New Orleans Saints Forums - blackandgold.com

New Orleans Saints Forums - blackandgold.com (https://blackandgold.com/community/)
-   Saints (https://blackandgold.com/saints/)
-   -   Where are our weak spots? (https://blackandgold.com/saints/67750-where-our-weak-spots.html)

The Dude 08-29-2014 07:01 PM

Where are our weak spots?
 
After following training camp and the pre season games I am very excited for the regular season. We have amazing depth at several positions and on paper look like the real deal. I was impressed with our offensive line as well, especially since Grubbs and Evans were out. I do have two areas of concern.

One is our run defense. I don't know if it is lack of talent at LB or what, but it seems to be a weakness. I don't think people will want to throw much against us but if we get a hard nosed running team we may be in trouble. We will have to play Seattle eventually and Lynch already has good history with us.
Another area I see as a potential weakness is WR. Yes I said WR. Cooks looks to be ROY material and Colton seems to be in true form, its not our WR corps talent I worry about its their health.
At some point in the season Graham will get hurt. It happens every year. He does seem to play through it, but I can see him out a couple games. Morgan is another one that is always hurt and is coming off a major knee injury. Stills is hurt now, how bad we don't know. Colston has his injury problems as well.
I can see all of these guys missing a game or two this season. Hopefully not all at once.
It does take talent and a bit of luck to win a Super Bowl. I have no doubt we are capable, I just hope the ball bounces our way.

saintfan 08-29-2014 07:20 PM

Re: Where are our weak spots?
 
Waterboy. We're definitely weak at waterboy.

And my phone still isn't ringing...

Danno 08-29-2014 07:44 PM

Re: Where are our weak spots?
 
Complacency and overconfidence is really our only true weakness. We have areas that are merely average (LB) but no real weakness unit wise

WhoDat!656 08-29-2014 07:45 PM

Re: Where are our weak spots?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by saintfan (Post 606495)
Waterboy. We're definitely weak at waterboy.

And my phone still isn't ringing...

You and Mike Smith have something in common!

Audiotom 08-29-2014 08:02 PM

Re: Where are our weak spots?
 
#2 corner and the linebackers

Running game is still to be determined but looks promising

saintfan 08-29-2014 08:14 PM

Re: Where are our weak spots?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by WhoDat!656 (Post 606502)
You and Mike Smith have something in common!

Well sir I'd like to take the opportunity to recommend a temporary ban of your account for even suggesting something so heinous.

:banana:

http://www.troll.me/images/downvotin...get-banned.jpg

hitta 08-29-2014 08:20 PM

Re: Where are our weak spots?
 
ILB is probably our weakest spot.

homerj07 08-29-2014 08:24 PM

Re: Where are our weak spots?
 
I think we are VERY average at LB and that could be an Achilles heal for the defense.

Utah_Saint 08-29-2014 10:18 PM

Re: Where are our weak spots?
 
Oline depth is a worry for me. If the starters stay healthy, we're in good shape but if a couple get dinged up, we could be in trouble.

Barry from MS 08-29-2014 10:35 PM

Re: Where are our weak spots?
 
Run defense. FIRST. By a long shot.

We were 19th in the NFL by giving up 112 rushing yards per game in 2013, but we were 28th in giving up 4.6 yards per carry. We gave up 4.6 yards per carry to place 28th in the NFL in 2013.

4.6 per carry is awful. A big bowl of awful.

Jack Vegas 08-29-2014 11:53 PM

Re: Where are our weak spots?
 
Most glaring weak spot right now is OLB in my opinion. We have little depth here. If either Haralson or Galette gets hurt we are totally screwed. It's mitigated by the fact this isn't really a true 3-4 defense and we don't use that position all the time, but even if you consider this a 4-3 defense there is not a lot of depth there.

I am not particularly worried about #2 CB. We have three and potentially four decent players there. Somebody will step up and claim it.

The Dude 08-30-2014 12:54 AM

Re: Where are our weak spots?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Utah_Saint (Post 606522)
Oline depth is a worry for me. If the starters stay healthy, we're in good shape but if a couple get dinged up, we could be in trouble.

They did just fine run blocking and pass blocking without our two pro bowl linemen. They can get the job done if need be.

jeanpierre 08-30-2014 03:49 AM

Re: Where are our weak spots?
 
Linebacker...

Haralson has been a great value for the trade for his first year and the subsequent re-signing as a 49er castoff (which says something about the level of our linebackers compared to the teams with elite linebackers)...

Lofton may "grade well" but he looks like he's always chasing down and not disrupting or making plays; really never see him make an impact, literally and figuratively; really didn't like this signing and it didn't help he was a Falcon...

Hawthorne has a little thump, but there still is no fear factor that is sorely needed from the second MLB; he plays with great effort, but he also lacks the quicker diagnosing talents needed and is a castoff as well, from the Seattle LB corps...

Galette is a fan favorite, but is a one-trick pony who often misses on his run defense assignments or when he's fails to sell as decoy against blocking schemes to allow others to make plays...

We really have lacked 34 linebackers which, ironically, may be why teams are struggling to figure out Ryan's defense...


Offensive Line

Strief is heart and soul, but was really exposed as a limited movement Right Tackle in those Seattle and Frisco games, limiting what the offense could do on that side...

Our best lineman, Jahri Evans, is getting old and is too expensive as a part-time guard because of injuries, because of mileage, because of age...

Tim Lelito shows great promise and I bet the real reason why we have Jon Goodwin is so Lelito can be available at Guard...

Where Ben Grubbs has failed to live up to his contract and often think we'd might have been better to have paid the extra mil to keep Carl Nicks but will give Loomis the benefit that maybe Nicks would shut it down after the big Mo...

But I see tremendous promise in Terron Armstead who could emerge as our best linemen and one of the better in the league by season's end...


Moving Forward...

Aside from Brees' contract, we're really hamstrung with the dead money to the Guards and Inside Linebackers which also negated the competition in camp at those spots...

While the positions may be considered weak, they are serviceable and we're still better than many teams in the league in these areas...

Aside from trading some rare depth (i.e. QB Luke McCown, FS Raphael Bush) for a younger offensive linemen needing opportunity (personal man crush would be former BamaBoy and now Ram Barrett Jones) we're set for the dance and tournament...

After this season, we should be freed of those contracts especially at MLB and G to pursue Younger, Faster, Stronger and Hungrier Players and allow draft picks and our favorite designation, Rookie UDFA, to come in and compete and have an impact at those positions...

Crusader 08-30-2014 04:48 AM

Re: Where are our weak spots?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jeanpierre (Post 606536)
Our best lineman, Jahri Evans, is getting old and is too expensive as a part-time guard because of injuries, because of mileage, because of age...

Injuries are the only problem here. 31 is not old for an OL and especially not for a guard. If Evans can stay healthy I can see 3-4 more years of him being an all-pro.

TheOak 08-30-2014 06:53 AM

Re: Where are our weak spots?
 
Can't tell what the main course will taste like when I've only had the bread so far.

halloween 65 08-30-2014 08:32 AM

Re: Where are our weak spots?
 
Last season FS and ILB was my main concern, well at least FS has been addressed. ILB is still an issue, there are basically 2 ways to adrdress it you either have big thumper type lb.'s that cause serious pain on rb.'s TE's and slot recievers that enter their hunting zones or what I call hybrids that can cover and tackle decent. In my opionion I like thumpers over hybrids, shuts down the run game and scares rb.'s, TE's and slot recievers because they know their getting some pain. With Lofton and Hawthorn, a SS will have to help out leaving the area just beyond the lb.'s exposed,our short deep middle, if they try to cover, the slant will eat those 2 up. Ryan can only cover up for the ILB position so long before they get exposed and eat up. It is a real weakness.
On the O. Depth on the O-line is a little concerning but not as bad. The back-ups played really well with the 1's when Evens and Grubbs were out.
#2 CB is starting to look like it possibly become a weak spot, but not so sure. I think with Robinson playing a mile off his man in the Ravens game was by design, now Bailey, he has me concerned, watch the waiver wire close.

hagan714 08-30-2014 10:06 AM

Re: Where are our weak spots?
 
[QUOTE=jeanpierre;606536]

Haralson is our most complete LB

Lofton run only

Hawthorne still waiting on him to return to form

Galette great pass rusher that has shown signs of improvement against the run but little help in pass coverage.

Ryans Defense - tapes out and we are seeing the changes by other teams already. now lets see what he can do to change things up

Offensive Line

Strief is heart and soul..

Our best lineman, are getting old - saints have not addressed this issue

Tim Lelito - aint ready

Terron Armstead huge bright spot

Moving Forward...

we have only moved forward at the safety position this off season to the point we may have over done it at the cost of other positions. it was not a huge area of need to justify all the the moves.

all four preseason games let me wishing we were as deep and talented as the teams we faced. we are not as deep as the media states.

inside hot routes will once again be our soft spot.





Cruize 08-30-2014 11:54 AM

Re: Where are our weak spots?
 
Payton calling 40 passes and 15 runs. No playmakers at LB. Known qualities and health outside of Colston at WR. Backup at T. Uncertainty/confidence at K.

Barry from MS 08-30-2014 12:23 PM

Re: Where are our weak spots?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jeanpierre (Post 606536)
Linebacker...

Lofton may "grade well" but he looks like he's always chasing down and not disrupting or making plays; really never see him make an impact, literally and figuratively; really didn't like this signing and it didn't help he was a Falcon...

Hawthorne has a little thump, but there still is no fear factor that is sorely needed from the second MLB; he plays with great effort, but he also lacks the quicker diagnosing talents needed and is a castoff as well, from the Seattle LB corps...

Galette is a fan favorite, but is a one-trick pony who often misses on his run defense assignments or when he's fails to sell as decoy against blocking schemes to allow others to make plays...

We really have lacked 34 linebackers which, ironically, may be why teams are struggling to figure out Ryan's defense...


Think this sums up what caused that atomic irritation I felt last year when teams consistently seemed to always be 2nd & 5 or 2nd & 3 after a 1st down run.

If we consistently get teams to start at 2nd & 9 or 2nd & 8, the chances are much better for 3-and-out or killing the drive. Pretty sure the law of averages will bear me out with that.

If Jenkins improves at NT this year with Jordan and Hicks already good run stoppers, this should help our steady yet unspectacular ILB core.

saintsfan1976 08-30-2014 04:30 PM

Re: Where are our weak spots?
 
Coverage LB
#2 CB (not sold on Robinson)


#3 WR - I'm getting more comfortable with Morgan.

Halo 08-30-2014 04:32 PM

Re: Where are our weak spots?
 
RUN DEFENSE! We have a hard time stopping the run.
When I watched the Ravens game in the Dome, the HOLES in our d-line were depressing to watch!!!!

Michigan_SF 08-30-2014 04:36 PM

Re: Where are our weak spots?
 
I guess if there's no kicker, then that should be considered a weak spot.

cars4dylan 08-30-2014 05:08 PM

Re: Where are our weak spots?
 
Anyone freaking out about Run Def because of Baltimore game where it was 95% dead men walking just trying to make the squad needs to breathe....just breathe.

CB#2 - I will NEVER trust Robinson until he shows me otherwise that he can stop blowing coverage. I'd take Bailey using a walker on the field for his knowledge over Robinson and his pention for letting guys by him routinely.

Morgan, impressing me every time he steps on the field and coming back from the knee issue that's over a year old now is impressive. I'm curious what Toon will do with opportunity now laid at his feet.

I'm also curious to see if Coleman with his 6'6" frame will make it to the PS or if a team like Carolina needing WRs goes after him.

lsutigerfan 08-30-2014 06:12 PM

Re: Where are our weak spots?
 
Kicker

Danno 08-30-2014 06:19 PM

Re: Where are our weak spots?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by lsutigerfan (Post 606721)
Kicker

How so? I'm thinking worst case is pretty good.

SmashMouth 08-30-2014 06:32 PM

Re: Where are our weak spots?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Michigan_SF (Post 606665)
I guess if there's no kicker, then that should be considered a weak spot.

Going out on a limb we see here....;)

The Dude 08-30-2014 06:40 PM

Re: Where are our weak spots?
 
Now all of a sudden CB makes me nervous. I felt champ would at least bring SOMEthing to the position.

Schmohams 08-30-2014 08:29 PM

Re: Where are our weak spots?
 
Payton said he liked what he saw in our Kickers so I don't see us bringing in someone like Ryan Succop. But since there is already 53 other players on the roster not listed at the kicker position someone is going to have a bad day.

Rugby Saint II 08-30-2014 08:50 PM

Re: Where are our weak spots?
 
My weak spot is between my ears. :razz:

saintsfan1976 08-30-2014 09:25 PM

Re: Where are our weak spots?
 
Coverage LB

hitta 08-31-2014 10:39 AM

Re: Where are our weak spots?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by cars4dylan (Post 606688)
Anyone freaking out about Run Def because of Baltimore game where it was 95% dead men walking just trying to make the squad needs to breathe....just breathe.

CB#2 - I will NEVER trust Robinson until he shows me otherwise that he can stop blowing coverage. I'd take Bailey using a walker on the field for his knowledge over Robinson and his pention for letting guys by him routinely.

Morgan, impressing me every time he steps on the field and coming back from the knee issue that's over a year old now is impressive. I'm curious what Toon will do with opportunity now laid at his feet.

I'm also curious to see if Coleman with his 6'6" frame will make it to the PS or if a team like Carolina needing WRs goes after him.

A team could go after Coleman, but I doubt it. The reason he was cut was because he wasn't NFL ready. You bring in a rookie to another team that needs to work on their hands while at the same time having to relearn their playbook... it's a waste of a roster spot really. They'd be better off bringing in a vet.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:22 PM.


Copyright 1997 - 2020 - BlackandGold.com