Grading the Saints......

BillyCarpenter1 · 10-19-2003, 10:03 AM

Thought it would be interesting to grade the Saints players and coaches and see how some others would grade them. Here's my grades --

Offense
WR 80 Pathon, Jerome - B
83 Stallworth, Donte' - C
87 Horn, Joe - B
LT 72 Gandy, Wayne - D
C 62 Fontenot, Jerry - C
64 Jacox, Kendyl - C
RG 65 Bentley, - A
RT 68 Riley, Victor - C
TE 85 Conwell, Ernie - C
82 Williams, Boo - C
QB 2 Brooks, Aaron - B
RB 26 McAllister, Deuce - A
FB 44 Smith, Terrelle - C

Overall Grade for Offense: C+

Defense
DE 94 Grant, Charles - B
90 Smith, Kenny - C
DT 97 Sullivan, Johnathan -C
DT 91 Jackson, Grady -B
DE 98 Whitehead, Willie - C
SLB 54 Smith, Darrin - D
MLB 56 Ruff, Orlando - C
WLB 59 Rodgers, Derrick - C
RCB 22 Thomas, Fred - D
33 Ambrose, Ashley - D
SS 20 Bellamy, Jay - C
FS 34 Jones, Tebucky - C
LCB 21 Carter, Dale - B

Overall Defensive Grade - C-

-

Coaches
Jim Haslett - C
Mike McCarthy - C
Rick Venturi - C
Overall Coaching Grade: C

whowatches · 10-19-2003, 10:24 AM

I agree for the most part except for the following

Jerome and Joe get a C+ in my book. I wanted to give them a B-, but B means \'above average\' , and neither of them are playing that way.

The same thing goes for Aaron. Although I do not blame our record on him solely, I can\'t justify a B rating. He gets a plain ole C for \'average\'.

McCarthy doesn\'t deserve a C in my eyes -- too much talent on his side of the ball. I\'d have to give him a big, fat, stinkin\' D.

whowatches · 10-19-2003, 10:26 AM

Oh, and give Grady a B+ for his efforts thus far. He\'s almost been playing to his first round potential. I could also see Charles Grant heading for an A rating in the next couple of games, especially if his momma stays on his rear end.

lumm0x · 10-19-2003, 08:32 PM

At first hand glance Billy the only changes I\'d make are dropping Bentley to a B. He has been pretty solid but just doesn\'t seem to have the same mean demeanor on the field that he had last year. I don\'t think losing was sitting well with him. And secondly, as much as I have criticized his play every year, Bellamy gets a B as well. He is playing better than I would have guessed. Give him a point and take one away from Tebucky. A \"D\" is almost too good for what he\'s done.

Although today\'s performance gets everyone a extra point.

[Edited on 20/10/2003 by lumm0x]

10-19-2003, 10:03 AM	#1
BillyCarpenter1 Banned Join Date: Oct 2004 Posts: 2,209	Grading the Saints...... Thought it would be interesting to grade the Saints players and coaches and see how some others would grade them. Here's my grades -- Offense WR 80 Pathon, Jerome - B 83 Stallworth, Donte' - C 87 Horn, Joe - B LT 72 Gandy, Wayne - D C 62 Fontenot, Jerry - C 64 Jacox, Kendyl - C RG 65 Bentley, - A RT 68 Riley, Victor - C TE 85 Conwell, Ernie - C 82 Williams, Boo - C QB 2 Brooks, Aaron - B RB 26 McAllister, Deuce - A FB 44 Smith, Terrelle - C Overall Grade for Offense: C+ Defense DE 94 Grant, Charles - B 90 Smith, Kenny - C DT 97 Sullivan, Johnathan -C DT 91 Jackson, Grady -B DE 98 Whitehead, Willie - C SLB 54 Smith, Darrin - D MLB 56 Ruff, Orlando - C WLB 59 Rodgers, Derrick - C RCB 22 Thomas, Fred - D 33 Ambrose, Ashley - D SS 20 Bellamy, Jay - C FS 34 Jones, Tebucky - C LCB 21 Carter, Dale - B Overall Defensive Grade - C- - Coaches Jim Haslett - C Mike McCarthy - C Rick Venturi - C Overall Coaching Grade: C
BillyCarpenter1 Banned Join Date: Oct 2004 Posts: 2,209

10-19-2003, 10:24 AM	#2
whowatches 500th Post Join Date: Jun 2003 Posts: 575	Grading the Saints...... I agree for the most part except for the following Jerome and Joe get a C+ in my book. I wanted to give them a B-, but B means \'above average\' , and neither of them are playing that way. The same thing goes for Aaron. Although I do not blame our record on him solely, I can\'t justify a B rating. He gets a plain ole C for \'average\'. McCarthy doesn\'t deserve a C in my eyes -- too much talent on his side of the ball. I\'d have to give him a big, fat, stinkin\' D.
whowatches 500th Post Join Date: Jun 2003 Posts: 575

10-19-2003, 10:26 AM	#3
whowatches 500th Post Join Date: Jun 2003 Posts: 575	Grading the Saints...... Oh, and give Grady a B+ for his efforts thus far. He\'s almost been playing to his first round potential. I could also see Charles Grant heading for an A rating in the next couple of games, especially if his momma stays on his rear end.
whowatches 500th Post Join Date: Jun 2003 Posts: 575

10-19-2003, 08:32 PM	#4
lumm0x Resident antediluvian Join Date: Jul 2002 Posts: 2,026	Grading the Saints...... At first hand glance Billy the only changes I\'d make are dropping Bentley to a B. He has been pretty solid but just doesn\'t seem to have the same mean demeanor on the field that he had last year. I don\'t think losing was sitting well with him. And secondly, as much as I have criticized his play every year, Bellamy gets a B as well. He is playing better than I would have guessed. Give him a point and take one away from Tebucky. A \"D\" is almost too good for what he\'s done. Although today\'s performance gets everyone a extra point. [Edited on 20/10/2003 by lumm0x]

Latest Blogs
2023 New Orleans Saints: Training Camp Last Blog: 08-01-2023 By: MarchingOn Puck the Fro Browl! Last Blog: 02-05-2023 By: neugey CFP: "Just Keep Doing What You're Doing" Last Blog: 12-08-2022 By: neugey