CheramieIII

great analysis and picks, even the kicker. It wasn't Serna but I'm happy about it all.

NolaBama

I love Ellis and give the pick a A+.

I think Porter is a nice pick, I would rate it a solid B because of some questions about his toughness, the ?'s about his tackling are silly, he had 80+tackles last season.

Pressley is another young beast in the middle to add PRESSURE to the opposing OB which we all know will go a long way in improving our secondary. I rate the pick a solid B.

Nicks is a beast, he is 6'5" and a house of a man, if he is coached up he could be our starting RT this season, I grade it an A.

Mehlhaff, I rate this an F, I think we could have scooped him in FA. This pick should have been an OLB or S.

Just my 2 cents....Steveo

FireVenturi

Ellis-A

Porter-A

Pressley-B

Nicks-A+

Kicker-C

Arrington-B

Overall draft-A minus

jergensl

i am very happy with this draft...
the kicker is questionable, but besides that i think the saints came away with possibly 3-5 players that could be starting by the end of the year (ellis, porter, pressley, nicks and mehlhaff)...ellis and nicks will start by the end of the year

FireVenturi

I think Ellis will start in game one against Tampa!

jtsaints

Why you so high on nicks which i like and whos job do you think he takes?

hagan714

No ones jog this year. Stinch is a UFA after next year. Lets see what happens. Besides I see him doing time at OG also. Next year at the latest I think we will see the OL suffled around. Good pick

shortlaw

If the kicker turns out to end our inconsistency since we let Carney leave, then I'll give it a B. No one was suprised that he was drafted, just that he was the first kicker off the board.