WhoDat!656

Lets look at how the Saints have faired against the QBs you listed since Payton/Brees came to New Orleans.

1.Peyton Manning:
2007 Lost 41-10 opening night @ Indy
2009 Won 31-17 in Super Bowl

2.Eli Manning:
2006 Saints won 30-17 @ NY (Giants did not run an offensive play on the Saints side of the field the entire game).
2009 Saints won 48-27 in the Superdome
2011 Saints won 49-24 in the Superdome

3.Aaron Rodgers:
2008 Saints won 59-21 in the Superdome
2011 Saints lost 42-34 on opening night @ Packers

4.Phillip Rivers
2008 Saints won 37-32 in London

5. Michael Vick
2006 Saints won 23-3, (Superdome re-opening game)
Saints won 31-13, (Vicks final game against Saints as a Falcon before dog-fighting conviction; Vick was injuried and did not play against Saints w/Eagles in 2009)

6. Cam Newton
2011 Saints won 30-27 & 45-17

None of those QBs have as good a team as the Saints right now; the only one I am even consider MAY be a loss is Packer game.

"A Veteran is someone who, at one point in his life, wrote a blank check made payable to "The United States of America" for an amount of "up to and including my life."