Colston wouldn't have been given a chance under that scenario. I feel players should get playing time based upon how well they can do their jobs. Who cares what round or how many picks they cost? You put your best team on the field. Round drafted should be forgotten and not come into play when deciding play. That is short-sighted, don't you think?

And you're wrong, Muhammad did develop as he was for the Colts what Trey What's His Name (As you so disrespectfully refer) Hendrickson-role

To be fair, Muhammad hasn't exactly lit the world on fire these past three seasons with the Colts.

I watched couple of their games last season, and he was very ineffective against both the passing and running game.

I don't think we'd be excited if the Saints signed a FA with his stats, and more importantly, his performance on the field.

Whew, alright, let's do it this way...

So would y'all agree these are the most successful picks in the respective draft classes of the Sean Payton/Mickey Loomis tenure?


2006 Draft

• RB Reggie Bush, R1
  
  
• SS Roman Harper, R2 (Via Trade Back, Gained C Jeff Faine)
  
  
• RG Jahri Evans, R4 (Via Trade Back, Gained NT Hollis Thomas)
  
  
• DE Rob Ninkovich, R5
  
  
• RT Zach Strief, R7
  
  
• WR Marques Colston, R7 (*Compensatory)

2007 Draft Class

• LT Jermon Bushrod, R4 (Via Trade of WR Donte Stallworth; If PHI re-signed DS, it'd been a R2 pick)
  

2008 Draft Class

• DT Sedrick Ellis, R1 (Via Trade)
  
  
• CB Tracy Porter, R2
  
  
• LG Carl Nicks, R5 (Via Trade)

2009 Draft Class

• CB Malcolm Jenkins, R1
  
  
• P Thomas Morstead, R5 (Via Trade)

2010 Draft Class

• CB Patrick Robinson, R1
  
  
• TE Jimmy Graham, R3

2011 Draft Class

• DE Cameron Jordan, R1
  
  
• RB Mark Ingram Jr, R1 (Via Trade)

2012 Draft Class

• DT Akiem Hicks, R3

2013 Draft Class

• SS Kenny Vaccaro, R1
  
  
• LT Terron Armstead, R3
  
  
• WR Kenny Stills, R5

2014 Draft Class

• WR Brandin Cooks, R1 (Via Trade)

2015 Draft Class

• LT Andrus Peat, R1
  
  
• CB P. J. Williams, R3 (Via Trade of Kenny Stills, Also Gained LB Dannell Ellerbe)
  
  
• NT Tyeler Davison, R5 (Via Trade of Ben Grubbs)

2016 Draft Class

• DT Sheldon Rankins, R1
  
  
• WR Michael Thomas, R2
  
  
• SS Vonn Bell, R2 (Via Trade)
  
  
• DT David Onyemata, R4 (Via Trade with WAS)

2017 Draft Class

• CB Marshon Lattimore, R1
  
  
• LT Ryan Ramcyzk, R1 (Via Trade of Jimmy Graham)
  
  
• FS Marcus Williams, R2
  
  
• RB Alvin Kamara, R3 (Via Trade)
  
  
• LB Alex Anzalone, R3
  
  
• DE Trey Hendrickson, R3 (*Compensatory)
  
  
• DE Al-Quadin Muhammad, R6

2018 Draft Class

• DE Marcus Davenport, R1 (Via Trade)
  
  
• WR Tre'Quan Smith, R3
  
  
• RB Boston Scott, R6
  
  
• OL Will Clapp, R7

2019 Draft Class

• C Erik McCoy, R2 (Via Trade)
  
  
• SS C. J. Gardner, R4 (Via Trade)
  
  
• LB Kaden Elliss, R7

2020 Draft Class

• C Cesar Ruiz, R1
  
  
• LB Zack Baun, R3 (Via Trade)
  
  
• TE Adam Trautman, R3 (Via Trade)
  
  
• QB Tommy Stevens, R7 (Via Trade)

Do you feel some have been left off that should be on the list as they were successful picks?

We'll come to UDFAs later, we're debating draft picks and there value for now, agreed?

That's 30 successful picks in the first three rounds. Then there's 15 listed from the final four rounds of which possibly eight can be called mildly successful or better. Those numbers are right around the league average. The success rate of picks after round three are historically much lower than those from the earlier rounds.

Throwing more later round picks at the wall might provide another success or two, but it would also result in many times more misses. Using those picks, instead, to move up into the first three rounds would give the team a much higher chance of individual success. You can still find the "diamonds in the rough", like Granderson, via UDFA.

A perfect example of volume of picks versus quality of picks can be seen with the Vikings. Since 2010 the Vikings have had more than the normally allotted seven draft picks every single year by trading down and accumulating more picks.

2010 8
2011 10
2012 10
2013 9
2014 10
2015 10
2016 8
2017 11
2018 8
2019 12
2020 15
2021 11

That's 122 picks over twelve years. They have only managed 13 Pro Bowl players over that period. What they did end up with is a lengthy list of players that are currently out of the league. Only 42 of those 122 have started at least one game. They have managed only four years with over eight wins, four playoff visits and only two playoff wins (yes, we know those two wins well).

That's 30 successful picks in the first three rounds. Then there's 15 listed from the final four rounds of which possibly eight can be called mildly successful or better. Those numbers are right around the league average. The success rate of picks after round three are historically much lower than those from the earlier rounds.

Throwing more later round picks at the wall might provide another success or two, but it would also result in many times more misses. Using those picks, instead, to move up into the first three rounds would give the team a much higher chance of individual success. You can still find the "diamonds in the rough", like Granderson, via UDFA.

A perfect example of volume of picks versus quality of picks can be seen with the Vikings. Since 2010 the Vikings have had more than the normally allotted seven draft picks every single year by trading down and accumulating more picks.

2010 8
2011 10
2012 10
2013 9
2014 10
2015 10
2016 8
2017 11
2018 8
2019 12
2020 15
2021 11

That's 122 picks over twelve years. They have only managed 13 Pro Bowl players over that period. What they did end up with is a lengthy list of players that are currently out of the league. Only 42 of those 122 have started at least one game. They have managed only four years with over eight wins, four playoff visits and only two playoff wins (yes, we know those two wins well).

Well, assign All-Pro recognitions based on Day drafted...

Then, pull the best player from each draft class, which day was that player drafted?