TheDeuce |
03-02-2006 12:10 PM |
Quote:
Deuce I understand you trust Kiper's word and why not the guy seems to have the authority on the matter but he is not in fallable. I wish I could see what he said about a guy like Heath Shuler when he left Tenn. The Redskins picked him with their third pick in the first round. I can assume that the reports on the guy were extremely positive and all. But in the end....well...you know. My deal here is character. I simply like Cutler's attitude a lot more than the others. Outside of the fact that he has the tools to succeed... with what I saw him do in Vandy (which wasn't much but it looked good to me.) and how he has approached the NFL situation makes me feel like this guy has the leadership skills needed to succeed. Especially with the Saints.
One more thing...I will not by any means be upset if we do get Leinart. Good for us if we do....he has proven that he knows how to win. The deal for me is that the NFL is different and I just feel that Cutler's character would benefit the Saints more. Remember this is New Orleans...the fans here are loyal but after so many years of futility...they also expect results. Cutler seems like the type of guy that can handle the pressure this city imposes on the team. Again, this is obviously my opinion.
|
Fatius, I respect that opinion and I guess only time will tell whether or not Cutler has "it." I just honestly think he doesn't. I think the guy is very athletic as can be seen from his respectable 40-time, and his impressive bench press numbers, but there's a lot more to being a quarterback than having a good attitude and athletic skills. A quarterback still has to be able to throw the ball, and that's where I think Cutler falls short of the others. He just isn't a very accurate QB. The biggest knocks on him are that he has poor footwork, makes poor decisions, and is not as accurate as some scouts would like. Sure he's got a big arm, but if he can't actually hit his WRs with his big throws, then what good is he?
Yes, I know Mel Kiper is not God, I just respect his opinion more than any other analyst because I believe he's studied more draft stuff than anybody else. I mean that's his whole job, and he does it for the premiere sports company in the nation. But yes, he is fallible. I'm sure he's made a lot of mistakes with his predictions. However, one thing I can tell you is that Heath Shuler probably wasn't as highly rated as Peyton Manning, but Leinart is. And I'm sure Cutler has "a good attitude" and everything, but what's to say that Leinart's isn't as good or better? Here's a guy who has said in an interview that he would be excited and honored to be the face of this franchise and their rebuilding process. That sounds like the kind of attitude that I want from my QB.
I also believe that a good attitude in the game of football is built through winning. Cutler has never had a winning season, Leinart has only lost two games in college. I believe that this team needs a guy who has a winning attitude, somebody who is used to winning, and that's all that Leinart does.
|