The Dude

With the history the Saints have we are full of I can't believe it moments. I was pretty much expect anything and nothing surprises me anymore. The score by Smith and the run by Lynch were sucky, but definitely not one of the biggest oh **** moments. Must be a lot of younguns voting. For me it was the river city relay. That was so amazing, but somehow I know when we lined up to kick the extra point we would miss it. God Im still pissed off about that.

onebyone

They all suck, but I have hurt less from personal tragedies than I did for the River City Relay. It gets my vote.

Saint_LB

The day that I heard we were getting Steve Walsh and gave up a ton of draft picks was my lowest moment as a Saint fan. I admittedly am an Ole Miss homer, and thought John Fourcade was indeed Johnny B. Goode, and I was so pleased that Fourcade was finally going to get the chance he deserved.

Fourcade may have been the original guy that ESPN homed-in on during the draft that didn't get drafted...or the original "snub". His college coach made a comment prior to the draft that, IMO, made pro GM's shy away. He was a "black sheep" his whole NFL career.

Anyway...Mora announced that he would be the starter that year, and Hebert took his football and went home. Fourcade got 3 games as the starter before Mora threw in the towel and mortgaged the farm for noodle arm.

Whether you think you can or think you can't...you're right!

alexonfyre

The missed extra point was definitely the worst from history, because I remember watching it. But overall we had a great chance to make it to our second super bowl and win our first on the road playoff victory, all we had to do was stop Alex Smith (ALEX G.D. SMITH!!) for less than a minute, and we couldn't do it. I absolutely could NOT believe it.

Stealthman

So far, no one has picked the Mike Lansford FG in the poll.

I guess I understand why... maybe. It was back in 1983, and many Saints fans weren't following the team (or even born) back then.

But for those who remember, the stage was set when Bum Phillips didn't trust Morten Andersen to make a 50 yd field goal. Morten would have iced the game, and the Saints would have been in the playoffs.

The late sportscaster Wayne Mack recounted: "That was the day Bum quit coaching. When the man John Mecom brought in to lead the team to the promised land fell short, Mecom decided to sell the team. And Bum Phillips lost his fire and motivation."

All water under the bridge, I guess!

Anyway, I'm glad we have the current team, FO and leadership!!!!!

Saint_LB

I will go about this a different way...

I cannot go with the missed extra point, because I am of the opinion that the extra point was missed on purpose!

I remember that I knew at the time the extra point was being attempted that we were already eliminated from playoff contention. The fact that we missed the extra point meant that they got to go home instead of playing an overtime that had no significance in the playoff race. Someone could've got hurt, too.

Missing the extra point put us higher in the next year's draft, so that is why, after considering all of what I just said, I believe the kick was missed intentionally.

I am beginning to believe that I am not remembering that correctly, because if I am correct, then missing that extra point was actually a smart move...not the darkest moment.

Whether you think you can or think you can't...you're right!

Tobias-Reiper

Having been a Saints fan for as long as I have, I don't know that things like giving tons of draft picks for 1 player, or missing a field goal, or a bone headed play qualify as worst moment as a Saints fan.

As a Saints fan, I think the worst I have ever felt watching the Saints play, was the Saints-Giants game after 9/11/2001. The first NFL game after the attack, playing NY at NY. I just wanted the Giants to win that game so bad...

FinSaint

True, but the initial question was: Your WORST "I Can't Believe It" moment with the Saints?

So, it was not about the worst moment as a Saints' fan as you stated... an event related to the Saints that shocked you when it took place was my interpretation of the question at hand.

Tobias-Reiper

... well, pardon me, then.

FinSaint

Don't take it the wrong way man, I just wanted to remind about the initial question and how it was set up, so that this thread wouldn't drift off to something it wasn't meant to be.

Nothing against you or your post.