we can not win with brooks as our qb.
 

it is not a debate anymore. the giants said to us last night let your qb beat us. we tryed and we got 4 turn overs from the guy. he has a great arm. he is athletic. he is not all there mentally and we will never win with him. saintswhodi you were RIGHT. you have said it and said it, preached it to no end. argued with a lot of us. in the end you are right. he is our best option right now. we basically have no choice but to start the guy. as far as winning though we won't. i could't put my finger on why this offense could't do nothing the last few years. now i know. he threw for 375 yards. only 1 td. we outgained the giants who didn't have 300 total yards. we didn't let up 100 yards rushing. our d did not play great all game but they played well enough for us to win. we should have won. the penalties are not brook's fault. the break down of protection i saw is not his fault. but he had time to throw at different times. we could have won the game. we should have won the game. the only thing i am absolutely sure of is we can't win with brooks. he is inconsistent and so is our team. no wonder in the past when you shut down deuce you beat the saints. because if you shut down deuce brooks has to beat you. you have a 50/50 chance then.

RE: we can not win with brooks as our qb.
 

I think you're wrong.

I don't particularly like AB and I've done my fair share of criticising - he'll get it done this year. Watch.

I think you've said "Just wait, you'll see AB deliver" each of the last 3 years.

AB is really Stevie Wonder without his sunglasses on in the Saints' offense. Wide eyed, head bobbing, goofy, toothy grin - oblivious to the world around him.

But, AB does not design the running schemes. How can a bigger, faster, younger, smarter O-Line get beat up EVERY weekend? Who's in charge of THAT mess?

I think you've said "Just wait, you'll see AB deliver" each of the last 3 years.

AB is really Stevie Wonder without his sunglasses on in the Saints' offense. Wide eyed, head bobbing, goofy, toothy grin - oblivious to the world around him.

But, AB does not design the running schemes. How can a bigger, faster, younger, smarter O-Line get beat up EVERY weekend? Who's in charge of THAT mess?

I've said just wait the last 3 seasons? Was that a "you" meaning WhoDat or a "you" meaning people in general?

Re: RE: we can not win with brooks as our qb.
 

This means more, hearing this from WhoDat (a known Brooks Basher, but someone who at least isn't completely blind to obvious reality), than from others who seemingly hold Aaron Brooks to a higher standard than Favre, Culpepper, Pennington, etc..

This is not the "same old Aaron".

RE: Re: RE: we can not win with brooks as our qb.
 

I too believe we can win with Brooks....but I don't think I've ever seen a QB in the history of me watching this game that makes me laugh and cry in every single game...
Brooks is Brooks and you have to take him in small doses..
I think he'll shake of the loss and have a good year.(maybe great)

AB is really Stevie Wonder without his sunglasses on in the Saints' offense. Wide eyed, head bobbing, goofy, toothy grin - oblivious to the world around him. [/quote]

Classic.

Classic.[/quote]


Did you guys actually watch the game? Or did you put in a tape from 2001? Sounds like you're repeating everything you've ever heard about Brooks, and simply trying to sound funny in the process.

You don't. It would only be funny if it were true.

Man, the Brooks pr machine is in full spin. I love it. Keep it up Gambler. :D