Kurt Warner vs. Peyton Manning
 

Kurt Warner was able to lead his team to 2 super bowls and he won one of them.

Peyton Manning, well ....... let's just say he hasn't done as well as Warner in the playoffs.

Both the Rams and Colts never had great defenses, but Warner still led his team to the promised land. TWICE !!

Why can't Peyton do what Warner did?

Let me hear it folks? :o

Kurt Warner vs. Peyton Manning
 

Half decent defense maybe? My grandmother can score on the Colts.

Kurt Warner vs. Peyton Manning
 

...because the AFC has the Patriots and the NFC doesn\'t?

Kurt Warner vs. Peyton Manning
 

and the Colts scored on your grandmother.

that\'s funny

[Edited on 6/4/2005 by BlackandBlue]

Kurt Warner vs. Peyton Manning
 

At least is wasn\'t old Ron Mexico.

Kurt Warner vs. Peyton Manning
 

Yeah, don\'t want ol\' Ron (Jeremy) Mexico putting the moves on granny.

Oh, the horror...

Kurt Warner vs. Peyton Manning
 

The Rams defense was ranked FIFTH in the league the last time they went to the Super Bowl. It was in the top 10, or so when they beat the Titans. Indy has consistently been in the bottom half of the league.

Additionally, Edge is nowhere near the RB that Faulk was at that time. To beat the Colts you stop Manning. To beat the Rams it used to be you stopped Faulk.

Kurt Warner vs. Peyton Manning
 

...because the AFC has the Patriots and the NFC doesn\'t??

Kurt Warner vs. Peyton Manning
 

The stadium ...... ;)

Same way Young had trouble freezing his nuts off in Green Bay .....

Kurt Warner vs. Peyton Manning
 

Why can\'t AB lead us to anything past a wild card game -- Warner did it without a defense