For WhoDat and whoever....

BillyC · 12-05-2003, 07:16 PM

WhoDat --

You have told me that Brooks is to blame for the offensive troubles this year. You stated the resaon for that was because he has turned the ball over more than anyone else on the team. Is that correct so far? You also contend that Brooks' turnovers have killed more drives than penalties, dropped passes, and everything else, because you contend these don't neccessarily kill drives. Is that also correct? I think your position is Brooks is MOST to blame. Is that correct?

Let's look at your arguement with another QB, like...uh.....Jake Delhomme. Is that fair? Of course it is. Delhomme has 11 interceptions and 10 fumbles for a total of 21. Obviouly Delhomme has more turnovers than ANYONE else on his team. He also has more turnovers than Aaron Brooks. Would you say that Delhomme is MOST responsible for the Panthers losses?

Let's take it a step further. I've looked at 10 QB's in the league and they all have more turnovers than ANYONE else on their team. Would you like to say that they are MOST to blame for their teams losses? As a matter of fact just about EVERY QB has more turnovers than any player on their team. Are all of these QB's most to blame for their teams losses?

Are you saying that Brooks is unique here? Or would you agree this is common in the NFL and Brooks is no different than Jake Delhomme or ANY other QB? I'm real curious here WhoDat. It sure seems like you're trying to say Brooks is doing something that other good QB's don't and he's just killing the Saints.

I don't think it's fair to compare ANY QB's turnovers to any other player on offense. After all, no other player has the opportunity to turn the ball over like a QB.

I do think it's fair to combine the other 10-players mistakes and compare them to the mistakes by a QB. I say that all of the mistakes added up by the other 10-guys on offense is contributing more to the lack of success on offense than Brooks.

There were a few members like LummOx, Gator, that commented on this discussion in another thread and I would now like to hear from all of you again on what I just posted? Especially LummOx and Gator. I think both of you will be fair.

[Edited on 6/12/2003 by BillyC]

12-05-2003, 07:16 PM	#1
BillyC Banned Join Date: Apr 2004 Posts: 842	For WhoDat and whoever.... WhoDat -- You have told me that Brooks is to blame for the offensive troubles this year. You stated the resaon for that was because he has turned the ball over more than anyone else on the team. Is that correct so far? You also contend that Brooks' turnovers have killed more drives than penalties, dropped passes, and everything else, because you contend these don't neccessarily kill drives. Is that also correct? I think your position is Brooks is MOST to blame. Is that correct? Let's look at your arguement with another QB, like...uh.....Jake Delhomme. Is that fair? Of course it is. Delhomme has 11 interceptions and 10 fumbles for a total of 21. Obviouly Delhomme has more turnovers than ANYONE else on his team. He also has more turnovers than Aaron Brooks. Would you say that Delhomme is MOST responsible for the Panthers losses? Let's take it a step further. I've looked at 10 QB's in the league and they all have more turnovers than ANYONE else on their team. Would you like to say that they are MOST to blame for their teams losses? As a matter of fact just about EVERY QB has more turnovers than any player on their team. Are all of these QB's most to blame for their teams losses? Are you saying that Brooks is unique here? Or would you agree this is common in the NFL and Brooks is no different than Jake Delhomme or ANY other QB? I'm real curious here WhoDat. It sure seems like you're trying to say Brooks is doing something that other good QB's don't and he's just killing the Saints. I don't think it's fair to compare ANY QB's turnovers to any other player on offense. After all, no other player has the opportunity to turn the ball over like a QB. I do think it's fair to combine the other 10-players mistakes and compare them to the mistakes by a QB. I say that all of the mistakes added up by the other 10-guys on offense is contributing more to the lack of success on offense than Brooks. There were a few members like LummOx, Gator, that commented on this discussion in another thread and I would now like to hear from all of you again on what I just posted? Especially LummOx and Gator. I think both of you will be fair. [Edited on 6/12/2003 by BillyC]
BillyC Banned Join Date: Apr 2004 Posts: 842