WhoDat

Everyone has his own opinion about Aaron Brooks and this is quite obviously one of the hottest topics on this board. Apparently, Saintfan and I represent the two most opposing views on Aaron. So I suggest that Saintfan and I sound off and each express our opinion about Brooks. Then everyone can at least hear some of the most fervent opinions on both sides of the fence about the Saints starting quarterback.

Now, I do want this to stay clean, so I will suggest some ground rules. I do not know Saintfan as a person, but I am sure he is a bright guy. While I disagree with his opinions about Brooks, I agree with other things he has said, and the bottom line here is that we're all Saints fans.

So, Saintfan, I guarantee that I will not take potshots at your character or at you as a person. Your opinion is just as valid as mine and I want us to be able to debate without attacking one another. Second, let's keep everyone other than Brooks out of this discussion. Other Saints, coaches, back up quarterback, media men, mickey mouse, every other person in the world. This is about Brooks. Let's talk about what we feel he can and cannot do. What do you say?