My best all-time NFL team.
 

QB---Warren Moon
RB---Barry Sanders
FB---Larenzo Neal
WR---Jerry Rice
WR---Randy Moss
TE---Shannon Sharpe
OT---Art Shell
OT---Anthony Munoz
G----Gene Upshaw
G----Bruce Matthews
C----Mike Webster
DE---Bruce Smith
DE---Deacon Jones
DT---Joe Greene
DT---Merlin Olsen
OLB--Lawrence Taylor
MLB--Ray Lewis
OLB--Mike Singletary
CB---Deion Sanders
CB---Darrell Green
S----Ronnie Lott
S----Brian Dawkins

of all your options you come up with Moon and Moss???

Here's One Of My All Time Teams......................
 

QB - Joe Montana
RB - Jim Brown
FB - Marion Motley
WR - Jerry Rice
WR - Lynn Swann
TE - Kellen Winslow Sr.
OT - Art Shell
OT - Anthony Munoz
OG - Gene Upshaw
OG - John Hannah
C -- Mike Webster
DE - David "Deacon" Jones
DE - Reggie "Minister Of Defense" White
DT - Junious "Buck" Buchanan
DT - Allen Page
OLB-Lawrence "LT" Taylor
MLB-Dick Butkus
OLB-Derrick Thomas
CB - Dick "Night Train" Lane
CB - Mel Blount
S -- Ronnie Lott
S -- Emlen Tunnell

This is just one of my all time greatest teams, there's noway to have just one.

Some nice lists. Like you say we all have more than one.
Backfield is the only area of disagreement.My RB vote has to go to
HB "The Sweetness" Walter Payton.
FB Larry Zonka.

QB - Favre
RB - Sweetness
FB - Larry Centers
TE - Keith Jackson
WR - Jerry Rice, Marvin Harrison
OT - Willie Roaf, Jonathan Ogden
OG - Gene Upshaw, Steve Hutchinson
C - Dwight Stephenson
DT - Warren Sapp, Gilbert Brown
DE - Reggie White, Neal Smith
OLB - Lawrence Taylor, Singletary
MLB - Chris Speilman
CB - Deion, Champ Bailey
FS - Steve Atwater
SS - Troy Polamalu (sp?)
K - Morten Andersen
P - Ray Guy

QB---Joe Montana
RB---Barry Sanders
FB---Jim Brown
WR---Jerry Rice
WR---Chris Carter
TE---Shannon Sharpe
OT---Willie Roaf
OT---Anthony Munoz
G----Will Shields
G----Bruce Matthews
C----Olin Kruetz (I have no idea who Mike Webster is)
DE---Bruce Smith
DE---Reggie White
DT---Joe Greene
DT---Marcus Stroud
OLB--Lawrence Taylor
MLB--Ray Lewis
OLB--Mike Singletary
CB---Deion Sanders
CB---Champ Bailey
S----Ronnie Lott
S----Rod Woodson

QB - Peyton Manning
RB - Walter Payton
RB - Barry Sanders
RB - Jim Brown
FB - Larry Csonka
WR - Jerry Rice
WR - Harold Carmichael
FL - Chris Carter
OT - Anthony Munoz
OT - Art Shell
OG - John Hannah
OG- Larry Allen
C - Dwight Stevenson
TE - Kellen Winslow Sr.


DE- Deacon Jones
DE- Reggie White
DT - Warren Sapp
DT - Randy White
OLB - Lawrence Taylor
MLB - Ray Lewis
OLB - Derrick Thomas
CB - Deon Sanders
CB - Darryl Green
S- Ronnie Lott
S - Rod Woodson

PR - Deon Sanders
KR - Brian Mitchell
K - Morton Andersen
P - Ray Guy

Players most likely to be on any all time list.

LT at OLB
Lott at safety
Munoz at OT
Rice at WR
and maybe Ray Guy at P

Hard to argue those first 4.

I'd have to add Reggie White at DE. Probably the best ever.

And Deion at corner.

QB - Dan the Man
RB - Barry Sanders
FB - L. Neal
WR - Jerry Rice
WR - Cris Carter
TE - Shannon Sharpe
OT - Anthony Munoz
OT - Art Shell
G - Will Shields
G - Bruce Matthews
C - Dwight Stephenson
DE - Deacon Jones
DE - Reggie White
DT - Joe Greene
DT - Warren Sapp
OLB - Lawrence Taylor
MLB - Ray Lewis
OLB - Derrick Thomas
CB - Deon Sanders
CB - Dick Lane
S- Ronnie Lott
FS - Steve Atwater

PR - Deon
KR - Mel Gray

K - Morton Andersen
P - Ray Guy

I can think of 10 QB's I'd take before Moon.

Aikman, Montana, Bradshaw, Favre, Manning, Young, Marino...

I'd go with Winslow at TE. Senior, of course.

This thread would be much more interesting if it would be to arrive at consensus best ever at the different positions, and then come up with a consensus all time team.

I'm also surprised that Moon would be the choice for #1 all time, over (in any order) Elway, Montana, Marino, Aikman, Tarkenton, Starr, Graham, Baugh, Bradshaw, Staubach, Favre, Brees :) , Unitas, Brady, Manning, etc, etc...

That's why it's his "My best all-time NFL team"... it's probably his favorite quarterback. Moon does have the numbers.

QB Joe Montana
RB Walter Payton
FB Lorenzo Neal
WR Jerry Rice
WR Michael Irvin
TE Kellen Winslow, Sr.
OT Art Shell
OT Anthony Munoz
OG Bruce Matthews
OG Gene Upshaw
C Dwight Stephenson

DE Reggie White
DE David "Deacon" Jones
DT Joe Greene
DT Randy White
OLB Lawrence Taylor
MLB Sam Huff
OLB Greg Lloyd
CB Deion Sanders
CB Rod Woodson
S Ronnie Lott
S Mel Blount

P Ray Guy
K Morton Anderson
KR Gale Sayers
ST Steve Tasker

Warren Moon has thrown for more yards, than any QB in pro football. When you add the Canada league yards with the NFL yards. Although he should have began and ended his career in the NFL. But at the time they did not want a "brother" at QB.

Dude, Chuck Noll for special teams? I grew up in Pittsburgh and my family had season tix. The Steeler's kickers were Roy Gerela and Bobby Walden, later replaced by castoff after castoff.

Here's a Noll SB 4th quarter special teams moment: against the Cowboys Noll is so wary of having a punt blocked that he goes for a 4th and long, a handoff to Rocky Bleier and turns the ball over on downs at midfield.

Give it to Noll for drafting and developing coaches, but not ST

heres mine:
QB-Troy Aikman
RB-Gale Sayers
RB-Bo Jackson
FB-Lorenzo Neal
WR-Jerry Rice
WR-Steve Largent
TE-Mike Ditka
OT-Willie Roaf
OT-Mark May
OG-Dan Dierdorf
OG-Will Shields
C-Mike Webster

DE-Reggie White
DE-Richard Dent
DT-Joe Greene
DT-Manny Fernandez
OLB-Lawerence Taylor
MLB-Mike Singletary
OLB-Jack Lambert
CB-Deion Sanders
CB-Champ Bailey
FS-John Lynch
SS-Ronnie Lott

K-Adam Vinatieri
P-Ray Guy

That's great and all, but in Canada, the field is wider, the endzones are twice as big, your WRs can get a head start, and you do not have the secondaries that you have in the NFL. And Doug Flutie had more success than Moon in the CFL, throwing for more yards than Moon in the same span of time, including most yards in a season.