Re: Grading Payton
 

99 right now. I am interested to see what he (& Loomis) does this off season & how they handle certain aspects of the draft, UFA & RFA.

Re: Grading Payton
 

Sorry guys and gals but I only gave him a B and it's because he's also had a couple of really Mediocre seasons. I know he's made alot of first for us but I think he has to follow up the Superbowl win with at least another appearance in the NFC Championship Game. I mean 3 NFC Championship games in 5 years who woulda thunk it! Then I'll give him the A+ but he's a great coach and has another 30 years in him to do it for us. Can everyone imagine the Saint Legacy after the next 30 or 40 years with Payton at the helm. Damn, just damn!

Re: Grading Payton
 

Why isn't there an F on this. I want to grade him an F for making a stupid call in the SB. YOu don't call an onside kick to start a half, LMAO.

Re: Grading Payton
 

He led the Saints to a Super Bowl victory! Enough said!

Re: Grading Payton
 

Normally Superbowl means you're exempted from your freshmen seminars; but Brian Billick, an "offensive genius" won a Superbowl with a great defense and he's not what I'd consider an "A" coach...

What makes Payton great was that he did it on his known strengths, changing the "culture" upon his arrival, and the statement he made with the move to get Williams as DC...

And he looks like he's addict when it comes to winning Superbowl trophies...

I'm down with that...

Re: Grading Payton
 

@ breesfan27's avatar: "You're not fully clean unless you're ZEST-FULLY CLEAN!!"

Re: Grading Payton
 

That call was risky and it could have gone either way. Saints won Super Bowl "Xtra Large 4", bottom line.

Re: Grading Payton
 

B+ ALSO CHER. Way to many lucky bounces through out the season for an A. He is not done. Lets see him load up even more now that the core is intact. youth movement is just getting started.

Re: Grading Payton
 

I give you an F-.

You are no longer a Saints fan. You've been banned for a year.
Have fun pulling for the Dirty Birds.


:^p

Re: Grading Payton
 

I'd give him an A just for the fact that he evaluates and impoves his coaching just as much as he does with the team. He's getting better and the team with him.