saintswhodi

Let me just add also that ONLY on a Saints forum could you get away with even comparing AB to Peyton Manning. I\'d like to see anyone play this argument out elsewhere. I can start a poll on another forum with fans from all teams and see how they stack up head to head if anyone would like.

GumboBC

I can give you a link to articles from the national media and from Indianapolis that call Petyon a choke artist in the playoffs.

I\'ve visited some Colts boards and many Colts fans lay the playoff losses on Peyton. Just as you blame Brooks for all of our losses...

Wanna bet?

saintswhodi

Go to those same boards and ask them if they wanna trade Peyton for AB. Please please please please I am begging you to do that. Then post the results here. Please. Just ask them. I would LOVE for you to do that. Please. I don\'t beg for much, but I am BEGGING you to do that.

GumboBC

I\'ve never said Brooks was better than Peyton. Where in the world did you get that from?

And Brooks really has nothing to do with this.

I\'m using your arguement that if you\'ve got the talent on offense then the QB has NO excuse for his team losing.

While Peyton has put up eye-popping stats, in the playoffs he hasn\'t done good. And that\'s putting it mildly. EVERY year Peyton and the offense plays terrible and the Colts lose.

So, despite the FACT that Peyton is surrounded by the best offensive talent in the NFL, he loses and they lose by VERY BIG MARGINS.

Why do you think that is saintwhodi?

And leave Brooks out of it?

Give me a straight answer?

saintswhodi

Could it be cause they play the Patriots who are 33-4 over the last 3 years? How much do you wanna bet 3 of those 4 losses came on the road and not at Foxboro in the winter? I would say possibly all 4 are on the road. Think that could have anything to do with it? Of course not right. Peyton has playoff RECORDS, how the hell can you really say he chokes in the playoffs? He is losing to the Superbowl Champs and a team considered a dynasty. He crushes EVERYONE else. Be for real.

And do you think they have talent on offense BECAUSE of Peyton? Trade Stallworth to Indy and he is Reggie Wayne. Trade Reggie Wayne here and he is Stallworth. Peyton completes OVER 60% of his passes ya know and reads a defense just about better than anyone in the league.

Let\'s look at Peyton\'s OVERALL playoff numbers:

2004. 696 yards 4 TDs 2 INTs Completing over 70% of his passes. That\'s without even looking at the stats from 2003 playoffs which were record setting.

I also knew you wouldn\'t back up your statements with action outside of this forum. Just wanted to see how much you believed in what you were saying. Not much apparently.

spkb25

i\'d have to go with brady