Your favorite 2004 Saints
 

OK, I see WhoDat isn't the only one who gets labeled player-x hater (cough*Brooks*cough) everytime he criticises a players production or lack of it.
So here's your chance to set the record straight. Who do you think the best players are on this team?
Here's my top-10 list, in order...
1. Charles Grant
2. Deuce McAllister
3. Joe Horn
4. Darren Howard
5. LeCharles Bentley
6. Mike McKenzie
7. Will Smith
8. Donte Stallworth
9. Aaron Brooks
10. Tie, Courtney Watson, Mike Karney, Jerome Pathon, John Carney, Michael Lewis.

Your favorite 2004 Saints
 

1. Johnathan Sullivan
2. Victor Riley
3. Wayne Gandy
4. Rick Venturi
5. Jim Haslett
6. Donte Stallworth
7. Aaron Brooks
8. Cie Grant
9. Tebucky Jones
10. Fred Thomas

These are my true heros, the goats of christmas present, the goats of christmas past, and likely the goats of christmas future........

Your favorite 2004 Saints
 

1.Joe Horn
2.Charles Grant
3.Mike Karney
4.Mike McKenzie
5.Will Smith
6.Courtney Watson
7.Darren Howard
8.Aaron Brooks
9.Donte Stallworth
10.Jerome Pathon

Your favorite 2004 Saints
 

No Deuce? Hmmm.

Your favorite 2004 Saints
 

Dont\' get your eggnog in a bundle, Deuce is a given.

Your favorite 2004 Saints
 

Now, how are you guys putting Stallworth above Brooks? I\'m just curious how you can rate a subpar WR over a QB that has delivered the ball well enough this year.

Sure Brooks does some stuff during the course of the game that would make a blind man say \"What the #*$#*$% was the that?? But Stallworth has been thrown to 96 times with only 51 catches. Even if you allow for passes defended well he has dropped between 30 - 40% of the throws that hit him square in the hands. He needs to become familiar with the term \"Stickum\".

Just my humble opinion though.
Darren

Your favorite 2004 Saints
 

Hey Danno, Deuce is second on your list, but here\'s what you said about him a week ago.

Funny how a week changes things.

Your favorite 2004 Saints
 

Best or favorites ---- Different lists for me (Beerman will always rank up there witrh my favorites)-- But for the sake of this thread I\'ll go with the best (my list will not be 10 though - don\'t think some deserve to be mentioned)

Charles Grant ---
Joe Horn
Will Smith
Deuce
Bentley
D. Howard
McKenzie
Kearney
Brooks

Your favorite 2004 Saints
 

Joe Horn, Deuce, Will Smith, Mckenzie, Grant, Kearney, Pathon, Michael Lewis,McAfee

Your favorite 2004 Saints
 

Nothings changed at all. The post was a jab at everyone that worships Deuce no matter what. Yet is critical of other players on this team, no matter what.

Whats that got to do with him being one of my favorite players on this team?

I think you are helping to prove my point actually.
You can like a player and still criticize his play.
But look out!!!! If you criticize a player\'s play (even if you like him) you\'re gonna be labeled a hater. If you look at my previous posts critical of Deuces play you\'ll frequently see that I call him one of our best players.
Funny, no one ever quotes that part ever.