Officiating

skymike · 12-29-2010, 04:10 PM

tell you what i hated seeing. the vikings were robbed last night by replay. #18 clearly made a perfect endzone catch, got his feet in, but was robbed by super slo-mo which showed the ball wiggling several atoms the size of an amoeba's balls .0000003 of a half inch, which they said meant he didnt have control. He caught the damn thing, and ended up with it. In the back yard, thats a freakin catch. Replay did exactly the same thing to Eric martin in 1988. Proves my point that all replay is, besides a delay of game, is a 2nd chance for the refs to screw up.

this is a wacky opinion, and nobody will agree with me, but we lived for years without it, and did fine. i know Im crazy. I also dont need a helmet to ride a bicycle.

WhoDat!656 · 12-29-2010, 06:26 PM

Originally Posted by skymike

tell you what i hated seeing. the vikings were robbed last night by replay. #18 clearly made a perfect endzone catch, got his feet in, but was robbed by super slo-mo which showed the ball wiggling several atoms the size of an amoeba's balls .0000003 of a half inch, which they said meant he didnt have control. He caught the damn thing, and ended up with it. In the back yard, thats a freakin catch. Replay did exactly the same thing to Eric martin in 1988. Proves my point that all replay is, besides a delay of game, is a 2nd chance for the refs to screw up.

this is a wacky opinion, and nobody will agree with me, but we lived for years without it, and did fine. i know Im crazy. I also dont need a helmet to ride a bicycle.

Penalties need to be added to what can be challenged. We have all watched games and a players number is called and that player was on the sidelines.

If a defender was held, and by it not being called,the QB completed a pass for a TD or 1st down, that should be challengeable.

skymike · 12-29-2010, 06:32 PM

Originally Posted by WhoDat!656

If a defender was held, and by it not being called,the QB completed a pass for a TD or 1st down, that should be challengeable.

So you want to expand replay?. uugh.

alright, this is America.

so anyway, WD656, what going on in the 318 tonight??? Im hungry for some poor people food, I know that.

12-29-2010, 06:26 PM	#2
WhoDat!656 10000 POST CLUB Join Date: Nov 2010 Location: Shreveport,Louisiana Posts: 16,097	Originally Posted by skymike tell you what i hated seeing. the vikings were robbed last night by replay. #18 clearly made a perfect endzone catch, got his feet in, but was robbed by super slo-mo which showed the ball wiggling several atoms the size of an amoeba's balls .0000003 of a half inch, which they said meant he didnt have control. He caught the damn thing, and ended up with it. In the back yard, thats a freakin catch. Replay did exactly the same thing to Eric martin in 1988. Proves my point that all replay is, besides a delay of game, is a 2nd chance for the refs to screw up. this is a wacky opinion, and nobody will agree with me, but we lived for years without it, and did fine. i know Im crazy. I also dont need a helmet to ride a bicycle. Penalties need to be added to what can be challenged. We have all watched games and a players number is called and that player was on the sidelines. If a defender was held, and by it not being called,the QB completed a pass for a TD or 1st down, that should be challengeable.

12-29-2010, 06:32 PM	#3
skymike E. Side Cholo Join Date: Sep 2008 Location: The Barrio, H-town Posts: 6,089	Originally Posted by WhoDat!656 If a defender was held, and by it not being called,the QB completed a pass for a TD or 1st down, that should be challengeable. So you want to expand replay?. uugh. alright, this is America. so anyway, WD656, what going on in the 318 tonight??? Im hungry for some poor people food, I know that.

12-29-2010, 04:10 PM	#1
skymike E. Side Cholo Join Date: Sep 2008 Location: The Barrio, H-town Posts: 6,089	tell you what i hated seeing. the vikings were robbed last night by replay. #18 clearly made a perfect endzone catch, got his feet in, but was robbed by super slo-mo which showed the ball wiggling several atoms the size of an amoeba's balls .0000003 of a half inch, which they said meant he didnt have control. He caught the damn thing, and ended up with it. In the back yard, thats a freakin catch. Replay did exactly the same thing to Eric martin in 1988. Proves my point that all replay is, besides a delay of game, is a 2nd chance for the refs to screw up. this is a wacky opinion, and nobody will agree with me, but we lived for years without it, and did fine. i know Im crazy. I also dont need a helmet to ride a bicycle.