Clarke

Here's how I would break those guys down...

The way that I see it, Roby and Morgan are in a one-on-one battle for a roster spot. They are similar style receivers that will also be used on special teams if they make the 46. Right now, I give the advantage to Roby based on performance in the preseason games, special teams contributions, and the veteran edge. Morgan does have potential, but he has to be solid through the rest of the pre-season.

I really like Tanner so far this preseason. He's shown a lot of good things, and a couple more performances like he has had make him hard to cut. I don't know if he makes the starting four, but I hope the Saints find a way to keep him around.

Toon has an excellent shot at the fourth receiver spot once he gets on the field. Worst case scenario I see is Toon as the fifth receiver on the roster. If he's not ready yet, then Roby probably replaces him as the fourth. Maybe Tanner.

Arrington, I remain skeptical about. The guy has trouble staying healthy, and has never really shown me anything astonishing on the field. The coaches have obviously kept him around this long because they see something in him though, and they know more than me. I would love for him to get healthy and prove me wrong, I just don't know if its going to happen.

So in a dream scenario, I run with Toon at fourth, Roby at fifth/teams, and Tanner on the PR.