If we were down by 6 points.....
 

Ben Roethlisberger, because he\'ll be able to lead us 80 yards for six points for the next decade and a half... ;)

If we were down by 6 points.....
 

I wouldn\'t take the choker Peyton.....TOM BRADY all the way!!!!!!!!!!

If we were down by 6 points.....
 

a.j. feely... seriously, probably peyton manning, but vick\'s athleticism is warranted here.

If we were down by 6 points.....
 

There\'s no one in better in the clutch than Tom Brady.

And how anyone could want Peyton Mannning is beyond me.

Let\'s face it........... Manning has the best offensive line he could ask for. He has the best receivers and a pro-bowl running back. And 2 of the best tightends in the NFL.

Manning has more talent around him than any other QB in the NFL.

And Peytons offense still can\'t get it done.

In his playoff career, Peyton has faced the Titans, Jets, Dolphins, and twice at the Patriots, Manning has thrown two touchdown passes and seven interceptions. His quarterback rating is 55.6. The most yards he has thrown for is 238. The Colts have lost by an average of 15.4 points.

A defense would certainly help. But Peyton has NO excuse for not putting up more points with the talent he has on offense.. :P


[Edited on 6/2/2005 by GumboBC]

If we were down by 6 points.....
 

Seriously? Again? I\'ll pull out the same argument from before.

If we were down by 6 points.....
 

saintwhodi-

Up until last year Peyton hadn\'t even won a playoff game is his career.

The Bottom Line is this:

EVERY year Peyton plays terrible in the last game and the offense chokes. Who do you blame?

If we were down by 6 points.....
 

Billy,

I\'d blame the whole team... :yes:

If we were down by 6 points.....
 

Yeah, I just want to hear saintwhodi say someone else can be blamed besides the QB.

I just figure it would be easier for him to say it with Peyton rather than Brooks.

Sometimes you\'ve got to use another QB besides Brooks to get a point across.. :D

If we were down by 6 points.....
 

I knew where you were going, but I figured I\'d point out the obvious before someone started on this whole - \"flip flop, flip flop\" carp (yes, I said carp). ;)

If we were down by 6 points.....
 

Oh yeah, cause I can see how you can call a QB who throws 55 TDs in a year(NFL record) is regarded as one of the best all time ALREADY, has the ability to run a no huddle offense cause his coaches believe in his play-calling ability and intelligence that much, a problem. So AB put up this numbers in his career? When he does, he is definitely NOT a problem. Please try harder than that. Peyton was 3-13 his first year, who has come farther him or AB? Too easy.