![]() |
Rate the Draft
FF would have created a poll. So in his honor, how do you rate the draft?
|
Re: Rate the Draft
No flash. Strong players with some versatility. B- potential but mostly C+ until proven which is what you want IMO. Take the given. Start reaching for some savior that rarely happens and that's when the hole can't be un-dug.
|
Re: Rate the Draft
Quote:
|
Re: Rate the Draft
Love the players, but we've got to get out of this trend of borrowing so much future draft capital...
|
Re: Rate the Draft
I voted C ... the players we got have great upside, but all the moving around and not grabbing a wideout does concern me. Sure hope this draft pans out but right now it feels like a 50/50 proposition.
|
Re: Rate the Draft
Quote:
They have done that forever. Not a bad strategy either. Being in debt is not a bad thing when at some point like a couple years ago we basically hit a bunch of home runs. It was probably the best Saints draft of all time. The teams with the best picks and lots of them often suck to the point where nothing is going to help them. Poor leadership. |
Re: Rate the Draft
I’m a B- the players we really wanted got snatched up I few picks before but we biotched till the cows came home for our guard play and we filled that. We needed backer we filled that
Wasn’t expecting a TE at all so good luck with Dayton flyer baller. The QB in the last trade will be a dud. But it’s his athleticism that they pulled the trigger on . I believe he ran all over the national champions on a Saturday nite. That opened Payton’s eyes , potential possibly but gave away draft pick next year for a cat that would have been on the streets I think. Good job to all who picked the rite guys . I pumped for some [emoji458] Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk |
Re: Rate the Draft
Quote:
We have to hope E Sanders stays healthy or we’ll be rite back where we were for last 2 years Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk |
Re: Rate the Draft
I give it a B. I like the picks, though I still don't like the price that was paid for Trautman. The last guy is a crap shoot. If they drafted him to be a QB it's an awful pick. If they drafted him to be a Taysom clone...well, let's see if he can handle that.
|
Re: Rate the Draft
Quote:
|
Re: Rate the Draft
I rate it "Incomplete".
Until we see more, we don't know. |
Re: Rate the Draft
Don't have a problem with what we drafted. We filled some needs and as for giving up late round picks for Trautman, if he turns out half as good as I think he will, it was worth it. I went back and looked at our 5th thru 7th round picks since 2010 and we have had 25 picks and only 3 are still with the team and another 3 playing on other teams. Once you hit 5th round it's a crap-shoot. You can hit some stars but mostly just PS material.
|
Re: Rate the Draft
Quote:
I have to agree It’s just did we give up a potential pick that may be a need next year that could fall but like u said shake the dice close your eyes and roll the MFers Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk |
Re: Rate the Draft
If this was a math quiz getting 4( actual draft picks) out of 9( 5 draft picks total given up last year, this year, and next year) you would fail that quiz.Also, it's not set in stone these picks work out. I would give it a D simply for these facts.
|
Re: Rate the Draft
Quote:
|
Re: Rate the Draft
I'm with 76 on the draft. Wait and see approach. It will take a year or two. Saints did ok. I think one or two could have an immediate impact in 2020. The Browns and Raiders seem to "nail" the draft every year.
At this level, all I ever hope for in the draft is that we select quality starters (Ramz, Armstead, David O) for years to come. |
Re: Rate the Draft
Quote:
|
Re: Rate the Draft
Quote:
Quality over quantity, especially for roster that are already very deep. Make no mistake about it, the Saints have one of the deepest rosters top to bottom in the entire league. |
Re: Rate the Draft
I voted C, but I would say C+. I was very happy about Ruiz. I liked the pickup of Baum even with giving up another 3rd rounder. I was ok with Trautman, but thought we gave up a lot. I think it will be worth it if he plays as well in the NFL as he did at small school NCAA. I hated the trade back in for that QB, can't even be bothered to remember his name at the moment. I could go with B-, maybe.
|
Re: Rate the Draft
We need to see how well our new center does if we move McCoy to right guard. I have as good a feeling about him as McCoy last year. But I feel better because the front office knew we needed to upgrade center and guard. We've got a top 3 linebacker and an athletic looking tight end that has me excited. And we got another QB/joker in this draft as well. Nothing is written in stone on these guys but I'm giving them a B+ before I see them on the field.
|
Re: Rate the Draft
Quote:
|
Re: Rate the Draft
Quote:
|
Re: Rate the Draft
A famous quote from one of my Bosses;
Because as we know, there are known knowns ; there are things things we Know. We also know there are know unknowns; That is to say we know there are some things we do not know. I felt certain we would pick one of the available LB’s at 24, but Ruiz at 24 has to be the best football/team pick. If our QB, any one of our QB’s, can have .5- 1 second additional time in the pocket ... And then have the ability to step up into the center of pocket with dominant guards and center that allow the QB’s move up ... Priority 1 from Coach, GM and scouting. Additionally if we can get the Oline working better for the power run game where opposing teams have to respect the running game between the tackles it will create even more mismatches for our offensive weapons. Can’t wait to see the 2 TE set with Cook and Trautman, Thomas and Sanders with Kamara or Murray out the backfield. What Defensive Coordinators nightmares are made of. With so few real holes to fill I think they did a good job filling those needs and adding depth to the roster. On giving up 4th 5th 6th and 7th For Trautman, what are chances any of those pick would have been anything other than camp bodies with the strength of our current roster ... “There things we know” The QB pick ... “We also know the are know unknowns”; Defer to the Coach and Scouting staff. If Taysom comes out as the heir apparent after Brees maybe it makes sense to have similar style backup QB. Not drafting a WR in round 1 or 3 ... Football/Team priorities. Guess they felt FA WR is a known known rather selecting and WR early that is known unknown See WR as a possibly in the draft plan for next year. I voted “Good but not spectacular” ... Granted selections where not liked by all on this board but hard to argue with the success the Saints have had trades and draft selections in the last 4 years. |
Re: Rate the Draft
Just read this, the last time the saints had only 4 draft picks was in 2009. We all know what happened that year boys and girls.[emoji512]with the [emoji471]
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk |
Re: Rate the Draft
I remember when Taysom Hill first joined the team. His pocket presence and his passing skills were below par. Now he looks like an entirely different guy back there. I'm not saying that Taysom or Tommy Stevens is our future QB, but Payton likes to develop things from the ground up... so the idea that Payton has no intention of using TS as a QB is misguided. If Brees sticks around for a couple more years, Tommy Stevens can learn the position really quickly. I think Payton sees him as a younger Taysom Hill with more time to develop him. He may very well use him in other roles like WR, but I wouldn't exclude QB from the equation.
|
Re: Rate the Draft
Solid B for now(GOOD but not spectacular).
Nothing against Cesar but I've always felt quality starting interior lineman can be found in the middle rounds. It was a good draft overall. All 3 should become eventual starters. |
Re: Rate the Draft
Not a lot of holes on the Saints. Ruiz will be a starter. Baun will be given an opportunity to start. Trautman will get some snaps and could develop into the future TE. Stevens was a swing at an athletic guy who posses some of the same skills as next years starting QB Hill. All of the picks seem like good people. With the lack of a normal off season, rookies will be further behind the curve than usual. All that said, I would grade it as a C-.
|
Re: Rate the Draft
Quote:
What would your definition of an A be? Seven out of seven starters or something along those lines? I'm honestly curious. |
Re: Rate the Draft
We will love TE Trautman. Love having interchangable C/Guards.
And love LB Braun if what I read him to be is true when he was being projected at #24 or so. We've hit a grandslam, slamdunk, and whatever the equivalent in socceer! Couldn't have drafted better! And normally, I can. Just not since 2017. So, sit back and enjoy. Nothing to complain about here. |
Re: Rate the Draft
Quote:
As for 7th round, I say let SP play. Let 'em in the game, coach. |
Re: Rate the Draft
Giving up draft picks to make the right picks isn't bad. If you have faith in your talent scouting, there is nothing wrong with that approach. You really have two approaches.. take a wide number of selections and hope you hit on some... or have faith in your talent scouting and make those few important choices. Neither approach is either right or wrong... comes with both pros and cons. If you miss on those few selections, you've ****ed up your whole draft. If you hit, you win. Grading the draft right now is a waste of time.
|
Re: Rate the Draft
Quote:
So, I respect your opinion but I like mine better. :banana: |
Re: Rate the Draft
Wasn’t thrilled about trading the picks but after thinking about it I figure what else would we do with them. We have a pretty stacked roster and I think there’s a better chance at landing a FA that can make the roster than any of those late round picks.
|
Re: Rate the Draft
Quote:
|
Re: Rate the Draft
Quote:
|
Re: Rate the Draft
Quote:
If we weren’t in a “win now” scenario I definitely would not be happy about it but considering the circumstances I’m ok with it. |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:36 AM. |
Copyright 1997 - 2020 - BlackandGold.com