Saints SB Not Ranked Among Top Ten All Time
 

Super Bowl XLII, 2008 - New York 17, New England 14 - The 10 Best Super Bowls - Photos - SI.com

...although it should be, even with the homer goggles taken off.

Some great games in that list, however.

Re: Saints SB Not Ranked Among Top Ten All Time
 

"If it's the ultimate game, how come they're playing it again next year?" Duane Thomas

Re: Saints SB Not Ranked Among Top Ten All Time
 

Well, on a positive note, it didn't make the 10 Worst SuperBowls list either, Super Bowl XXIV, 1990 - San Francisco 55, Denver 10 - The 10 Worst Super Bowls - Photos - SI.com .

I'm looking at that list, the 10 Best, and for some reason I'm thinking maybe it's because the Saints opponent was Indianapolis. IDK, I'd have to look into it more for anything more definitive.

Re: Saints SB Not Ranked Among Top Ten All Time
 

Funny the Falcons SB was the worst, I always thought Atl had no business in that SB as well and believe Minny would of fought harder.

The one I cant agree with was the 49ers/Chargers SB, while Pitt/San Fran would of been better, that was SB was at least entertaining as saw an end of an era and a team similar to todays Saints team that was fun to watch sometimes.


But now I do have issues on the Best SBs, quite frankly I think any SB with the Patriots in it on this list dont belong there, I watched them and they all felt like they were staged, you could literally predict what was going to happen in each of those games, least the ones New England won.
Its also funny Jets/Colts is on there to, thats 4 SBs right there I firmly believe had some fishy stuff in it, from Unitas throwing that game to Spygate 30 years later.

Re: Saints SB Not Ranked Among Top Ten All Time
 

Jets/Colts make it just because of the Joe Namath prediction-thing & it was the first time the AFL won anything. Earl Morrall started the game for the Colts, Unitas didn't come in until the third qtr after Baltimore was down by a couple of scores.

It was early in Don Shula's coaching career and he just went with the wrong horse (Morrall) in his QB controversy, that probably lost them the SB.

Hindsight is 20/20, of course, :mrgreen:.

Re: Saints SB Not Ranked Among Top Ten All Time
 

Earl Morrall was one of the best quarterbacks in the NFL and was having one of the best seasons all time (up to that point). The Colts had a bad gameplan and were entirely too predictable. In addition, Namath audibled every play, only calling snap counts and formations in the huddles.

Saying this game wasn't one of the all time great games misses the facts as well as the convergence of opposing dynamic forces that transformed professional football. Simplifying the game as merely a win by the AFC is equivalent to characterizing the invention of the assembly line as a bad day for artisan labor.

Re: Saints SB Not Ranked Among Top Ten All Time
 

Morall was an inconsistent starter with four different teams before being given the Colts starting job because Unitas hurt his shoulder. He had the best season of his career, which led rookie H/C, Don Shula, to start what he thought was a 'hot' quarterback in the SuperBowl despite Unitas being able to play. The rest is history.

If the game had been won by Baltimore, it would not be considered one of the top ten. The only reason it makes the list is because that game marked the end of the NFL's dominance over the AFL in championship games up to this point, and Namath's guarantee.

It really is that simple.

Re: Saints SB Not Ranked Among Top Ten All Time
 

I would like to know why the Saints Super Bowl didn't make the list!?

The onside kick alone was a big enough play to put the game on the list.

Re: Saints SB Not Ranked Among Top Ten All Time
 

I dunno I think it could be a factor that the game was quite boring really.

Their was no real big play that happened in that game, the biggest play was an onside kick, which kind of speaks volumes on what kind of game that was.

It was however a back and forth game up to a point.

Re: Saints SB Not Ranked Among Top Ten All Time
 

Boring! WTFO!!

How many teams have out-scored the Colts 25-7 in a half?

Other than the Saints, I can't think of any!

The Saints set 2 Super Bowl records: the three 40+-yd FGs by Hartley and the first ever onside kick not in the 4th quarter!

Boring? I think not!!

Re: Saints SB Not Ranked Among Top Ten All Time
 

The pick-six was boring? Brees was 32-39 passing--- that's boring?
Lance's 2-point conversion was boring?

What game were you watching?


I think that the fact that a small town franchise known for losing more than winning and the fact that it was a rebuilding city blown up by a storm, should be considered a top ten Superbowl on principle alone. Homer or not.

This team wins and does more than collect a trophy. It energizes a region and fans all over the world.

Re: Saints SB Not Ranked Among Top Ten All Time
 

I wouldn't call it boring but its not the most exciting one either. i could have been on that list but I have no problem with it not being on there either.

Re: Saints SB Not Ranked Among Top Ten All Time
 

I really don't remember much from the first two SuperBowls, but I remember those Packer teams of the late '60s and something about most the SBs following.

When I think of all these SuperBowls, only one or two really stand out and I would be hard pressed to compile a Top Ten list.

But what I do remember from the SB XLIV is that it was the Saints first appearance after being the perennial doormats of the NFL, Brees' passing, the onside kick and the inspiring fact that it was so soon after Katrina.

I agree with iceshack, that alone should put it in the Top Ten, or at least tie it with SB III, which was considered in the Top Ten because of similiar, inspirational off field stuff, ie Namath's guarantee.

Re: Saints SB Not Ranked Among Top Ten All Time
 

While our Super Bowl was a nail-biter for us, from a national standpoint it wasn't. They probably lost half their audience after the Tracy Porter pick-six. When a team needs a last minute TD and THEN successful onsides kick and THEN still need another last second TD just to tie the game, it's just not considered that close of a game.

Re: Saints SB Not Ranked Among Top Ten All Time
 

Well we all know SB44 ranks #1 for us, and that is all that really matters.

Re: Saints SB Not Ranked Among Top Ten All Time
 

I was coming to this thread to post that very thing!

:bng:

Re: Saints SB Not Ranked Among Top Ten All Time
 

It will always be #1 to Saint's Fans. That is all that matters.