Luke Johnson | Taysom vs. Jameis QB battle: Taysom Hill closes on a strong note in 2-minute offense
 

Re: Luke Johnson | Taysom vs. Jameis QB battle: Taysom Hill closes on a strong note in 2-minute offense
 

Ian Book shined too?

Re: Luke Johnson | Taysom vs. Jameis QB battle: Taysom Hill closes on a strong note in 2-minute offense
 

I’m starting to think neither one of these guys are an answer long term. I was high on Winston but so far it seems like same old story hot and cold. If it turns out Winston isn’t the answer I’ll be fine with a gimmicky Hill led offense. Or even dual Qb offense for this year.

Re: Luke Johnson | Taysom vs. Jameis QB battle: Taysom Hill closes on a strong note in 2-minute offense
 

If neither one of them can win the job, give it to Book and see what he's got. Use Hill as a gadget guy and Winston in some packages to mix it up.

I hope preseason shows something.

Re: Luke Johnson | Taysom vs. Jameis QB battle: Taysom Hill closes on a strong note in 2-minute offense
 

QB looks like it will be a tight competition for second place. :wink:

Re: Luke Johnson | Taysom vs. Jameis QB battle: Taysom Hill closes on a strong note in 2-minute offense
 

I think Book will beat out Hill for QB2. Then again, that would partially be because of Hill's value as the Swiss Army knife.

Re: Luke Johnson | Taysom vs. Jameis QB battle: Taysom Hill closes on a strong note in 2-minute offense
 

Ian is going to hold the clip board & sport a backwards baseball cap all season long ... assuming he cracks the final roster.

Re: Luke Johnson | Taysom vs. Jameis QB battle: Taysom Hill closes on a strong note in 2-minute offense
 

Hill, no. Jameis, jury's out but I thought he played well despite leading the 2nd and 3rd string. He went through his progressions, didn't risk too much. Some of those throws were absolute ropes!

Fumble, not his fault. INT, underthrown (slightly) but arguably not his fault and had that been completed we're talking about him as the #1 QB.

Re: Luke Johnson | Taysom vs. Jameis QB battle: Taysom Hill closes on a strong note in 2-minute offense
 

If the Saints organization started Book over Winston and Hill you can guarantee there would be a mass exodus and an increase in trade requests. You’d lose that locker room instantly. The players want Winston as it is. Payton needs to choose leader sooner than later.

Re: Luke Johnson | Taysom vs. Jameis QB battle: Taysom Hill closes on a strong note in 2-minute offense
 

Hill
By far played the best of the two. JW was slow on release and held the ball as long as AB use too. It’s hills to lose at this point. Wouldn’t be surprised it JW is released or traded before the season