|
Is Micheal Vick the best QB in the NFL?
He may quite possibly be at least this year be the best QB in the NFL..
|
I agree!
Andy Reid has made the most of his passing ability, and with his scrambling ability; very dangerous. |
Yes he is...hands down. He is down right scary. Good WRs are helping him shine also.
|
As a Saints fan i am straight hating the fact at how good he is.. but as a football fan i am appreciating just all out good and exciting Skills and ball game! WOW!!!! I hope philly doesn't make the playoffs they will be unstoppable as long as Vick and his WR's are healthy!
|
It's like Vick has been watching film of Fran Tarkenton ... very heady play with the run and the pass.
|
Ron Mexico? Is that you? Quit the shameless self-promotion already!
|
Quote:
Correlating that into Payton having no faith in Daniels does not relate. Our starting quarterback isn't Alex Smith or Chad Henne... it's Drew Brees. We would have a veteran quarterback backing up Brees if Payton had "no faith" in Chase Daniels. |
Quote:
The only thing that would have happened if we pulled brees for some other QB or Mike Vick, would be that we would create a contraversy and basically alienated a guy that has pretty much been the saviour of the city and the organisation. As papz said, Brees is an all pro and i'm going to say will be a hall of famer once his career is over, Mike Vick is playing well but Brees is way way way better. Vick is just a change of pace for the Eagles, i do admit hes playing real well. |
The answer is no. He is dynamic, and he is a much better player post prison than pre, but he still makes it happen with his feet. He needs the time because, in my opinion, he takes a while to read a defense.
What I saw on Monday night looked to me like a team that was not prepared to defend him, and you do have to adjust your game for a player of his caliber. But the best QB in the NFL? Ummmm no. Brady, Manning, Brees or Rivers and probably a few more before you get to Vick... |
I hate to say it, but maybe.
|
The NFL... where everything is "what have you done for me lately". Just a couple of weeks ago Chris Ivory put up a great game against the Tampa Bay Bucs... and then people were saying how great of a running back he was going to become here. People are way too quick to jump on and off bandwagons. He had a great game... one that certainly went down in the history books. But the best in the league... personally I don't think so. Without a doubt Vick is the most electrifying football player in the league... but if I had a must win game with everything on the line, he would not be in my top 5.
Brady, Manning, Brees, Rodgers, and Big Ben would be my top 5... Vick probably right after that. |
It hurts me to say it, but, at the moment, the just might be. Ouch.
|
well i have always hated him do to fact we had to play him twice a year.
But DAMN the dude was unbelievable last night. If he plays like that the rest of the year. Yes he would be the best! I really hope they don't make the playoffs. |
Quote:
|
.
Vick is the reason we give people a "second chance". Speaking as a former 'Vick hater' - I'm actually cheering the guy on. I saw his maturity in the Gruden interview. Glad to see his transformation and I hope he becomes a beacon of light for embattled youths. |
I'm just curious, but before we crown Vick as the "best", what is the Redskins defensive rankings right now? Anyone want to post that? I gave Haslett credit before, on his defensive schemes, but I gotta say, they all played like hot garbage last night. In fact, after the Eagles were up in the 2nd quarter, they all seemed to quit, more than anything else. Vick is a great player, but the best QB in the league? You gotta be kidding me. The skins are in a total rebuild this season, on both sides of the ball, with a new head coach, and an all new coaching staff. Let's not get too carried away here.
Let's also not forget that the Skins beat the Eagles, in THEIR house, the first time they played. Didn't Vick play that game? |
The Saints and our great fans are better without Vick. Let me explain: Vick should've never been given an opportunity to play professional football aqain because he didn't just make one or two mistakes and pay for them, he made a killing grounds purposely, he is inhumane purposely, he made money betting on his endeavors purposely, he lied about everything purposel. So you see there were hundreds of mistakes, a couple I could forgive but IMO Michael Vick and everything thug like him has no place on this earth and I mean that with all my heart.
|
I decided to answer my own question. Going into that game, the Skins were ranked 31st against the pass. Not exactly the best secondary in football I suspect.
"When the statistics are moved to the side - and that will be hard to do - there will be significant questions about the Redskins defense, which must somehow right itself over the season's final seven games. Washington entered the night allowing 393.3 yards per game, third-worst in the NFL. It had been especially susceptible to the pass, ranking 31st in the league at 280.9 yards per game." |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Do you get it now Bro? |
Vick is the flavor of the week, if they loose to the Giants and Vick does poorly then no one cares what he did this week against a horrible Redskins team .... stop being caught in the moment, one good game does not make you great
|
I have a better question for this thread, "IS HASLETT THE WORST DEFENSIVE COORDINATOR IN THE LEAGUE RIGHT NOW?"
|
Quote:
http://www.charity.com/uploads/jl-mda2004-0004_rj.jpg |
1 Attachment(s)
|
Quote:
Quote:
I think Vick is playing better than ever and so far looks like a top 10 QB, but Monday night was a combination of Vick being in the zone and the Redskins defense just being gawd-awful. Let them eat the cheese. |
I think in Hasletts case he's one of those rare guys that is a better head coach then he is a coordinator.I feel like he should have been allowed to stay the head coach of the Rams.
|
I have to go with Strato on most of his replies.
One great amazing game and people are ready to label Vick the best in the league. 1/2 way into the season people are ready to give him MVP. Where was all this talk when they lost to Indy? Lets see what he does this week against the Giants Defense before you go giving him the key to the city. I was never a Vick fan and I will never be a Vick fan. He was not 13 years old when he did what he did. He was a grown man. He also didn't stop on his own. He got caught! Quitting after 3 years in jail is like quiting smoking after your told you have lung cancer... Not a representation of strength or great character. I have a one liner for you. Bret Favre the whole 2009 Season, well till he met us in the Play Offs.. LOL.... What's he doing now? |
x626x funny thing is they beat Indy.
|
I think he's doing great because they're allowing him the freedom of using all of his gifts.. when he initially went to the Falcons in ATfail they allowed him to use his feet as well as throw the ball mostly he ran to compensate for his lack of accuracy..
Since the dog case and all he's apparently gotten more accurate with the help of mentoring from Mcnabb and now they are allowing him to run his type of offense and allow him the freedom he had in college and his first couple of years in the Pro's.. We're seeing the Real Micheal Vick and he looks very dangerous when he's healthy! YIKES!!!!!! |
How come I can't see page five?
|
Quote:
|
okay I kept seeing page four everytime I clicked on this thread.Sorry about the useless post.It's fixed now.It may have just been a problem on my end.
|
| All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:28 AM. |
Copyright 1997 - 2020 - BlackandGold.com