After 2014, Brees should be traded

halloween 65 · 04-04-2015, 07:48 AM

Originally Posted by arsaint

He finished with a 97.0 QB rating after all.

Do you know just how bad that is compared with previous Saints QBs and their best efforts in the black & gold???

Billy Kilmer 74.9 in 1969
Archie Manning 81.8 in 1980
Ken Stabler 71.8 in 1981
Dave Wilson 83.9 in 1984
Bobby Hebert 82.9 in 1987 and 1992
Wade Wilson 87.2 in 1994
Jim "Chris" Everett 87.0 in 1995
Mike Ditka's QB cluster 83.5 (Tolliver) in 1998
Aaron Brooks 88.8 in 2003

Yep, it's painfully obvious that we would be smart to dump Brees and go back to our normal QB carousel...

In all fairness if you put some of those qb.'s behind Brees O-line and Brees behind theirs, Brees would be much, much, lower and theirs especially Archie's would be much higher.
Kilmer- a good qb. that in those years the run was dominate.
Archie- to me, hall of famer, never to even get a sniff in Canton. Any decent team might have won a Superbowl with him. Not being a homer here just looking a a truely talented qb. that wasted away on a sad team year in and year out.
Stabler- washed up when we got him.
Wilson- nothing flashy but solid for the O we ran.
Heber- trader that talked a better game than he played.
Everett- I really don't know what to think about him.
Ditkas cluster- was just that
Brooks- punk, makes me sick til today. Many times I would wish a blitzing lb. would decapatate his head from his body.

04-04-2015, 07:48 AM	#33
halloween 65 5000 POSTS! + Join Date: Sep 2011 Location: Grand Haven, Michigan by way of a little Mississippi River town in Louisiana Posts: 5,893	Re: After 2014, Brees should be traded Originally Posted by arsaint He finished with a 97.0 QB rating after all. Do you know just how bad that is compared with previous Saints QBs and their best efforts in the black & gold??? Billy Kilmer 74.9 in 1969 Archie Manning 81.8 in 1980 Ken Stabler 71.8 in 1981 Dave Wilson 83.9 in 1984 Bobby Hebert 82.9 in 1987 and 1992 Wade Wilson 87.2 in 1994 Jim "Chris" Everett 87.0 in 1995 Mike Ditka's QB cluster 83.5 (Tolliver) in 1998 Aaron Brooks 88.8 in 2003 Yep, it's painfully obvious that we would be smart to dump Brees and go back to our normal QB carousel... In all fairness if you put some of those qb.'s behind Brees O-line and Brees behind theirs, Brees would be much, much, lower and theirs especially Archie's would be much higher. Kilmer- a good qb. that in those years the run was dominate. Archie- to me, hall of famer, never to even get a sniff in Canton. Any decent team might have won a Superbowl with him. Not being a homer here just looking a a truely talented qb. that wasted away on a sad team year in and year out. Stabler- washed up when we got him. Wilson- nothing flashy but solid for the O we ran. Heber- trader that talked a better game than he played. Everett- I really don't know what to think about him. Ditkas cluster- was just that Brooks- punk, makes me sick til today. Many times I would wish a blitzing lb. would decapatate his head from his body.

LinkBacks (?) LinkBack to this Thread: https://blackandgold.com/saints/71785-after-2014-brees-should-traded.html
Posted By	For	Type	Date	Hits
The Latest New Orleans Saints News \| SportSpyder	This thread	Refback	04-01-2015 03:01 PM	5
After 2014, Brees should be traded	This thread	Refback	04-01-2015 02:46 PM	10