Re: P Manning or A Peterson?
 

I think AP doesn't qualify because he was injured at the very end of the season and didn't miss any time. Otherwise, it would be a hard decision, but I think AP would take it. It will be Manning.

Re: P Manning or A Peterson?
 

Peyton Manning - Comeback Player of the Year
Peyton Manning - Most Valuable Player
Adrian Peterson - Most Valuable Modern Day Slave.

Re: P Manning or A Peterson?
 

Denver has done what the Vikings tried to do. If they don't win a championship this year they still have no long term solution at QB. As we know Manning is great at winning games but championships are another story.

Peyton achieved best ever before injury
Peterson achieved best ever after injury
Both exceptional but I gotta give the vote to AP

Re: P Manning or A Peterson?
 

AP should get Comeback Player and Manning should get MVP because Broncos wouldn't be in position they are without him.

Too bad Vikings didnt play Saints this year! Against our defense AP would have gotten a huge chunk of what he needed! Of course, someone would then have said that his record needed an asterisk since he played against the Saints!

Re: P Manning or A Peterson?
 

Come on 'Bama, that isn't necessary.

Re: P Manning or A Peterson?
 

Neither was his comments about comparing his situation to slavery. I know, tit-for-tat is a bit childish, but oh well. He asked for it and I'm happy to oblige.

Re: P Manning or A Peterson?
 

Yeah, I've gathered that much. Carry on, 'Bama. :rolleyes:

Re: P Manning or A Peterson?
 

My name's not 'Bama.

Re: P Manning or A Peterson?
 

Id tend to disagree that the Broncs wouldn't be in the playoffs without Peyton. The Broncos went with Tebow last season. AP is the only offensive threat on that team, yet approaching an epic record one year removed from a devastating knee injury. Take AP out, and the Vikes would be staring at 3-13 IMO. Having both AP and Harvin out at once would be too difficult for Vikes fans to fathom.