New Orleans Saints Forums - blackandgold.com

New Orleans Saints Forums - blackandgold.com (https://blackandgold.com/community/)

- Saints (https://blackandgold.com/saints/)

- - Back-up QB options? (https://blackandgold.com/saints/25605-back-up-qb-options.html)

Re: Back-up QB options?

Quote:

Originally Posted by CantonLegend (Post 213707)

lmao garcia over brunell

you guys are goofy

judging brunell on 1 game against a top defense with all of our backups in.....shame on all of you

Do you even know football? BRUNELL IS DONE. He is 73 years old. Chase needs a chance but he needs a vet to push him. Brunell needs a nurse to push him.

Re: Back-up QB options?

Quote:

Originally Posted by D_it_up (Post 213768)

Must I explain one more time how crappy and sluggish the Carolina defense played in that game? I don't care if they were top 5 in defense or not. Their play didn't show it. Brunell couldn't complete anything downfield even when receivers were open and he was playing with players that he practiced with regularly, so there should have been some sort of rhythm, but there wasn't. Sure, he may have been accurate in the past, but he showed no signs of it in that game. You say arguing after one game is dumb and then try to bring Drew's name in this? Now who is the one with the dumb comment? Drew is a starter and we knew that he was better than that game and that he would improve. No one here can say with any certainty that Brunell has still got it or if he doesn't. We have our opinions, and we voice them. In my opinion, if Brees were to miss four games in a regular season, the Saints would be lucky to win one game. If they did win more than that, it wouldn't be because of the arm of Mark Brunell.

The the Carolina D might have collectively had a bad day, but Brunell, with no recent starts under his belt and playing with mostly 2nd and 3rd stringers couldn't? Surely you see how this empties the argument completely, right?

Re: Back-up QB options?

Quote:

Originally Posted by voodooido (Post 213769)

Do you even know football? BRUNELL IS DONE. He is 73 years old. Chase needs a chance but he needs a vet to push him. Brunell needs a nurse to push him.

Eh? What's that sonny? Get offa my grass whipper snapper. LMAO

Re: Back-up QB options?

Quote:

Originally Posted by saintfan (Post 213775)

It empties the argument no more than going by 2 plays and a resume that hasn't been added to in 4 years.

Re: Back-up QB options?

Quote:

Originally Posted by D_it_up (Post 213777)

It empties the argument no more than going by 2 plays and a resume that hasn't been added to in 4 years.

that is just a piece of my argument where as it is your entire argument

Re: Back-up QB options?

Quote:

Originally Posted by voodooido (Post 213769)

Do you even know football? BRUNELL IS DONE. He is 73 years old. Chase needs a chance but he needs a vet to push him. Brunell needs a nurse to push him.

:doh:

thats one thing i miss about SR.com.....i always loved being called out for not watching the games or knowing nothing about football

bummer

Re: Back-up QB options?

Quote:

Originally Posted by D_it_up (Post 213777)

It empties the argument no more than going by 2 plays and a resume that hasn't been added to in 4 years.

Well then argument A is no more valid than argument B. Rekon we're down then to opinion, unless there is more evidence to go on. Brunell has been a successful starter, and there is really no valid evidence to suggest that he can't spot start successfully if needed. That's my take, and I'm not biased in either direction on the guy.

Re: Back-up QB options?

wooohooo.....this thread has helped me achieve the activity award.

id like to thank all the little people....now i can add it to my collection

http://www.wuma.uk.com/news/wp-conte...feb-2009-2.jpg

Re: Back-up QB options?

Damnit where's MY award? I'm active...kinda...I like to argue at least, which should count for SOMEthing around here, especially in the off season.

Re: Back-up QB options?

Quote:

Originally Posted by saintfan (Post 213791)

Damnit where's MY award? I'm active...kinda...I like to argue at least, which should count for SOMEthing around here, especially in the off season.

here you can have this one out of my collection.....i dont need it anymore

http://lh5.ggpht.com/_Edkz1MU-UKg/SJ...801-015218.jpg

you're welcome