Riddle me this:?
 

I stole this post off of another board. The dude makes a damn good point to me.

Rip it apart guys!!

Riddle me this:?
 

That\'s easy. Sully did what he did while under contract with the Saints, McPhereson didn\'t. I give a **** what he did in college.

:shrug:

Riddle me this:?
 

...something in the lines of embracing skinny girls you just met and ignoring fat chicks that don\'t put out?

Riddle me this:?
 

I\'m not an FSU fan?
Seems to me that Sully\'s immaturity hurt the Saints. McPherson\'s hurt the Seminoles (whom I detest anyway).

For example, if we cut Sully and he goes on to be a hall of fame player for the Falcons, I\'d still detest him for what he did to us.

Riddle me this:?
 

First of all, McPherson didn\'t do his screwing up while making #6 overall money. We\'ve been paying Sullivan, but he hasn\'t been performing.

Second, I\'d be shocked to know anyone didn\'t have questions about whether McPherson has truly put things behind him. The only question left for Sulivan is whether he will even be worth keeping on the team. He will never prove to be worth the 2 first round picks we gave up for him.

The bottomline is McPherson is new and will be given some latitide and time to show us who he is. Sully has already had that chance and is at the end of the rope.

Riddle me this:?
 

I thought this would spark some good conversation. Saints\' fans are nothing if not passionate!!

Both guys are very young, right?

Both made mistakes, right?

Both were considered extremely talented, right?

So, the main difference is Sully screwed up as a Saints and we gave up a lot to get him? Correct?

And McPhearson ... well ... he hasn\'t hurt us yet and we didn\'t give up a lot to get him?

Still, Sully didn\'t tell Micky Loomis and Haslett to give up 2-first round picks for him. Seems like you guys should be mad at Loomis and Haslett for that. Not Jonathan Sullivan.

You should be mad at Sullivan for not doing everything in his power to be the best player he can be. But does Sullivan not deserve another chance like you guys are giving McPhearson?

Riddle me this:?
 

McPherson now has a two year track record of having changed.
The only thing that implies Sully has changed are a couple of mini-camp reports, many of which contradict each other.

McPherson is MUCH further along in proving he regrets the errors of his youth. Sullivan hasn\'t even started yet.

Riddle me this:?
 

I do not know what I could add to all of the other responses except for my own personal opinions -- I completely agree with Scotty -- we wasted 2 #1\'s on Sully; We are paying Sully big bucks currently hurting our cap -- Sully is a drag on the team\'s morale.

Now Mcpherson -- cost us a number 5 and will cost us a number 5 salary; performed well in the Arena league which is a step above college ball, has a chip on his shoulder to prove the NFL he is a claiber QB.

All in all I would say it is completely obvious why we can have different opinions on the 2 subjects.

Riddle me this:?
 

Danno --

You\'ve only got McPhearson\'s word that he\'s changed. Just like Sully has given his word.

Not a lot to go on for either one.

McPherson is MUCH further along in proving he regrets the errors of his youth?????????????

Yeah, well, he commited his \"sin\" MUCH longer ago than what Sully did. Stands to reason that he\'s MUCH further along. But, just because he hasn\'t stolen any checks in a couple of years really doesn\'t indicate he won\'t screw up again.

And McPhearson\'s \"sin\" was a lot worse than Sully.

Riddle me this:?
 

Come on guys ....

Loomis and Haslett gave up 2-first round picks for Sully.

Jonathan had nothing to do with that.

Did you blame Ricky Williams for Mika Ditka giving up a whole draft for him? Come on!! That wasn\'t Rickey\'s fault.

If you guys want to blame someone for giving up 2 first round picks ... shouldn\'t you blame Haslett and Loomis?

Jonathan Sullivan\'s fault?????? :D