Lets look at how the Saints have faired against the QBs you listed since Payton/Brees came to New Orleans.

1.Peyton Manning:
2007 Lost 41-10 opening night @ Indy
2009 Won 31-17 in Super Bowl

2.Eli Manning:
2006 Saints won 30-17 @ NY (Giants did not run an offensive play on the Saints side of the field the entire game).
2009 Saints won 48-27 in the Superdome
2011 Saints won 49-24 in the Superdome

3.Aaron Rodgers:
2008 Saints won 59-21 in the Superdome
2011 Saints lost 42-34 on opening night @ Packers

4.Phillip Rivers
2008 Saints won 37-32 in London

5. Michael Vick
2006 Saints won 23-3, (Superdome re-opening game)
Saints won 31-13, (Vicks final game against Saints as a Falcon before dog-fighting conviction; Vick was injuried and did not play against Saints w/Eagles in 2009)

6. Cam Newton
2011 Saints won 30-27 & 45-17

None of those QBs have as good a team as the Saints right now; the only one I am even consider MAY be a loss is Packer game.

The Green Bay game is scary. They have a chip on their shoulders too.. Maybe not like the mountain we're carrying down here, but they sure were supposed to win it all last year...

Numbers don't lie, but my ex sure does.........:wink: