K Major

Jim Kelly outside the top 10?

dam1953

Leaving Brees off of any list chaps my butt. He own's about every personal passing record in the books. By the time he retires, he will own them all.. Under Brees, the Saint's have consistently been a top 5 offense, even when they had no running game to speak of.

The only reason he doesn't have 3 or 4 rings is because he doesn't play defense. If he did, they would just figure out some other way of keeping him off of their lists.

hitta

I'm of the opinion that anyone that leaves Brees out of the top 5 either brain damage, has a bias against a small market, or has a bias against Brees. I've heard some extremely ridiculous arguments: (ball has more zip on it coming out of other QBs hands; football is a team sport...and Brees doesn't make his team better; Brees doesn't have championships). It's like people just don't want to include him on the list for some unknown reason. They'll say that Brees shouldn't be on the list cause he has only 1 Superbowl, but then they'll say that Marino should be on the list. Then when it is brought up that Marino doesn't have a superbowl, they'll change the entire frame of their argument to something else. They don't want to admit that Brees is great and they have no logical reason why.