CheramieIII

E. Manning 10 for 18 113 yards 55.6 passer rating 4 sacked 0 TD's 3 Int's

and they lost 23 to 0 at home, damn now that's an assssssssss whippin!!

JOESAM2002

Don't be to quick to judge him there Cheramie. Remember he's just getting started. This kids gonna be real good! Mark my words.

sarge06

I have to agree. I expect that he will at least be in the same neighborhood as his brother soon.

CheramieIII

I was only giving everyone **** for saying Leinhart was rated higher than Eli and trying to make the point that if Mel rates a QB higher than a pile of shiiiiitttt, it doesn't mean anything more than his opinion.

sarge06

Im just saying that I would take that pile of s**t anyday. And if Linehart is as good or better then please take him

papz

I've always thought Kiper was a load. Eli still lead his team into the playoffs, he'll be fine. It's hard to compare Eli to Leinart, two different players at completely different programs. We don't know Eli would have done with better talent and Leinart would have done with less.

Milians

Thats good for the Giants. Those bastards with their nine home games deserved that beating. And for the record, no one is in the same league as Peyton, let alone neighborhood. Eli has a ways to go before he can even think about carrying his brother's jock-strap. The Giants didn't win their division because of him, but rather in spite of him.

hagan714

Not bad for second year QB. They will be drafting and signing FA offensive line this year for him. Thier defense has a solid foundation and that has kept them alive to this point. Getting the point?

sarge06

Sorry pal Tiki Barber kept them alive

CheramieIII

I did about the DEFENSE and all!