Penalty or not? Bengals P Huber out for year
 

Y! SPORTS

he gets drilled

Re: Penalty or not? Bengals P Huber out for year
 

If they want to be considered a defensless player then don't play defense. If the punter/kicker is attempting to tackle the other team he is fair game and better be ready cause that is every blockers dream. If they want to declare him defenseless then he should not be allowed to make a tackle or any progression towards the ball, just kick and get out of the way.

Re: Penalty or not? Bengals P Huber out for year
 

That is a NASTY hit. Looks like a clean hit though.

http://usatthebiglead.files.wordpres...lers.gif?w=600

Re: Penalty or not? Bengals P Huber out for year
 

The only thing I wonder if he gets hit with the helmet or just the shoulder. If its the shoulder then its a legal hit and just too bad he got injured. If its a hit with the helmet then its a penlty. Most importantly I hope he has a speedy recovery. A fractured vertabrae is no joke.

Re: Penalty or not? Bengals P Huber out for year
 

Wow, that was brutal like getting hit by a car. Hopes for a speedy recovery.

Re: Penalty or not? Bengals P Huber out for year
 

Wow that is so close to going either way.

I expect Goodell will probably fine him anyway. It was borderline unnecessary. The dude is the freaking punter.

Its also so close to that other rule about peel back blocks.

Re: Penalty or not? Bengals P Huber out for year
 

I'm with this, that's my take on it. My reaction isn't even worrying whether it's a legal hit or not, my reaction is, uh, WHY? You can easily take him out the play without sending him to the freaking hospital for a week. Garvin must be a real tough guy -- ooooh he decked a freaking defenseless punter. I mean if you view these types of one-on-one football things philosophically, as man vs. man, a test of physicality, like gladiators or wrestling or rugby blah blah blah, well that hit certainly didn't prove anything about Garvin.

Re: Penalty or not? Bengals P Huber out for year
 

I agree. He could just as well have shoved him with two hands and the effect on the play would be the same.

Re: Penalty or not? Bengals P Huber out for year
 

Re: Penalty or not? Bengals P Huber out for year
 

He was not penalized for helmet to helmet, or how hard he hit him. In the rules a punter is considered a defenseless player <full stop>... Yep, even when he is trying to tackle and you cant hit him above the pads.

Fine.... Label kickers non-football players and make them run off the field after they punt. I doubt Garvin even knew he was the punter... Saw an opposing player and just nailed him.

Re: Penalty or not? Bengals P Huber out for year
 

yep

Y! SPORTS

I think he should have been fined for the area he hit him, not this defenseless player crap
Maybe punters should wear a different color jersey so players know not to him them.
pink perhaps

Re: Penalty or not? Bengals P Huber out for year
 

Horrific.
Hope the guy recovers.

I foresee a rule change. Not sure how they will do it but something like a slight costume identifier for punters/kickers. But, but these guys have gotta know it is a jungle out there and what can occur.

Re: Penalty or not? Bengals P Huber out for year
 

Look who's the big bully when the punter isn't looking.... SMH

Re: Penalty or not? Bengals P Huber out for year
 

It looks almost identical to the hit we put on Kurt Warner in 2009. That was a legal hit...right?

Re: Penalty or not? Bengals P Huber out for year
 

Yeah it looks like it, except for the fact that the Warner hit was lower in the midsection, angled more from the side -- this hit is full-on frontal direct at his shoulders/neck, the guy hits him like ten times harder than McCray, and the punter is like 20 pounds lighter than Warner...otherwise they are identical hits I suppose