What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

Here are my all time top 10 Saints players. What are yours...
We are not looking for a list of the best players ever.

10. Sammy Knight
9. Tommy Meyers
8. Joe Horn
7. Bobby Hebert
6. Rickey Jackson
5. Conrad Dobler
4. Pierre Thomas
3. Marcus Coltson
2. Morton Anderson
1a Tracy Porter
1. Drew Brees

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

Well, don't wish to be rude, but a poll would've made this easier...

:)

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

I thought about it for a few seconds. ;)

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

I'll give it a shot....

10. Jerry Fontenot
9. Rickey Jackson
8. Morten Andersen
7. Steve Gleason
6. Joe Horn
5. Scott Fujita
4. Mike McKenzie
3. Pierre Thomas
2. Deuce McAllister
1. Drew Brees

HM: Quinn Early, Fred McAfee, Tyrone Hughes, Fred Thomas, Norman Hand

A little surprised not more from the Mora years. I think all the playoff choke jobs must've soured me a little.

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

What?! No Sam Mills on any of those list?

Sam Mills, Willie Roaf, Eric Martin, Morten Anderson, Kyle Turley, Drew Brees, Deuce McAllister, Craig Heyward, Pierre Thomas, and finally... Hoby Brenner. I just always liked his name.

Cam Jordan and Junior Galette with a few more seasons on their belt will sky rocket up the list.

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

How can anyone not have Guido Merkins on their list?

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

Dalton Hilliard, Reuben Mayas, Pat Swilling, Vaughn Johnson, Frank Warren, Jimmy Graham, Sean Payton, George Rogers, Chuck Muncie.

Finally, did anyone mention Drew Brees?

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

Err #1 on the list babbbyyy. :bng:

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

Loved Sam Mills but I think of him as a Panther. I am sure that sounds weird, but I have such a dislike for that franchise and then they went and put up a statue of them after he played there like 3 years. Not his fault, really, just the way I feel.

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

I forgot TRACY PORTER!! :itsgood:
Had to go back and add.

http://media.cleveland.com/sports_im...da89_large.jpg

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

Had a short career due to injuries but I use to love watching Keith Poole. He took massive hits and would get right back on his feet. Man had some serious heart. I remember one game even the announcers were sure he was knocked out. He got up with the ball and started talking smack..lol!

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

1. Drew Brees
2. Deuce McAllister
3. Pierre Thomas
4.Marques Colston
5.Rickey Jackson
6.Pat Swilling
7.Tracy Porter
8.Tommy Myers
9.Devry Henderson
10.Dalton Hilliard

Anderson,Horn & Hebert would have made the list if they had not signed with the failclowns!

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

Wes chandler Joe horn Dome Patrol Duece Mcallister William Roaf Tracy porter Drew Brees

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

I'm excluding current players on the roster. Why? because it's my top 10;

1 Archie Manning
2 Ricky Jackson
3 Hokie Gajan
4 Deuce
5 Sam Mills
6 Joe Horn
7 Lance Moore
8 Dalton Hilliard
9 Eric Martin
10 Rueben Mayes

The question was asked, why isn't Guido Merkens on someone's list? Uh, I dunno, maybe because he scored 2 TD's in his 6 year career in New Orleans. I liked him because he could play just about any position, but he wasn't a standout player at any of them. But I'll support you putting him on your list if you so desire.

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

Im going to catch hell for this but Mario Bates and Michael Haynes. Nobody could beat me in madden with that team. Not my favorites of all time but they was on the team the year I got into football. The sad part is I cant even remember who the quarterback was.

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

10. Ricky Williams ( ehh )
9. Ricky Jackson
8. Tracy Porter
7. Darren Sharper ( ehh^107 )
6. Joe Horn
5. Kenny Vaccarro ( Already )
4. Jimmy Graham
3. Kenny Stills ( I think it's the Hair )
2. Mark Ingram ( Serious Man Crush )
1. Drew let the top down in New Orleans just so I can feel the Brees

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

In no particular order:

- Morten Anderson - "The Great Dane", MSU All-American
- Wille Roaf - HOF'er, gotta' respect offensive lineman who so often toil in obscurity
- Sean Payton - coaching great who turned a franchise around ... on par with the likes of Scotty Bowman, Sparky Anderson and others, IMO.
- Tom Dempsey - anyone who can kick a ball that far with only half a foot gets my vote
- Kyle Turley - the world needs more enforcers
- Thomas Morestead - at one point, a season or two ago, he was the best tackler on special teams, or so it seemed
- Jimmy Graham - redefined the touchdown celebration by wrecking the goal posts
- Steve Gleason - for the 'block heard round the world' ... and it was against the Failclowns, which made it even more special, :lol:
- Bobby Hebert - won championships with the Michigan Panthers (USFL) & has my undying gratitude for that one brief, shining moment he brought winning football to Detroit
- Drew Brees - how can you not love the guy?

honorable mention:

- Tom Lelito - hasn't really done anything (yet), but a Michigan 'local boy' done good
- Joe Horn - the whole 'barbecue sauce' thing won me over
- Reggie Bush/Joique Bell - first running back tandem in NFL history to each record 500+ rushing/receiving yds in one season, albeit for the Lions ... but we all know where they got their grit from, ;).
- Lance Moore - 'cuz his Mama raised him right & he was a darn good route-runner.


dishonorable mention:

- Pat Swilling - came to Detroit, insisted on wearing a previously retired number of one of Detroit's all-time greats (#56, Joe Schmidt) & was then a flop.

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

01) Chuck Muncie
02) Ricky Williams
03) Ken Stabler
04) Drew Brees
05) Devery Henderson
06) Joe Horn
07) Deuce McAllister
08) Kenny Stills
09) Dalton Hillard
10) Tony Galbreath

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

#1 Danny Abramowicz held the NFL record for most consecutive games with a t least one catch and all of the Saints receiving records until Eric Martin. He has to be on this list and no way Devery can take his place.(and I love Devery), plus he coached me to play WR at Jesuit., #2 Dalton Hilliard, 3 # Archie Manning, # 4 Deuce Mcallister, # 5 Eric Martin, #6 Rickey Jackson, # 7 Sam Mills, # 8 Drew Brees, # 9 Sam Mills, # 10 Willey Roaf. Hard to leave off.......Bobby Hebert, Joe Horn, Pat Swilling, Ironhead, Vaughn Johnson, and of course Morten Anderson.

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

1. Payton
2. Brees
3. Swilling
4. Vaughn
5. Deuce
6. Colston
7. Eric Martin
8. Gleason
9. Michael Lewis
10. Turley

I know Payton's not a player, but he got injured on a play, so he counts.

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

Im cant say my favorite, to hard to put in place. But I will say some older ones. Dalton Hilliard, Eric Martin, Ricky J., Wayne Martin. I can go on and on. Really anyone but Jason David.......

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

10. Sam Mills
9. Morten Andersen
8. Pat Swilling
7. Marques Colston
6. Joe Horn
5. Jimmy Graham
4. Pierre Thomas
3. Drew Brees
2. Deuce McCallister
1. Eric Martin

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

I always liked Kevin Mathis. He was a little guy and fun to pull for.

Brees
Deuce
Hebert
Jackson
The guy who's wife Joe Horn banged (Roaf)
Horn
Can I count the entire dome patrol.

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

I am shocked that Archie is not on every list

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

Well, most probably never saw him play.

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

I'm a big Sam Mills fan too, but I'm only giving him one spot.:p

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

1- Brees
2- McAllister
3- Pierre Thomas
4- Joe Horn
5- Roaf
6- Lance Moore
7- Vilma
8- Michael Lewis
9- Gleason
10-Porter
11- This is too hard.

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

oh god gotta think on this one.

Archie
Drew
Duce

Jim Dombrowski
Eric Martin
Dalton Hilliard
Pierre Thomas
Morten Andersen
Danny Abramowicz
Dome Patrol
La'Roi Glover
Jumpy Geathers
Doug Atkins
Dave Waymer
Craig Heyward
Wayne Martin
Tom Dempsey
Wes Chandler
Russell Erxleben
Stan Brock
Bruce Clark
Brian Hansen
William Roaf
Kyle Turley

It is a work in progess

It got no better than this back in the day
1993 - Pro Bowl
Rickey Jackson, Vaughan Johnson, Sam Mills & Pat Swilling, K Morten Andersen & C Joel Hilgenberg

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

This guy gets it. Guido Merkins played like 8 different positions(QB, RB, WR, TE, K, P, CB, S).

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

I think the QB was Jim "Don't call me Chris" Everett.

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

This is a hard list

In no particular order....
Brees, Dempsey, Rickey Jackson-Mills-Swilling_Vaughn and sorry if I let anyone out of the Bourbon Street Bruisers (one of their many names), M.Andersen, 2009 Saints entire SB team.
Manning for sentimental reasons.

Does it count to groups people together? No, it does not.

This is a good thread. A hard thread.:bng:

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

1. Drew Brees 2. Archie Manning 3. Steve Gleason 4. Chris Reis 5. Morten Andersen 6. Deuce Mcallister 7. Reggie Bush 8. Scott Fujita 9. Marcus Colston 10. Every other player on SB winning team!

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

names i missed?

Gene Atkins
Jay Bellamy
Toi Cook
Mark Fields
Joe Johnson
Wayne Martin
Brett Maxie
Keith Mitchell
Whitney Paul
Will Smith
Winfred Tubbs
Jim Wilks

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

Names I missed that should be called out...individually....
Reggie Bush, Vilma, even Hartley for making that fg that sent the team off to the SB.

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

Oops! Too many Natty Ice's.

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

How about Hoby Brenner? I always loved how that dude flipped on his head every time he seemed to get tackled.

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?
 

1.Archie Manning
2.George Rodgers
3.The dome Patrol
4.Joe Johnson
5.Dave Waymer
6.Sammy Knight
7.Eric Martin
8.Morten Anderson
9.Dalton Hillard
10.Dombrowski,S.Brock,J.hilgenberg,W.Roaf (gotta show the fat guys some love)

other to receive consideration J.Geathers,J.Wilks,F.Warren,R.Turnbull,T.Cook,V.Buck,B.Hebert,Wayne Wilson,H.Brenner,W.Martin,B.Maxie,T.Hughes,M.Grey can go on and on and on.

This list is more like completely reflective more of my youthful days growing up. Too tough to narrow down to just 10

Re: What are your Top 10 Favorite All Time Saints?