Originally Posted by Eric Edholm, Shutdown Corner, Yahoo Sports

Cowboys denied chance to win when Dez Bryant catch overturned


Football karma is funny stuff.

The Dallas Cowboys were widely viewed as the beneficiaries of a favorable call (or two) in their wild-card win over the Detroit Lions last week, as ridiculous rumors of Cowboys favoritism ruled the sports water-cooler chatter.

Well, hard to argue that now.

Mr. Fourth Down, Cowboys head coach Jason Garrett, make a risky call with his team down 26-21 with 4:42 left. He decided to go for it on fourth-and-2 from the Green Bay 32, and it appeared a brilliant risk when Dez Bryant made a circus catch at the 1-yard line, skying over cornerback Sam Shields.

But Packers head coach Mike McCarthy challenged the spot after earlier missing on a challenge, arguing that Julius Peppers tipped a pass on what was called a Packers pass interference call. That one failed. In fact, every challenge this season made by McCarthy has failed — all five of them, including the earlier one.

After review, the referees ruled that Bryant didn't catch the ball. Despite what the world saw as a brilliant football play and the fact that he took three steps after catching it. It was the old, cruel Calvin Johnson Rule, failing to "complete the process" of the catch, being played out in what had been a classic battle of two great teams prior to that.

The ball moved after hitting the ground when Bryant hit the chewed-up Lambeau Field turf, and that was enough for the Mike Perieras of the world to say: no catch. The replay officials agreed.

So much for a great game. It was marred by a technicality.

A score would have resulted in a one-, two- or three-point Cowboys lead and the ball in Rodgers' hands with a chance to win it. Instead, he played a great game of keepaway after the controversial call. A bit anticlimactic, no?

Heck, even the Lions — who were victimized by two calls against them in the Cowboys game — felt bad for the Cowboys on that one, reminiscing on the Johnson would-be game-winning TD that was called back famously years ago against the Chicago Bears.


Bryant was incensed. The Cowboys were stunned. Their defense was unable to stop the Packers thereafter, with Aaron Rodgers making a few clutch throws and his receivers making some great catches, and Green Bay moved onto the NFC title game.

But once more we exit a playoff game with controversy. Our eyes, it seemed, deceived us. What looked like a catch, thanks to the voluminous NFL rulebook, was ruled not so. Brilliance — gutsy, spine-tingling gambling that worked — was denied.

Seems a bit wrong in such a great game.

http://sports.yahoo.com/blogs/nfl-sh...211859169.html

Originally Posted by SmashMouth (Post 637112)

... and the Romo Choke legend continues.

Originally Posted by K Major (Post 637124)

The rule sucks but it was the correct call.
So glad I don't have to watch the Cows another week.

Originally Posted by WhoDat!656 (Post 637113)

How is that play a Romo choke? Bryant is the one that didn't hold onto the ball!!

Originally Posted by ScottF (Post 637136)

.
I don't really care, but I do think Dallas would have zero chance vs Sea
GB will give them a game

Originally Posted by dizzle88 (Post 637139)

Dallas beat Seattle earlier in the season.

Originally Posted by B_Dub_Saint (Post 637115)

I hate the Cowboys, but as a fan of the NFL, the officiating has been horrific.

Originally Posted by lee909 (Post 637163)

All i have to add is


HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
Couldn't happen to a nicer team

Originally Posted by SloMotion (Post 637156)

Agree, and if it was a team/player I liked, I'd probably be more upset, :lol:. I'm beginning to think they somehow reinstated the Replacement Refs from a few seasons ago, :rolleyes: ... maybe it's not that bad, but come on!. There were a few other calls where I kinda' went, "huh?".

Kudos to Mike McCarthy & his staff for the challenge if they did so in the knowledge that Bryant did not make a 'football move' after the catch, yada, yada, yada ... that's a pretty technical assessment to make in real time during the heat of battle. My guess is they just threw the flag out there & hoped for the best, :neutral:.

Couple good points I've heard since last week's fiasco and in this article are: 1) NFL refs are part-time, maybe they should consider full-time refs, 2) "All-Star" officiating crews for the post season aren't getting the job done., 3) the NFL rulebook is too voluminous for refs to properly officiate a game or for the players/coaches/fans to understand. :neutral:.

JMO.

Originally Posted by Beastmode (Post 637235)

The NFL is a reflection of their leadership. Sure, the Pats were within the rules but it was absolutely dirty, no way around it. Who effin does that?

The NFL is slowly digging its own grave on the way they call games. They stick by the rules on some things yet turn a blind eye to other blatant infractions. They have the best cameras in professional sports but refuse to review certain plays, especially in the playoffs.

Originally Posted by Beastmode (Post 637235)

The NFL is a reflection of their leadership. Sure, the Pats were within the rules but it was absolutely dirty, no way around it. Who effin does that?

The NFL is slowly digging its own grave on the way they call games. They stick by the rules on some things yet turn a blind eye to other blatant infractions. They have the best cameras in professional sports but refuse to review certain plays, especially in the playoffs.

Originally Posted by lee909 (Post 637250)

I don't see the Stafford play the same myself.
The team shouldn't switch off and although the Stafford play.

While the NE play is legitimate, its definitely underhand and will be stopped in the post season.
I'd laugh it the Colts did it to them next week

Originally Posted by SloMotion (Post 637247)

Baylor ran that play vs Michigan State in the Cotton Bowl ... IDK if it's dirty in as much as it's a college-level/trick play? Kinda' like how Matt Stafford (DET) signaled in a game earlier in the season that he was gonna' spike the ball to stop the clock & then plunged it in for a TD ... perfectly within the regulations, but was that a dirty play? Or just deceptive? Ironically, that was against the Cowgurlz also, :lol:.

https://dn3pm25xmtlyu.cloudfront.net...VGSUJFNRFZBBTA

Originally Posted by B_Dub_Saint (Post 637115)

I hate the Cowboys, but as a fan of the NFL, the officiating has been horrific.

Originally Posted by VegasSaint9 (Post 637117)

Don't like the Cowboys. Didn't like last weeks call either but they got robbed in this one. How come it always seems Green Bay gets crappy calls in their favor?