year-old in Athens, Ala., used to run on the field during measurements and signal first down. On birthdays, Rivers staged football games instead of parties on his father’s lined high school field. That was up Brees’ alley.

But no, Rivers couldn’t have Brees’ Chargers. So when Doc Andrews tells Brees to rehab or else, the switch goes on again. The day after surgery, he’s already stretching. Two weeks after surgery, he’s out of his sling. Four weeks after surgery, he’s in treatment nine hours a day. Six weeks after surgery, he’s asking when he can play golf. Eight weeks after surgery, on the eve of free agency, his external rotation is 143°, meaning he can reach behind his head to scratch his back. “Nuts, huh?’’ Brees asks.

The scuttlebutt at this point is that he may miss the start of the season, but he plans to throw in May and practice full-bore in July. “By Sept. 1,� he says, “I’ll be doing back handsprings.�

He’s asked if, worst-case scenario, the Chargers might have to start Rivers, and he says he isn’t worried. Because either way, he’s going to be a Charger. That’s what the general manager told him.
SOMETHING’S HAPPENED. Something baffling. The Chargers have made their offer, and it’s low, worth only $2 million in guaranteed money. “That’s what backup quarterbacks get,’’ Brees says.

What’s this about? The surgery? Did it go worse than expected? It turns out, there was a partially torn rotator cuff to go with Brees’ torn labrum, and rotator cuff has the Chargers thinking Chad Pennington. Smith consults myriad doctors, and though he won’t say so, their reactions appear to be mixed. The GM decides two things. First, he will not use his franchise or transition tag on Brees. Second, he won’t break the bank for him, even though he has about $20 million in cap room. Considering that Pennington’s surgery was also done by Andrews, and considering that Pennington
has flopped, Smith's lowball offer makes some sense. “We had a price tag,� Smith says. “There isn't sweetening it or lessening it. We make decisions on the dollar sign for all our players. And in saying that, a lot of teams didn't even pursue Brees. They didn't want anything to do with it.�

Brees can't believe that two straight winning

seasons mean nothing. A 51:22 TDs-tointerceptions ratio over two years means nothing. Those players-only meetings mean nothing. The Chargers' almost becoming an elite team means nothing. But Smith isn't budging. If the bonus baby ends up as his QB, so be it.

Word leaks out, and the Chargers offices are inundated with angry calls. Fans threaten to cancel season tickets. Smith goes public and says, yes, Brees claims he wants to come back, but only if the
money's right. The GM is still seen as heartless. LaDainian Tomlinson, Brees' friend since their days as Texas high school stars, comes out against the move. Marty Schottenheimer, who's not even speaking to Smith because of apparent control issues, comes out

against it too. Speculation is that Smith is setting Schottenheimer up to fail, although the coach says that if that's the case, Smith's setting himself up to fail too. Consensus is that Brees is a Marty guy and Rivers is an A.J. guy, although Smith denies it. “I don't care who holds up the Super Bowl trophy,'' he says. “The Chargers players are my guys.''

But Brees is miffed. There was that phone call during the layover in Dallas, remember? “I'm a guy of integrity,'' Brees says. “If I tell you I'll do
something, I'll do whatever it takes to get it done. Or at least I'll say I tried. I don't think A.J. can look back and say, `Hey, we tried.' To have that phone call and then to have everything that's transpired since then? I can't say they've tried.''

Smith's reaction: “Wrong. Wrong. I told him, This is a business. Every team goes through this. Look at the Colts and Edgerrin James.' You can't
take care of everyone.’’

Fact is, Smith admires three franchises: the Patriots, the Steelers and the Eagles. Three teams unafraid to cut ties with
veterans no matter how many jerseys they have in the stands. “Yeah,� Brees says, “and three franchises with established QBs.’’

So on the first night of free agency, March 11, it isn’t the Chargers dialing Drew Brees; it’s the Saints and the Dolphins. He checks his cell phone one last time before going to sleep to see if San Diego has called. Nothing.
IT’S LOOKING like Miami. The Saints are offering a stunning $10 million
guaranteed-$8 million more than the Chargers-and Brees isn’t signing it yet. So he must like Miami better, right?


But Miami’s dragging, and the reason is the shoulder. Brees thinks San Diego has spread a rumor that his arm is a mess-Smith denies it-so he gives the Dolphins a DVD of his surgery and workouts. But Miami still chooses
Daunte Culpepper over him. That leaves the Saints, the vagabond Saints.
Brees sees the irony of it all. He is New Orleans: broken down. Undervalued. In need of reinventing. He signs the deal, and within minutes, his Chargers teammates are text
messaging him, upset like hell. Of course, they don’t say it publicly. They have Rivers to prop up now. Lorenzo Neal,
Keenan McCardell and Roman Oben quickly contact the kid and tell him, “Let’s go, this is what you’ve been waiting for.� Tomlinson phones
Rivers and tells him not to misconstrue his support of Brees as a lack of support for him. And Rivers, a solid guy who’s just happy to be off the scout team, forgives
him: “I know you’re going to miss Drew. We’re all going to miss Drew. But this is not
a setback. We’ll keep it going. It’s not like I’m brand-new.’’
Meanwhile, Schottenheimer invites Rivers into his office for a 30-minute meeting, telling him, “If you were the starter last year
and you were the free agent, I would’ve wanted you back. I just like continuity.’’ The spin is in, although not completely. Because Schottenheimer goofs. Later he does an interview and says, “We may have to run the ball more next season.’’

The GM is irritated by the comment, while Rivers sloughs it off. But it’s a sign of trouble, a sign that a good portion of the franchise thinks the team has backtracked. “It’s pretty interesting there,’’ Brees says, referring to the Smith-Schottenheimer rift. “They should make a reality show. I’d TiVo it, watch it whenever I could.’’

Is he mad? Not at Rivers. The two talk after the Saints deal is done, and Brees tells him, “It’s your team now.’’ He never thought he’d say it, but what’s true is true. He also says he’ll see him soon because he’s planning to visit the Chargers’ facility one more time, to “waltz in there like I own the place’’ and clear out his locker. He’s going to pack up everything, including the Salty Dog Cafe football. But first he’s gonna sign that ball. Sign and date it one last time.

Because Drew Brees is salty.

Will the Chargers regret choosing Philip over

Drew?

LongTimeFan 04-02-2006 10:22 AM

Dame spkb, you read my mind, I saw the article on ESPN but I'm not an Insider subscriber so I see it here and read it, very interesting.
"A setback ain't nothing but a setup for a comeback. ", I love this quote.
The more I read on Brees the more I like him, everything about him tells me he's the real deal and is a team player who does whatever his team ask of him.
Glad to read that the doctor was satisfied with the surgery and felt it was his best he has performed, he said it's up to Drew now, I think Drew will work hard to get back to his play soon, the future looks good for the Saints now that we have Brees, we have hope now, something we didn't have in a long time which makes a LongTimeFan very happy.
Drew will be fine, gotta believe
Go Saints

Thanks for the post spkb, that was a good one..

mighty12 04-02-2006 10:41 PM

I really believe Brees is what we have been waiting for since the turn of the century! He is a leader, He commands a team to be just as dedicated as he is, and most importantly he is fueled to be the BEST QB this year.

pakowitz 04-03-2006 07:14 AM

wow i just read that and brees has got some character man... im really glad we picked him up, success or fail, that guy stands up for what he believes in and gives it his all.. unlike some other people we have had around here...........................im B not R gonna O say O any K names S...........

FatiusJeebs 04-03-2006 08:39 AM

Wow...all of a sudden I'm thinking of Brooks....how did that happen? :shock:

LKelley67 04-03-2006 08:49 AM

I'm not afraid to critique any player on the team. I'm not rah-rah for bums. I understand the realities and risk of Brees shoulder. That said, I haven'r read one thing that has made me feel negative in anyway about him. In fact, if you are going to take a risk on a guy he is the exact type you do that on. (NOT friggin cokehead Dale Carter).

zachsaints52 04-03-2006 09:55 AM

Yeah, I was gonna post it too, because I get the Magizine. I am happy we got him now. I really want to see him suceed (of course haha) but now that I read that, I really belive in him now.

Tobias-Reiper 04-03-2006 10:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FatiusJeebs
Wow...all of a sudden I'm thinking of Brooks....how did that happen? :shock:

..it's that "sublimination" thing, man... it's the government controlling your thoughts, man... here's some tin foil...

..gotta tell ya, just a couple weeks ago, before Drew was signed, I said go with Leinart, because I was worried about the injury. But the more I read about him, and the things he says, bad shoulder or not, this is the type of man you want involved on your organization. The man has character.

FatiusJeebs 04-03-2006 11:00 AM

Whew....I look like a watered down, 7-11 version of Magneto. Thanks TR.

On a serious note though, I like Brees and I have been a fan of his since he was at Purdue. It thrills me to see that he is now a Saint. The only thing I can't shake from all of this is why did he visit Miami after the offer we made him? I mean....Does he REALLLLLLY want to be here? I dunno...I sometimes can't help but feel that Brees is here cause in essence....nobody really wanted him.

Tobias-Reiper 04-03-2006 11:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FatiusJeebs
Whew....I look like a watered down, 7-11 version of Magneto. Thanks TR.

On a serious note though, I like Brees and I have been a fan of his since he was at Purdue. It thrills me to see that he is now a Saint. The only thing I can't shake from all of this is why did he visit Miami after the offer we made him? I mean....Does he REALLLLLLY want to be here? I dunno...I sometimes can't help but feel that Brees is here cause in essence....nobody really wanted him.

..true, but the beauty of it, is that now Drew has a brand new chip on his shoulder...

I don't really put too much on where he wanted to go. For all we know, it could've been his wife telling him she didn't want to live in a city devastated by a hurricane and to make every possible attempt to go to Florida. As long as he commits to the Saints now that he's signed and his shoulder holds, that's all i care.

He IS our QB now...

BJSim 04-03-2006 11:11 AM

Quote:

I dunno...I sometimes can't help but feel that Brees is here cause in essence....nobody really wanted him.
Fatius, I think that's partially true. But I think he's now going to make the best of the situation and ensure this team knows he's the man, that it's his team, and he'll be our starting QB come week one.

Quote:

..gotta tell ya, just a couple weeks ago, before Drew was signed, I said go with Leinart, because I was worried about the injury. But the more I read about him, and the things he says, bad shoulder or not, this is the type of man you want involved on your organization. The man has character.
Tobias, I agree with you. And the more I read about Lienart, the less he seems to be like Brees (Manning(s) or Brady). He had a mediocre Pro-Day, and most articles mention how he's more interested in his press than his bench-press. This is a guy who's knock was a weak arm, and he's not working out every day to get it stronger? I haven't completely left the draft Leinart camp, but I'm at the edge and peering into the other camps to see what going on in them.

FatiusJeebs 04-03-2006 01:38 PM

Like TR and BJ have iterated....I can only hope that he really does now apply the atittude that this is his team and that he will do everything in his power to succeed and makes us successful. Lord knows what the city will do for him if he does come through :party: ......

LKelley67 04-03-2006 02:02 PM

I am sure they had some preliminary ballpark numbers out there to schedule visits from. Also,I do think plenty of other teams would want him- just at a lower price. He had an offer on the table from SD. It was not clear from the posturing if Brees decided on NO first or whether Miami said Culpepper first. On that, I don't care. So what if he would have went to Miami if he could have. He has clearly shown his professionalism and character as a player you want to lead your team and who will go all out to prove his worth. He had a chip on his shoulder when they drafted Rivers. With the national attention and big price on his head I think he will be all the more determined. If all goes well with his health and play I am sure they will gladly renegotiate the contract to a more legitimate long tem deal. It is a sweet contract for NO as is. In essence it is just two years and he can even be tossed after this year if he fails and his shoulder blows out. I count it as the most aggressive if not shrewdest FA move since Mueller left.

In related thought, I won't be surprised if you see teams avoiding high first round quarterback prospects increasingly. The success ratio is so very small in proportion to the investment. I always think back to the infamous '99 draft- QBs Couch, McNabb, Akilli Smith 1-2-3 and two of them are out of football. Culpepper and Cade McNown later in the first round, same thing. Other first rounders Tory Holt, Champ Bailey, Anthony McFarland, Jevon Kearse, Chris McAlister, and Al Wilson were all much more predictable surer things.

mighty12 04-03-2006 02:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LKelley67
The success ratio is so very small in proportion to the investment. I always think back to the infamous '99 draft- QBs Couch, McNabb, Akilli Smith 1-2-3 and two of them are out of football. Culpepper and Cade McNown later in the first round, same thing. Other first rounders Tory Holt, Champ Bailey, Anthony McFarland, Jevon Kearse, Chris McAlister, and Al Wilson were all much more predictable surer things.

I was saying that throughout the whole "Draft Leinart" Fiasco, and continuously caught crap because of it. The proof is in the pudding. Name 5 Probowl QBs drafted in the top 5 over the past 10 years.

FatiusJeebs 04-03-2006 02:12 PM

Honestly...the Pro Bowl means crap to me now. How on earth M. Vick made it to the Pro Bowl this year boggles my mind. Seriously!!!! WTF?? and HTF??? :puke:

mighty12 04-03-2006 02:21 PM

Well then name 5 QBs drafted in the top 5 that have made a positive impact on their team. There is Peyton Manning from 1998, McNabb in '99, Carson Palmer in '03, and MAYBE Eli Manning in '04(I say MAYBE because he shows flashes of greatness, and then falls apart.) I left Vick out of this because he still has alot to prove, but I will admit he did turn around the Falcons for a year. so 3 maybe 4 QBs out of 11(Not counting Alex Smith YET!) The odds are against selecting a QB first. Even being selected number 1 overall has its inconsistancy.

LongTimeFan 04-03-2006 02:42 PM

IMO M. Vick isn't more than a backup, the guy runs good but I've noticed in a few games last year that some popped him (Urlacker) making him think twice before running and that's all it takes to throw him off, he's not much of a passer, what the guy avg. 155 yards per game?
Again, IMO I think the Falcons get rid of him if he doesn't get much better really soon.
A lot of fans love Vick, reason he made the Pro-Bowl, that's crap if you ask me..

FatiusJeebs 04-03-2006 02:45 PM

LOLOL....I should have added LTF????.....to my post. Thankx LTF. I did not see the game but i noticed in the highlights that he was QB. I felt sick......real sick.

LKelley67 04-03-2006 02:47 PM

My emphasis is that all too often it can be hit or completely miss with QBs. With a Super Mario, Brick, or Hawk you get a player that even if he does not end up being an All Pro or high impact player he can still be a serviceable useful starter. Highly touted QBs more often tend to be boom or bust, starter or fade out with the bonus money.

jnormand 04-03-2006 03:38 PM

I agree with you guys on Brees. No matter what, it seems like a good deal for both parties. If Brees does well, the Saints will give him a contract extension. If his shoulder do not hold up, the Saints can let him go. I really think Brees will come in and do a great job. Plus, anyone with his type of character and attitude is going to help a club.

I think Brees is the real deal. I'm excited to see what the guy can do.

As far as Leinhart, I don't know. I don't know what would be a good move. If we get Leinhart, the Saints will have to pay him big, big bucks and Brees may take it like the team does not believe in him. I guess go with the best defensive player on the board?...

FrenzyFan 04-03-2006 03:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BJSim
...
Tobias, I agree with you. And the more I read about Lienart, the less he seems to be like Brees (Manning(s) or Brady). He had a mediocre Pro-Day, and most articles mention how he's more interested in his press than his bench-press. This is a guy who's knock was a weak arm, and he's not working out every day to get it stronger? I haven't completely left the draft Leinart camp, but I'm at the edge and peering into the other camps to see what going on in them.

I don't know what you read about Leinart's pro day, but what I read said that everyone was impressed with his accuracy, touch, field presence and leadership. They also said they were impressed by his mobility, which is not something he's known for.

No matter, I agree with the sentiments in this thread. The article feels a bit more like drama than reality, but Brees seems to be a high character guy. I am concerned by his chasing of guaranteed money. His shoulder is risky. We paid too much. Despite all these things, I feel that if you're going to take a risk like this he SEEMS to be the right kind of guy to take the risk on.

I sincerely hope all the leadership hype in the article is real. This team needs an on-the-field leader more than anything else right now. Brees COULD be that guy.

xan 04-03-2006 04:11 PM

I guess it doesn't worry anyone else here that of the 20 or so teams looking for qb help, only two teams bothered to talk and one dropped out almost immediately? While I like Mr. Brees and wish him the best because he's a Saint, I have no confidence that he can return to the Pro Bowl form for which he is getting paid UPFRONT.

The Saints really isn't his team until he can prove he can play for it.

LongTimeFan 04-03-2006 06:31 PM

"The Saints really isn't his team until he can prove he can play for it."

Let's be fair about it, Brees has only been with the Saints a few weeks, at least let him get through camp before saying anything negative about him.
Wait and see...

jnormand 04-03-2006 09:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by xan
While I like Mr. Brees and wish him the best because he's a Saint, I have no confidence that he can return to the Pro Bowl form for which he is getting paid UPFRONT.

The Saints really isn't his team until he can prove he can play for it.

Xan, at least give the guy a chance. I can understand some doubt, but not having any confidence in him is a little exteme. Hey, as far as I'm concerned, the team is more his now than it was for their prior QB. And Brees at least has the drive and the attitude to excel. I think his attitude already has shown his leadership and persistance to win.

With all due respect Xan, I hope you are very wrong about Brees.

xan 04-04-2006 01:01 AM

I hope I am very wrong about Mr. Brees, too. However, players who have this kind of injury take a long time to heal and the vast majority of them don't recover the mobility control and flexibility necessary to play quarterback in the NFL. I hope he's the exception, but he's got to actually do something. Every one, but the Saints, in the football know passed on this guy because they have a realistic expectation about this kind of injury. He's one loose throw from being on the IR for the whole season, one measily little "elbow touch foul" on his follow through from playing Madden 2006 for the rest of the season. I will cringe every time he gets sacked knowing the spit and duct tape holding his livelihood together may fail. Who can blame him or any on his "team" for being optimistic (wildly, I'd say) about his prognosis and current condition. The only suckers are the people who overextend their risk relying on this optimism.

I would definitely have a different attitude if he were entering our camps this spring with no career threatening injury, that he's the leader and he'll be the man. Unfortunately, he may not see any action until the very end of preseason at the earliest. Then what? Who leads this team into the season? How long will it take Mr. Brees to catch up to game conditions?

I can see no worse situation than having your overpaid franchise quarterback on the bench at the beginning of the season and some total nimrod cast off running another season of offensive underachievement. I want a margin for error, and there is none without a quality backup, which we don't have.

Tobias-Reiper 04-04-2006 04:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by xan
I hope I am very wrong about Mr. Brees, too. However, players who have this kind of injury take a long time to heal and the vast majority of them don't recover the mobility control and flexibility necessary to play quarterback in the NFL. I hope he's the exception, but he's got to actually do something. Every one, but the Saints, in the football know passed on this guy because they have a realistic expectation about this kind of injury. He's one loose throw from being on the IR for the whole season, one measily little "elbow touch foul" on his follow through from playing Madden 2006 for the rest of the season. I will cringe every time he gets sacked knowing the spit and duct tape holding his livelihood together may fail. Who can blame him or any on his "team" for being optimistic (wildly, I'd say) about his prognosis and current condition. The only suckers are the people who overextend their risk relying on this optimism.

I would definitely have a different attitude if he were entering our camps this spring with no career threatening injury, that he's the leader and he'll be the man. Unfortunately, he may not see any action until the very end of preseason at the earliest. Then what? Who leads this team into the season? How long will it take Mr. Brees to catch up to game conditions?

I can see no worse situation than having your overpaid franchise quarterback on the bench at the beginning of the season and some total nimrod cast off running another season of offensive underachievement. I want a margin for error, and there is none without a quality backup, which we don't have.

Geez, man... new coaching staff, new QB, and already bitter before the draft?

Look, many teams neeed QBs, but not many teams needed a STARTING QB, nor many teams had the cap room to sign Brees. Tell me, which team at the start of FA needed a starting QB and had the money to sign Brees? Of the teams that had at least 10,000,000 in cap room, only the Lions needed a QB, and they have Matt Millen as GM - I do like the Kitna signing, though -. The Dolphins made a run at Brees knowing perfectly well they did NOT have the money Brees wanted.

Yes, signing a guy with an injury is a gamble, but, if you are going to gamble, this is the type of guy you want to gamble on.

LongTimeFan 04-04-2006 05:44 AM

I can't imagine any team paying a QB 18 mil. first year unless they knew he had a great chance of playing well after a surgery, I can almost bet the Saints doctors checked him out and gave Benson & company a good report clearing him to play , 18 mil. is a lot of money to give out to any player if there is a good chance he couldn't play well due to an injury.
Give Brees a chance because it is what it is, he's a Saint now.

FrenzyFan 04-04-2006 06:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by xan
I hope I am very wrong about Mr. Brees, too. However, players who have this kind of injury take a long time to heal and the vast majority of them don't recover the mobility control and flexibility necessary to play quarterback in the NFL. I hope he's the exception, but he's got to actually do something. Every one, but the Saints, in the football know passed on this guy because they have a realistic expectation about this kind of injury. He's one loose throw from being on the IR for the whole season, one measily little "elbow touch foul" on his follow through from playing Madden 2006 for the rest of the season. I will cringe every time he gets sacked knowing the spit and duct tape holding his livelihood together may fail. Who can blame him or any on his "team" for being optimistic (wildly, I'd say) about his prognosis and current condition. The only suckers are the people who overextend their risk relying on this optimism.

I would definitely have a different attitude if he were entering our camps this spring with no career threatening injury, that he's the leader and he'll be the man. Unfortunately, he may not see any action until the very end of preseason at the earliest. Then what? Who leads this team into the season? How long will it take Mr. Brees to catch up to game conditions?

I can see no worse situation than having your overpaid franchise quarterback on the bench at the beginning of the season and some total nimrod cast off running another season of offensive underachievement. I want a margin for error, and there is none without a quality backup, which we don't have.

I have the same fears. Throughout the years we've watched this type of injury pretty much ruin QBs. They never recover the long ball, which tends to sail on them after this kind of injury. They take a hit that originally would not have been a problem, but now knocks them out for the season. Each hit like that makes them come back worse than the year before. It's usually a career ender, though not always that year - many times it takes two or three years before they admit it. I have a similar injury, though I didn't play QB. My throwing shoulder never came back fully. All those things I take as facts, not pessimism.

By the same token, what I read about Brees seems to indicate he's a fighter with a chip on his shoulder. He's an on-the-field/off-the-field leader, calling his team mates at their homes and checking on them. Coming up with innovative "team" things in the locker room (like the Salty Dog football). It seems to me that having Rivers breathing down his neck lit a fire under him, put him in a position where he had to prove something and he did. I see his ordeal this off-season as a similar situation wherein AGAIN he feels like he has something to prove. I suspect his long ball will be gone (a duck), but I don't care about that if he is poised and accurate on the short to mid routes. If he can read a defense and lead the team, I believe we can win with this team. When I look at the last few seasons, the absence of that leadership and poise cost us at least three games a year.

Basically what I'm saying is that I am willing to reserve condemning Brees and the money we paid him, based on hope. I have nothing concrete, just hope. At the same time, I acknowledge that this was a HUGELY risky signing and the odds are not good.

As an aside, I personally feel that if we pass on Leinart our front office is filled with fools. Leinart seems to be everything Brees grew into, without a shoulder injury or the baggage from time spent in the San Diego situation. I understand when our new coach says he wants to win now, but I take the longer view. Great linemen and great linebackers come out in the draft every single year. How often will we have a high enough draft pick to select someone like Leinart.

xan 04-04-2006 10:15 AM

Bitter? You ain't seen bitter yet, baby. Just pass on Lienart and don't get Brees back until week 14. Then you'll see bitter, starting with the last preseason game (with hints of acrid spew every time Brees doesn't throw in drills). I find his attitude refreshing for the Saints, but there's a reason that we pay the cheerleaders NOTHING, and this guy wouldn't look good in a halter top.

Remember, Brees didn't start playing well until there was a real challenge waiting anxiously on the sidelines in SD.

FanNJ 04-04-2006 12:27 PM

Frenzy,

Nice post, I appreciate you bringing some personal reality to the injury. Like I stated elsewhere I have seen what happens with the injury.

Just curious how long did it take to get the strength and motion back into the sholder and arm?

And for all of the optimists out there I too hope that Brees can return to pre injury form, however I suspect that boosting ticket sales had alot to do with the signing. I hope he can return intime for the season, but do not want to watch a one year stop gap player all season, when there are some great prospects there in the draft.

FrenzyFan 04-04-2006 03:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FanNJ
Frenzy,

Nice post, I appreciate you bringing some personal reality to the injury. Like I stated elsewhere I have seen what happens with the injury.

Just curious how long did it take to get the strength and motion back into the sholder and arm?

And for all of the optimists out there I too hope that Brees can return to pre injury form, however I suspect that boosting ticket sales had alot to do with the signing. I hope he can return intime for the season, but do not want to watch a one year stop gap player all season, when there are some great prospects there in the draft.

I don't mean to imply that my injury was as serious as Brees'. In truth I have no clue how bad his was, I just know that mine was bad. The first time I walked on real snow was when I was 22 years old, spending a winter in Boston, MA. Slipped on some wooden steps, and went through a wooden railing. Landed where my shoulder was bent back towards my spine. Dislocated, rotator cuff torn, arm dead.

I spent fourteen months doing pretty faithful physical therapy when all was said and done. To be honest, and with all the (un)wisdom of youth, I stopped working it before I should have and never got back all the mobility. I can reach my left hand to roughly the center of my back from below. With my right (injured) arm, I can reach a bit above my beltline. Since my main concerns at the time were push-ups, bench press, etc. I didn't notice any real loss. I had stopped pitching years before and my current sport was Rugby, so again I didn't notice any real loss. I sure noticed when I tried to play catch. My whole throwing motion felt like it was "wrong." When I tried to put the kind of zip on the ball I was used to, it was like I was trying to throw with my off-hand...just wrong and shortly thereafter, painful.

Funny how when you're young, you can accept those things. Thanks for asking. I recognize that Brees has much better doctors than I had access to. He makes a ton more money and his full-time job is about physical fitness, so he can devote a lot more time to recovery than I can. In my opinion, his recovery will be all about how much be puts into it and what kind of man he is. What I've read so far is encouraging.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:03 PM.


Copyright 1997 - 2020 - BlackandGold.com