dorsey for either grant or smith?
 

would you trade the rams straight up either of these for the rights to pick dorsey? preferrably grant with his contract. then we would still have the abillity to trade our first and 2nd or 3rd to move up and get gohlston or long.

Re: dorsey for either grant or smith?
 

#1 - They are not worth that much.

#2 - Why trade them if they were?

Re: dorsey for either grant or smith?
 

The Rams would be idiots to do that, now maybe they would do our # 10 and grant or smith for the # 2 pick

Re: dorsey for either grant or smith?
 

I'd give them Jason David and a case of beer.

Re: dorsey for either grant or smith?
 

I'll give them two season passes to Jazzland! :D

Re: dorsey for either grant or smith?
 

that's like amputating your leg to save your foot...it doesn't make any sense

Re: dorsey for either grant or smith?
 

JD, the beer or Jazzland??? I don't get it :(

Re: dorsey for either grant or smith?
 

I'm confused.... Tickets to Jazzland or a case of beer?

Damn, you beat me to it. LOL

Re: dorsey for either grant or smith?
 

And don't forget we are throwing in David.

Re: dorsey for either grant or smith?
 

Who???

Re: dorsey for either grant or smith?
 

i mean trading grant or smith for dorsey is like trading your leg for your foot...what's the point of it??

Re: dorsey for either grant or smith?
 

i think that would take away from the point.....if we think that DT is our biggest need...getting rid of our DEs would only make it worse....dorsey is not more talented than will smith even tho the game style they bring is different....i just dont think the saints are interested enough in moving up to get a DT

Re: dorsey for either grant or smith?
 

why trade from the weak side of the ball? Canton is right. two steps forward one step back.
how about from the offense? Brown?

Re: dorsey for either grant or smith?
 

As far as I am concerned, both Grant and Smith should be completely off limits. I know they both had rough seasons last year, but both are borderline superstars and should bounce back in a big way. DE is one of the most difficult positions in football, and the Saints are lucky to have two that are better than average. If the Saints give up on either of these guys, it could possibly be an easy 10 year gap before they are adequately replaced. So to answer the question, NO, I would not pawn Grant or Smith for Dorsey. As much as I would love to see Dorsey in a Saints uniform, it's simply not worth giving up on either starting DE.

Re: dorsey for either grant or smith?
 

An impact DT like Ellis or Dorsey makes our DE's better...instantly and substantialy.

Re: dorsey for either grant or smith?
 

I wouldn't be suprised if something like this was to happen. Lets not forget that with Jim Hazlett calling the shots on defense he may still be interested in a player he already know off the Saints team.