Is Brees comeback QB of the year?

LongTimeFan · 12-28-2006, 09:28 PM

43% of the people who voted on the poll agree with me in saying yes.

Go to the link and cast your vote, Brees is ahead by a large margin, let's help in keeping it that way..

Others QB that others have voted for..

Palmer, 5%
McNair, 14%
Pennington, 15%
Garcia, 24% (What a season he's having, IMO he comes in second behind Brees, I put Brees ahead of him because of the injury Brees had last season and that not to many people thought he'd ever be the same, he proved them wrong..)

JOESAM2002 · 12-28-2006, 09:51 PM

Link????

LongTimeFan · 12-28-2006, 10:17 PM

http://sports-ak.espn.go.com/nfl/index

Here's the link....

Teechauze · 12-29-2006, 10:26 AM

As great a season Brees is having, To me Jeff Garcia deserves Comeback Player.
Brees had that injury, but when he left San Deigo, he was already a proven player and the top Free Agent on the market. There was more than just us bidding for him.
Garcia, on the other hand, played in the shadows of Steve Young and Joe Montana at San Fransisco. After that, he plays for Cleveland (only starts 10 games) and basically plays back-up to Joey Harrington in that NFL wasteland Detroit.
Then a struggling Philly team has their #1 stud QB go down and when Garcia steps in, everyone write Philly off.
But just the opposite happens. Garcia steps up bigtime and the Eagles are right back in the playoff picture.

ScottyRo · 12-29-2006, 10:57 AM

Garcia being Comeback Player is as absurd as Romo going to the Pro Bowl. Garcia has been playing well, but he has only done it for 4 or 5 games. That's not long enough to evaluate whether he is really on some sort of comeback or if he's just on a hot streak.

If the Pro Bowl voting was done like it should be done (after the season or at least after most of the season was played), I think Romo's chances of getting in would be lessened. He, like Garcia, had 4 or 5 good games. Now he has cooled off and isn't playing as well.

Brees on the other hand was written off by coaches like Shottenheimer and Saban in favor of a QB with very little, if any, experience and a QB who was recovering from 3 torn ligaments in his knee. That shows just how little NFL personnel thought of Brees' chance of recovery. Now he's leading the NFL in passing and taking a team with a woeful history to one of, if not THE, best seasons ever. I'd say that is one heck of a comeback.

Palmer, McNair and Pennington are all good choices for the honor - especially Pennington for all the troubles he's had the past couple of years. However, none of these are having the year that Brees is having.

frankeefrank · 12-29-2006, 11:10 AM

I would love for Brees to win...
Heck I wish The Saints could sweep every award.
But,
the fact is... Brees never missed a game. So what was he coming back from?
If we gave awards to guys who were "written off" or guys "people didn't believe in," wouldn't that taint the likes of Garrison Hearst who won the award after suffering a career-threatening injury?

xan · 12-29-2006, 11:25 AM

Brees was an injured cast-off who was even rejected by Miami. He may have had a decent year last season (not a playoff year!), but given the injury he had and the situation he was "relegated" to, I'd say he's done more to deserve both MVP and Comeback than any player that could be named.

WVSaint · 12-29-2006, 08:38 PM

how about we just give it to culpepper in miami as a way of saying "thank you"

12-29-2006, 10:26 AM	#4
Teechauze Rookie Join Date: Dec 2006 Location: Loreauville, LA Posts: 19	As great a season Brees is having, To me Jeff Garcia deserves Comeback Player. Brees had that injury, but when he left San Deigo, he was already a proven player and the top Free Agent on the market. There was more than just us bidding for him. Garcia, on the other hand, played in the shadows of Steve Young and Joe Montana at San Fransisco. After that, he plays for Cleveland (only starts 10 games) and basically plays back-up to Joey Harrington in that NFL wasteland Detroit. Then a struggling Philly team has their #1 stud QB go down and when Garcia steps in, everyone write Philly off. But just the opposite happens. Garcia steps up bigtime and the Eagles are right back in the playoff picture.
	Phil Never forget where we came from---[url=http://www.nosaintshistory.com]New Orleans Saints History.com[/url]

12-29-2006, 11:10 AM	#6
frankeefrank 500th Post Join Date: Jul 2003 Posts: 775	I would love for Brees to win... Heck I wish The Saints could sweep every award. But, the fact is... Brees never missed a game. So what was he coming back from? If we gave awards to guys who were "written off" or guys "people didn't believe in," wouldn't that taint the likes of Garrison Hearst who won the award after suffering a career-threatening injury?
frankeefrank 500th Post Join Date: Jul 2003 Posts: 775

12-28-2006, 09:28 PM	#1
LongTimeFan Moderator Join Date: Jan 2005 Location: Louisiana Posts: 2,403	Is Brees comeback QB of the year? 43% of the people who voted on the poll agree with me in saying yes. Go to the link and cast your vote, Brees is ahead by a large margin, let's help in keeping it that way.. Others QB that others have voted for.. Palmer, 5% McNair, 14% Pennington, 15% Garcia, 24% (What a season he's having, IMO he comes in second behind Brees, I put Brees ahead of him because of the injury Brees had last season and that not to many people thought he'd ever be the same, he proved them wrong..)

Latest Blogs
2023 New Orleans Saints: Training Camp Last Blog: 08-01-2023 By: MarchingOn Puck the Fro Browl! Last Blog: 02-05-2023 By: neugey CFP: "Just Keep Doing What You're Doing" Last Blog: 12-08-2022 By: neugey

12-28-2006, 09:51 PM	#2
JOESAM2002 1000 Posts + Join Date: Aug 2002 Location: CRYSTAL BEACH TEXAS Posts: 4,100	Link????

12-28-2006, 10:17 PM	#3
LongTimeFan Moderator Join Date: Jan 2005 Location: Louisiana Posts: 2,403	http://sports-ak.espn.go.com/nfl/index Here's the link....

12-29-2006, 10:57 AM	#5
ScottyRo 1000 Posts + Join Date: Jun 2002 Location: Williamsburg, VA (ugh, the food here) Posts: 1,704	Garcia being Comeback Player is as absurd as Romo going to the Pro Bowl. Garcia has been playing well, but he has only done it for 4 or 5 games. That's not long enough to evaluate whether he is really on some sort of comeback or if he's just on a hot streak. If the Pro Bowl voting was done like it should be done (after the season or at least after most of the season was played), I think Romo's chances of getting in would be lessened. He, like Garcia, had 4 or 5 good games. Now he has cooled off and isn't playing as well. Brees on the other hand was written off by coaches like Shottenheimer and Saban in favor of a QB with very little, if any, experience and a QB who was recovering from 3 torn ligaments in his knee. That shows just how little NFL personnel thought of Brees' chance of recovery. Now he's leading the NFL in passing and taking a team with a woeful history to one of, if not THE, best seasons ever. I'd say that is one heck of a comeback. Palmer, McNair and Pennington are all good choices for the honor - especially Pennington for all the troubles he's had the past couple of years. However, none of these are having the year that Brees is having.

12-29-2006, 11:25 AM	#7
xan Professor Crab and Site Donor 2014 Join Date: Oct 2004 Location: Princeton Posts: 3,369 Blog Entries: 34	Brees was an injured cast-off who was even rejected by Miami. He may have had a decent year last season (not a playoff year!), but given the injury he had and the situation he was "relegated" to, I'd say he's done more to deserve both MVP and Comeback than any player that could be named.

12-29-2006, 08:38 PM	#8
WVSaint 500th Post Join Date: Dec 2005 Location: West Virginia Posts: 807	how about we just give it to culpepper in miami as a way of saying "thank you"