Current Saints Roster with Analysis

LKelley67 · 03-28-2006, 10:45 AM

response-

OT- Gandy looked like grandpa to me too. Expensive now too. However, I will trust the FO talent evaluation whether he has any gas left or is worth the price. Ditto for Stinch. If they say either is a worthy starter then the draft outlook is much different. If not a OT is needed in the first 2 rounds fo sho.

CB- dunno about if 2th weakest but definitely needs upgrade with FA and/or draft whether Smith move is viable or not

DT- agreed, FA stoppers are disappearing. Need a Wroten or better on draft day

WR- is light on depth. Will be interesting to see how many "drops" there are bringing in a QB with more than one gear in the touch dept. A big inside posession guy would be ideal.

OG- Holland is tendered. Staying here unless someone offered something we felt to wacky to match. Mayberry is much like Gandy IMO. I'll let the FO make the call. He is a center option too.

I would add-

C- No mention of the position that we only have a questionable G to play. Need somebody!

LB- One good solid journeyman signed in Fujita. Simmons is a giant boom or bust story. McKinnon is ancient and hasn't been resigned. He could stop the run but was useless on pass coverage. Should be able to get at least one decent player out of youngsters Watson, Fincher, and Bock. Impact player here would transform D

K- Only more downhill ahead for Carney I believe. Edinger and Josh Brown would be upgrades IMO. At least bring in some legitimate camp competition.

QB- One extremely good but yet to be proven again QB. A veteran backup needed badly, just in case. Maddox, Banks, and Wright are all proven not break the bank options.

what's left? LOL a Pro Bowl punter, good RB depth, and solid DEs.

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Switch to Linear Mode Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

03-28-2006, 10:45 AM	#1
LKelley67 1000 Posts + Join Date: Jan 2005 Location: baton rouge Posts: 2,540	response- OT- Gandy looked like grandpa to me too. Expensive now too. However, I will trust the FO talent evaluation whether he has any gas left or is worth the price. Ditto for Stinch. If they say either is a worthy starter then the draft outlook is much different. If not a OT is needed in the first 2 rounds fo sho. CB- dunno about if 2th weakest but definitely needs upgrade with FA and/or draft whether Smith move is viable or not DT- agreed, FA stoppers are disappearing. Need a Wroten or better on draft day WR- is light on depth. Will be interesting to see how many "drops" there are bringing in a QB with more than one gear in the touch dept. A big inside posession guy would be ideal. OG- Holland is tendered. Staying here unless someone offered something we felt to wacky to match. Mayberry is much like Gandy IMO. I'll let the FO make the call. He is a center option too. I would add- C- No mention of the position that we only have a questionable G to play. Need somebody! LB- One good solid journeyman signed in Fujita. Simmons is a giant boom or bust story. McKinnon is ancient and hasn't been resigned. He could stop the run but was useless on pass coverage. Should be able to get at least one decent player out of youngsters Watson, Fincher, and Bock. Impact player here would transform D K- Only more downhill ahead for Carney I believe. Edinger and Josh Brown would be upgrades IMO. At least bring in some legitimate camp competition. QB- One extremely good but yet to be proven again QB. A veteran backup needed badly, just in case. Maddox, Banks, and Wright are all proven not break the bank options. what's left? LOL a Pro Bowl punter, good RB depth, and solid DEs.