Best back in NFL
 

He\'s lost his 1st gear and his top gear because of that weight gain. Those were his bread and butter his first few years. Until he gets those back I have him around 13.
Are we rating them on what they\'ve done over the last 3 years? I didn\'t read it that way. In that case he\'s around 5.

Isn\'t that kinda exactly what I said?
There\'s that big IF again. Hmmm, we sure are qualifying Deuce posts with a lot of IF\'s aren\'t we. ;)
Insert \"IF\" analogy here.

Best back in NFL
 

tomlinson
alexander
lewis
james
deuce/green
holmes
martin maybe only for another year
dillon
taylor

Best back in NFL
 

Tomlinson
Holmes
Alexander
Lewis
Green
Dillon
Deuce
Portis
James
Taylor

Best back in NFL
 

Alexander
L. T.
Green
Deuce
Portis

Best back in NFL
 

if i could have one for a fantasy player next year only i would pick in order-
tomlinson
holmes
alexander
lewis
dillon
green
portis
deuce
james
taylor
martin

building a team to have rb for a while-
tomlinson
alexander
portis
lewis
deuce
green

Best back in NFL
 

Since I have to watch Green a lot, I may under-rate him a little bit, but I have to say that I firmly believe he is not a top five back.

Here\'s mine:
1. L.Tomlinson
2. P. Holmes
3. S. Alexander
4. C. Portis
5. C. Dillon
6. Duece
7. C. Portis
8. A Green
9. E. James
10. J. Lewis

Best back in NFL
 

1. Jamal Lewis
2. Tomlinson
3. Ahman Green
4. S. Alexander
5. Decue
6. Priest Holmes
7. Portis
8. Dillion
9. Edge James
10. Curtis Martin

Best back in NFL
 

The list is pretty subjective -- are we to list based on talent or production last year -- or production over the course of their career -- or importance to the team. I would have a different list for each -- But without listing - I cannot see how any list would not have Priest Holmes in the top 5 (if not number 2). I also agree with whomever said to put Vick in at number 2